Re: Licensing questions regarding distribution of the raspberry pi platform bundled with proprietary software

2015-06-23 Thread Paul Wise
On Wed, Jun 24, 2015 at 5:28 AM, Charles MacKay wrote:

> What legal grounds do I need to adhere by to make sure that is legal for me
> to sell my raspberry pi system and software bundled with it to others?

Anything from Debian main should be legal to distribute as long as you
also distribute the source packages.

Since you are using a Debian derivative and not using Debian, you'll
need to review the parts that have been added to or changed from
Debian. The Raspbian people can probably tell you about their policies
but I imagine that Raspbian main has the same policy as Debian main.
So you should check if any packages not from Raspbian main are
installed and review their copyright information.

https://www.raspbian.org/

To make things more complicated, as I understand it, the Raspbian
images distributed by Raspberry Pi are modified from the Rasbian
distributed by Rasbian themselves. I personally don't know what
changes were made, hopefully the Raspberry Pi folks will answer you.

-- 
bye,
pabs

https://wiki.debian.org/PaulWise


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-legal-requ...@lists.debian.org
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org
Archive: 
https://lists.debian.org/CAKTje6H3-xTmtVKsWLimh_ow6EGzeuAS5FpuWqZ=yoae8zp...@mail.gmail.com



Re: Licensing questions regarding distribution of the raspberry pi platform bundled with proprietary software

2015-06-23 Thread Riley Baird
> I am creating a video streaming platform using the Raspberry Pi. I have
> wrote software that captures video and streams it to a server using OpenCV.
> The client then can monitor the video feed using a computer, or smartphone.
> OpenCV uses the FreeBSD license, and my code is running on Raspbian, a
> Debian distribution, using the raspberry pi 2.
> 
> However, there are many other bundled packages that are included with the
> Raspbian image, such as python, java, and other software I'm not using. It
> is required to remove these packages before distributing the system, or is
> the Raspbian image itself GPL compliant?
> 
> What legal grounds do I need to adhere by to make sure that is legal for me
> to sell my raspberry pi system and software bundled with it to others?

Firstly, this is not legal advice. If you're doing something
this significant, you should see an attorney that knows the law with
regards to intellectual property in your jurisdiction.

Secondly, DFSG 9 is "License Must Not Contaminate Other Software".

Thirdly, you can sell GPL software anyway, even for profit, without
asking for permission. Look at how many people sell Debian CDs:
https://www.debian.org/CD/vendors/


pgpPvalASLfOU.pgp
Description: PGP signature


Licensing questions regarding distribution of the raspberry pi platform bundled with proprietary software

2015-06-23 Thread Charles MacKay
Hello,

I am creating a video streaming platform using the Raspberry Pi. I have
wrote software that captures video and streams it to a server using OpenCV.
The client then can monitor the video feed using a computer, or smartphone.
OpenCV uses the FreeBSD license, and my code is running on Raspbian, a
Debian distribution, using the raspberry pi 2.

However, there are many other bundled packages that are included with the
Raspbian image, such as python, java, and other software I'm not using. It
is required to remove these packages before distributing the system, or is
the Raspbian image itself GPL compliant?

What legal grounds do I need to adhere by to make sure that is legal for me
to sell my raspberry pi system and software bundled with it to others?

Thank you,
Charles