Re: Bug#321102: data-loss still possible with kmail 3.5.2
Le Mer 17 Mai 2006 05:30, Adam Porter a écrit : On Tuesday 16 May 2006 11:03, Christopher Martin wrote: Perhaps a better solution would be disable dimap support in the 3.5.3 upload, and make sure that the fixed package makes Etch (which is looming). Daniel, what do you feel about this? Given that upstream appears to be unable to replicate and fix the problem, I think this might be the safest, and least bothersome (to all other KMail users) way of dealing with this issue. Personally, I'd be disappointed if this was done. I know the bug is present, but I rely on KMail's dimap support for my mail. I switched from Thunderbird because of Thunderbird's lousy, buggy dimap support. KMail's is superb, other than this bug (which hasn't hit me yet). this is not acceptable for our users. I'm in favor of disabling dimap until that bug really disappears as well. -- ·O· Pierre Habouzit ··O[EMAIL PROTECTED] OOOhttp://www.madism.org pgp66Vx9kF0XA.pgp Description: PGP signature
Bug#321102: data-loss still possible with kmail 3.5.2
So here it is, someone confirmed this bug with 3.5.2 on Debian: http://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=104956 Quote: Bam! I had this bug right now. Using KDE 3.5.2 on Debian. Lost a whole folder of mails (thank god it was only a ML). Nevertheless this is totally uncool... Whoever marked this bug as found in $VERSION should upgrade this to the newest version too or remove it completely (we know this bug is open for years and there is IMHO reason to track every version-number the bug appeared). And please consider to remove KMail from testing again. There is nothing stable about losing a whole Mail-Folder. Especially when we *know* the software leads to data loss but pretend it to be stable. Best regards, Bastian -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] with a subject of unsubscribe. Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Bug#321102: data-loss still possible with kmail 3.5.2
found 321102 4:3.5.2-1 found 332473 4:3.5.2-1 found 350851 4:3.5.2-1 stop On Tuesday 16 May 2006 10:05, Bastian Venthur wrote: So here it is, someone confirmed this bug with 3.5.2 on Debian: http://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=104956 Quote: Bam! I had this bug right now. Using KDE 3.5.2 on Debian. Lost a whole folder of mails (thank god it was only a ML). Nevertheless this is totally uncool... Darn, I thought that perhaps it had gone away. Whoever marked this bug as found in $VERSION should upgrade this to the newest version too or remove it completely (we know this bug is open for years and there is IMHO reason to track every version-number the bug appeared). I have added the founds for this version for the sake of clarity, but it isn't necessary to mark founds for every last upload; the bug is assumed to be present by the BTS unless marked fixed. And please consider to remove KMail from testing again. There is nothing stable about losing a whole Mail-Folder. Especially when we *know* the software leads to data loss but pretend it to be stable. Perhaps a better solution would be disable dimap support in the 3.5.3 upload, and make sure that the fixed package makes Etch (which is looming). Daniel, what do you feel about this? Given that upstream appears to be unable to replicate and fix the problem, I think this might be the safest, and least bothersome (to all other KMail users) way of dealing with this issue. Cheers, Christopher Martin pgpEuMHg3zIEy.pgp Description: PGP signature
Processed: Re: Bug#321102: data-loss still possible with kmail 3.5.2
Processing commands for [EMAIL PROTECTED]: found 321102 4:3.5.2-1 Bug#321102: kmail looses mails Bug#332473: kmail: dangerous handling of dimap-folders Bug#350851: kmail: v1.9.1: Data loss w/disconnected IMAP (reported upstream) Bug marked as found in version 4:3.5.2-1. found 332473 4:3.5.2-1 Bug#332473: kmail: dangerous handling of dimap-folders Bug#321102: kmail looses mails Bug#350851: kmail: v1.9.1: Data loss w/disconnected IMAP (reported upstream) Bug marked as found in version 4:3.5.2-1. found 350851 4:3.5.2-1 Bug#350851: kmail: v1.9.1: Data loss w/disconnected IMAP (reported upstream) Bug#321102: kmail looses mails Bug#332473: kmail: dangerous handling of dimap-folders Bug marked as found in version 4:3.5.2-1. stop Stopping processing here. Please contact me if you need assistance. Debian bug tracking system administrator (administrator, Debian Bugs database) -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] with a subject of unsubscribe. Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Bug#321102: data-loss still possible with kmail 3.5.2
On Tuesday 16 May 2006 11:03, Christopher Martin wrote: Perhaps a better solution would be disable dimap support in the 3.5.3 upload, and make sure that the fixed package makes Etch (which is looming). Daniel, what do you feel about this? Given that upstream appears to be unable to replicate and fix the problem, I think this might be the safest, and least bothersome (to all other KMail users) way of dealing with this issue. Personally, I'd be disappointed if this was done. I know the bug is present, but I rely on KMail's dimap support for my mail. I switched from Thunderbird because of Thunderbird's lousy, buggy dimap support. KMail's is superb, other than this bug (which hasn't hit me yet). By the way, you referred to the fixed package. As far as I'm aware, this bug isn't about to be fixed. A comment was made on the KDE Bugzilla that really fixing it would require a restructuring of the IMAP backend/kioslave. Did I miss something? I sure hope so, cause I'd love for this bug to be truly fixed. pgpIMq14nkt4a.pgp Description: PGP signature
