Re: Package selection for bugreport (suspend, BIOS option, Interrupt remapping)

2019-08-22 Thread Henrique de Moraes Holschuh
On Thu, Aug 22, 2019, at 07:26, Johan Kröckel wrote:
> my system (Thinkstation c20) does not wake up from suspend to ram when 
> "Interrupt remapping" is enabled in BIOS. Took me some time to find the 
> problem and I wanted to report a bug. Towards which package should I report 
> it?
> System is Buster.

Well, it is a BIOS+kernel issue.

This is a X58 or 5520 chipset system (tylesburg 36D) according to @lenovo.com.

Interrupt remapping is non-functional on these systems due to chipset errata 
(read: hardware defect). Do not enable it, unless you know for sure you have a 
fixed stepping of the chipset (note that I am not sure such a fixed stepping 
was ever released). 

As for where to file a bug, well, the Linux kernel apparently is not 
force-disabling interrupt remapping on resume.  If it is doing so on boot, it 
is a kernel bug to not do so on resume...

That said, please make sure you have the latest version of the thinkstation c20 
firmware (BIOS, etc).  It is a BIOS bug to even offer to enable interrupt 
remapping on a non-fixed version of the chipset in the first place.

--
 Henrique de Moraes Holschuh 



Package selection for bugreport (suspend, BIOS option, Interrupt remapping)

2019-08-22 Thread Johan Kröckel
Hi,
my system (Thinkstation c20) does not wake up from suspend to ram when
"Interrupt remapping" is enabled in BIOS. Took me some time to find the
problem and I wanted to report a bug. Towards which package should I report
it?
System is Buster.

Regards Johan