Bug#155626: ITP: exiscan -- An email virus scanner for the exim MTA

2002-08-07 Thread David Schmitt
Hi Gerfrid, folks!

On Tue, Aug 06, 2002 at 12:14:28PM +0200, Gerfried Fuchs wrote:
 Though it's GPL it will go into contrib for it needs any virus scanner
 and I don't think that there is an open source one. 

ave you taken a look at clamav?

[EMAIL PROTECTED]:~$ apt-cache show clamav 
Package: clamav
[..]
Description: powerful anti-virus scanner for Unix.
 A GPL'ed virus scanner featuring:

  Thanks for the flames/comments/input.

I want this package! :-)




Regards, David

-- 
Afrika kommt nach Europa. Das ist der Kontineltaldrift. Da kann man auch
mit einem neuen Asylgesetz nichts dagegen machen. Das sollte mal wer
denen von der FPÖ erklären!
-- Dietern Nuhr (www.nuhr.de) in der Wiener Remise, 2002-08-02


pgpPuJ4eFzMLy.pgp
Description: PGP signature


Bug#155626: ITP: exiscan -- An email virus scanner for the exim MTA

2002-08-07 Thread Gerfried Fuchs
On Wed, 2002-08-07 at 07:21, David Schmitt wrote:
 Hi Gerfrid, folks!

 Thanks for the offlist-copy. I guess you knew by my unusual mailaddress
that I am currently having problem with my primary mail account :)

 ave you taken a look at clamav?
 
 [EMAIL PROTECTED]:~$ apt-cache show clamav 
 Package: clamav
 [..]
 Description: powerful anti-virus scanner for Unix.
  A GPL'ed virus scanner featuring:

 Not yet.  I currently don't have my unstable machine ready (the power
supply unit is broken :/) so I didn't know about amavis-exim neither
while writing this.  I have taken a quick look at it -- does it have
virus signatures and/or can use the databases others are offering?

 I want this package! :-)

 That's a valueable input, thank you, David. Now I know that I'm not
doing it just for me (like it seems with some of the other packages I am
maintaining).

 Have fun,
Alfie
-- 
  YbdP d'`b d'`b 8 d'`b d'`b 8 8
   Yb  db  dP  8   8 8   8   8   Yb.   8   8 8  8
 ___YbalfbdP___8___8_8___8___8_Yb._8___8_88___
E   N   T   E   R   T   A   I   N   M   E   N   T




Bug#155626: ITP: exiscan -- An email virus scanner for the exim MTA

2002-08-07 Thread David Schmitt
On Wed, Aug 07, 2002 at 09:30:50AM +0200, Gerfried Fuchs wrote:
  Thanks for the offlist-copy. I guess you knew by my unusual mailaddress
 that I am currently having problem with my primary mail account :)
 
 On Wed, 2002-08-07 at 07:21, David Schmitt wrote:
  Have you taken a look at clamav?
  
  [EMAIL PROTECTED]:~$ apt-cache show clamav 
  Package: clamav
  [..]
  Description: powerful anti-virus scanner for Unix.
   A GPL'ed virus scanner featuring:
 
  Not yet.  I currently don't have my unstable machine ready (the power
 supply unit is broken :/) so I didn't know about amavis-exim neither
 while writing this.  I have taken a quick look at it -- does it have
 virus signatures and/or can use the databases others are offering?

Yes. See

http://packages.debian.org/unstable/utils/oav-update.html
http://www.openantivirus.org

  I want this package! :-)
 
  That's a valueable input, thank you, David. Now I know that I'm not
 doing it just for me 

Several clients (including myself) want virusscanning at the mail
gateway, but I was always reluctant to implement complex setups with
dual queues or double sends which let setup maintnance costs explode.


After browsing a bit through the URL there, exiscan v4 looks even more
intresting, because with v2 one has to make sure that no exim -q is run
_ever_ (which isn't as easy as it sounds).

OAre there any plans to package exim v4 in the near future?



Regards, David


-- 
Afrika kommt nach Europa. Das ist der Kontineltaldrift. Da kann man auch
mit einem neuen Asylgesetz nichts dagegen machen. Das sollte mal wer
denen von der FPÖ erklären!
-- Dietern Nuhr (www.nuhr.de) in der Wiener Remise, 2002-08-02


pgpZUpNGblU5h.pgp
Description: PGP signature


Bug#155626: ITP: exiscan -- An email virus scanner for the exim MTA

2002-08-07 Thread Keith G. Murphy

Gerfried Fuchs wrote:


Package: wnpp
Version: N/A; reported 2002-08-06
Severity: wishlist

* Package name: exiscan
  Version : 2.4
  Upstream Author : Tom Kistner [EMAIL PROTECTED]
* URL : http://duncanthrax.net/exiscan/
* License : GPL
  Description : An email virus scanner for the exim MTA

I'd like to see it!  I would probably have tried exiscan 
already if it had a Debian package.  


As it is, amavis is working OK, so I haven't bothered rocking
the boat, in absence of a package (though I have had to go to a 
non-packaged version of amavis as well).






Bug#155626: ITP: exiscan -- An email virus scanner for the exim MTA

2002-08-07 Thread Brian May
On Wed, Aug 07, 2002 at 07:21:39AM +0200, David Schmitt wrote:
 Hi Gerfrid, folks!
 
 On Tue, Aug 06, 2002 at 12:14:28PM +0200, Gerfried Fuchs wrote:
  Though it's GPL it will go into contrib for it needs any virus scanner

Strange. Wonder how I missed that...

 [EMAIL PROTECTED]:~$ apt-cache show clamav 
 Package: clamav
 [..]
 Description: powerful anti-virus scanner for Unix.
  A GPL'ed virus scanner featuring:

...add to that:

Package: scannerdaemon
Priority: optional
Section: mail
Installed-Size: 119
Maintainer: Brian May [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Architecture: all
Version: 5.1-4
Depends: kaffe, oav-virussignatures
Filename: pool/main/s/scannerdaemon/scannerdaemon_5.1-4_all.deb
Size: 49024
MD5sum: 882c2c6e4a2b2a350d524738f5cd0ad4
Description: virus scanner written in Java
 Scannerdaemon is a daemon that accepts incoming requests to
 scan files for viruses.

This is also in main.
-- 
Brian May [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Bug#155626: ITP: exiscan -- An email virus scanner for the exim MTA

2002-08-06 Thread Gerfried Fuchs
Package: wnpp
Version: N/A; reported 2002-08-06
Severity: wishlist

* Package name: exiscan
  Version : 2.4
  Upstream Author : Tom Kistner [EMAIL PROTECTED]
* URL : http://duncanthrax.net/exiscan/
* License : GPL
  Description : An email virus scanner for the exim MTA

 Exiscan is an email virus scanner which works together with the Exim MTA
 (http://www.exim.org). It is written in Perl and designed to be very easy
 to implement. Exiscan supports multithreaded unpacking and scanning of mail,
 with a configurable number of processes. Exiscan has generic support for
 available command line virus scanners. Exiscan can scan inside of MS-TNEF
 and SMIME (signed) wrapped messages.

 For I am using it here @WORK anyway I thought it would be a nice idea
to have it as package too, to let other people find their way to it.
Though it's GPL it will go into contrib for it needs any virus scanner
and I don't think that there is an open source one.  It might be
possible to have it in main if I disable the filtering at all (which
would reduce the usefulness of the package at all).

 I don't know about amavis -- that should be able to do almost the same,
but the exim hooks aren't turned on in that package.  It's just a
sugguestion to do this package.

 Thanks for the flames/comments/input.
Alfie



Bug#155626: ITP: exiscan -- An email virus scanner for the exim MTA

2002-08-06 Thread Brian May
On Tue, Aug 06, 2002 at 12:14:28PM +0200, Gerfried Fuchs wrote:
  I don't know about amavis -- that should be able to do almost the same,
 but the exim hooks aren't turned on in that package.  It's just a
 sugguestion to do this package.

amavis-exim?

(recommended configuration requires newer version of exim not yet in
Debian ;-( )

amavis-ng?

(I am not sure if amavis-ng has been uploaded to Debian yet, but there
was an ITP).

  Thanks for the flames/comments/input.

Sounds like a good idea, and might be worth while even if it
does compete with amavis.

(just look at the number of forks in amavis...)
-- 
Brian May [EMAIL PROTECTED]