Re: Newcomer component

2006-04-11 Thread David W. Van Couvering

If you can't do a permanent link to a filter, then let's keep it as it is...

David

Andrew McIntyre wrote:

On 4/11/06, David W. Van Couvering <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:


That's a good point, but if we put a link to the JIRA filter for
newcomers on the newcomer Wiki page it shouldn't be too bad...



Except I don't think you can't get a permanent link to a saved JIRA filter.



The question I have, is how hard it is to convert bugs with Newcomer
component to bugs with the Newcomer checkbox...



That part is easy, with the bulk change operation.

andrew


Re: Newcomer component

2006-04-11 Thread Andrew McIntyre
On 4/11/06, David W. Van Couvering <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> That's a good point, but if we put a link to the JIRA filter for
> newcomers on the newcomer Wiki page it shouldn't be too bad...

Except I don't think you can't get a permanent link to a saved JIRA filter.

> The question I have, is how hard it is to convert bugs with Newcomer
> component to bugs with the Newcomer checkbox...

That part is easy, with the bulk change operation.

andrew


Re: Newcomer component

2006-04-11 Thread David W. Van Couvering
That's a good point, but if we put a link to the JIRA filter for 
newcomers on the newcomer Wiki page it shouldn't be too bad...


When entering a JIRA bug, the checkboxes are very easy to see and easier 
to select than components, so that's a plus.  That and it is more 
accurate, IMHO.


The question I have, is how hard it is to convert bugs with Newcomer 
component to bugs with the Newcomer checkbox...


David

Andrew McIntyre wrote:

On 4/10/06, David W. Van Couvering <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:


It seems to me that "Newcomer" should be a flag, not a component.  I
think of components as parts of the code.  Is it possible to convert
this to a flag?



That's fine with me, although then you don't have that nice "Newcomer"
listing on the front page of the Derby JIRA. Having to go through the
web interface to create a filter for the newcomer flag, or even get to
a global filter, puts quite a few steps between the newcomer and
issues that they could work on. I don't really have strong feelings
either way, though.

andrew


Re: Newcomer component

2006-04-10 Thread Andrew McIntyre
On 4/10/06, David W. Van Couvering <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> It seems to me that "Newcomer" should be a flag, not a component.  I
> think of components as parts of the code.  Is it possible to convert
> this to a flag?

That's fine with me, although then you don't have that nice "Newcomer"
listing on the front page of the Derby JIRA. Having to go through the
web interface to create a filter for the newcomer flag, or even get to
a global filter, puts quite a few steps between the newcomer and
issues that they could work on. I don't really have strong feelings
either way, though.

andrew


Newcomer component

2006-04-10 Thread David W. Van Couvering
It seems to me that "Newcomer" should be a flag, not a component.  I 
think of components as parts of the code.  Is it possible to convert 
this to a flag?


Thanks,

David