Re: Welcome Aleksandr Sorokoumov as Cassandra committer
Congratulations Aleksandr! > On Mar 17, 2022, at 3:49 AM, Brandon Williams wrote: > > Congratulations and thank you Aleksandr! > > Kind Regards, > Brandon > > On Wed, Mar 16, 2022 at 8:15 AM Benjamin Lerer wrote: >> >> The PMC members are pleased to announce that Aleksandr Sorokoumov has >> accepted >> the invitation to become committer. >> >> Thanks a lot, Aleksandr , for everything you have done for the project. >> >> Congratulations and welcome >> >> The Apache Cassandra PMC members
Re: [Discuss] replacement of airlift/airline framework in CLI tools
airline/airlift is deprecated. I suspect if there were any security issues they would not be fixed. Their project recommends moving to Airline 2 or picocli. I share Stefan's concern about the stability of the CLI and output formatting. We should avoid any breakages resulting from this migration. Lots of automation depends on this "interface" being stable. > On Mar 17, 2022, at 1:42 PM, Stefan Miklosovic > wrote: > > Hi Tibor, > > Thanks for raising this. > > Do you see some important issues you would like to address by > switching to a newer Airline or are we updating just because the > former version is not supported anymore? How much do you miss the new > Airline library and does the older library prevent you from achieving > something the newer one is able to deliver? Can you be specific? > > I am used to picocli too, it is a very handy library, one class > actually. However, I am afraid that switching to anything else would > be quite a "shock" to users who are just used to good old & stable > stuff. People are parsing the output of this tooling in scripts and so > on. It is a very delicate matter. The output matters. This might be > probably something for 5.0, I do not think that having such a breaking > user-facing change would be appropriate to introduce in 4.1 or any > point release ... > > Regards > > On Wed, 16 Mar 2022 at 15:03, Tibor Répási wrote: >> >> In CASSANDRA-17445 we’ve started discussing the options of replacing the >> deprecated airlift/airline framework used in CLI tools. >> >> Considering the amount of commands this framework is used in, the impact >> this might cause and the future possibilities the operational aspects of >> Cassandra could leverage, first comments at slack revealed an in-depth >> discussion would be desirable. >> >> Kind request for comments.
Re: [Discuss] replacement of airlift/airline framework in CLI tools
Hi Tibor, Thanks for raising this. Do you see some important issues you would like to address by switching to a newer Airline or are we updating just because the former version is not supported anymore? How much do you miss the new Airline library and does the older library prevent you from achieving something the newer one is able to deliver? Can you be specific? I am used to picocli too, it is a very handy library, one class actually. However, I am afraid that switching to anything else would be quite a "shock" to users who are just used to good old & stable stuff. People are parsing the output of this tooling in scripts and so on. It is a very delicate matter. The output matters. This might be probably something for 5.0, I do not think that having such a breaking user-facing change would be appropriate to introduce in 4.1 or any point release ... Regards On Wed, 16 Mar 2022 at 15:03, Tibor Répási wrote: > > In CASSANDRA-17445 we’ve started discussing the options of replacing the > deprecated airlift/airline framework used in CLI tools. > > Considering the amount of commands this framework is used in, the impact this > might cause and the future possibilities the operational aspects of Cassandra > could leverage, first comments at slack revealed an in-depth discussion would > be desirable. > > Kind request for comments.
Re: Welcome Aleksandr Sorokoumov as Cassandra committer
Congratulations and thank you Aleksandr! Kind Regards, Brandon On Wed, Mar 16, 2022 at 8:15 AM Benjamin Lerer wrote: > > The PMC members are pleased to announce that Aleksandr Sorokoumov has accepted > the invitation to become committer. > > Thanks a lot, Aleksandr , for everything you have done for the project. > > Congratulations and welcome > > The Apache Cassandra PMC members
Re: Welcome Aleksandr Sorokoumov as Cassandra committer
Congratulations !!! - - -- --- - - Jacek Lewandowski On Thu, Mar 17, 2022 at 8:49 AM Mick Semb Wever wrote: > > Congrats Aleksandr! 拾 > > On Wed, 16 Mar 2022 at 14:16, Benjamin Lerer wrote: > >> The PMC members are pleased to announce that Aleksandr Sorokoumov has >> accepted >> the invitation to become committer. >> >> Thanks a lot, Aleksandr , for everything you have done for the project. >> >> Congratulations and welcome >> >> The Apache Cassandra PMC members >> >
Re: Using labels on pull requests in GitHub
Hi, I would like to note that I as contributor cannot add labels or do almost nothing in my PRs to Apache Cassandra. So it completely relies on committers, I guess. In a case you decide to ask contributors/PR owners to label their PRs it will be necessary to provide the functionality. Best regards, Ruslan
Re: Welcome Aleksandr Sorokoumov as Cassandra committer
Congrats Aleksandr! 拾 On Wed, 16 Mar 2022 at 14:16, Benjamin Lerer wrote: > The PMC members are pleased to announce that Aleksandr Sorokoumov has > accepted > the invitation to become committer. > > Thanks a lot, Aleksandr , for everything you have done for the project. > > Congratulations and welcome > > The Apache Cassandra PMC members >
Re: Welcome Aleksandr Sorokoumov as Cassandra committer
Well done Aleksandr! On 17/3/22 3:44, Anthony Grasso wrote: Congratulations Aleksandr! Thank you for your work on the project. On Thu, 17 Mar 2022 at 12:33, Erick Ramirez wrote: Congratulations Aleksandr and welcome aboard! On Thu, 17 Mar 2022 at 00:15, Benjamin Lerer wrote: The PMC members are pleased to announce that Aleksandr Sorokoumov has accepted the invitation to become committer. Thanks a lot, Aleksandr , for everything you have done for the project. Congratulations and welcome The Apache Cassandra PMC members
