felix subproject bundles without the compendium classes
Hi All Does anyone know if there are build flags that allow the felix subproject jars (for example eventadmin or http) to be built without including the org.osgi.* classes that from part of the standard compendium? Thanks Bruce
Re: felix subproject bundles without the compendium classes
You can change the bnd instructions inside the poms to do that. For event, add org.osgi.service.event to the list of Import-Package. However, there has been a long debate of the pros and cons of including interfaces into implementation bundles. When exported correctly there is usually no big disadvantage other than possibly wasted disk space. On the other hand it much more consumer friendly to ship the interfaces, too. So, do you really want to used forked versions of the felix bundles here ? Toni On Thu, Feb 3, 2011 at 12:36 PM, Jackson, Bruce bru...@qualcomm.com wrote: Hi All Does anyone know if there are build flags that allow the felix subproject jars (for example eventadmin or http) to be built without including the org.osgi.* classes that from part of the standard compendium? Thanks Bruce -- *Toni Menzel - http://www.okidokiteam.com*
Re: felix subproject bundles without the compendium classes
Hi, On 03.02.11 13:00, Toni Menzel t...@okidokiteam.com wrote: You can change the bnd instructions inside the poms to do that. For event, add org.osgi.service.event to the list of Import-Package. However, there has been a long debate of the pros and cons of including interfaces into implementation bundles. When exported correctly there is usually no big disadvantage other than possibly wasted disk space. On the other hand it much more consumer friendly to ship the interfaces, too. So, do you really want to used forked versions of the felix bundles here ? I think it's for Android right ? In that case, no choice... Regards, Clement Toni On Thu, Feb 3, 2011 at 12:36 PM, Jackson, Bruce bru...@qualcomm.com wrote: Hi All Does anyone know if there are build flags that allow the felix subproject jars (for example eventadmin or http) to be built without including the org.osgi.* classes that from part of the standard compendium? Thanks Bruce -- *Toni Menzel - http://www.okidokiteam.com*
Re: felix subproject bundles without the compendium classes
Yes, correct. For Android I have to be able to compile ate Android part of the app against the osgi compendium jar with that on the app classpath, and then export the compendium classes into the felix framework. If the same packages appear in the bundles, you then run into the whole classloaders problem. On 03/02/2011 12:09, Clement Escoffier clement.escoff...@gmail.com wrote: Hi, On 03.02.11 13:00, Toni Menzel t...@okidokiteam.com wrote: You can change the bnd instructions inside the poms to do that. For event, add org.osgi.service.event to the list of Import-Package. However, there has been a long debate of the pros and cons of including interfaces into implementation bundles. When exported correctly there is usually no big disadvantage other than possibly wasted disk space. On the other hand it much more consumer friendly to ship the interfaces, too. So, do you really want to used forked versions of the felix bundles here ? I think it's for Android right ? In that case, no choice... Regards, Clement Toni On Thu, Feb 3, 2011 at 12:36 PM, Jackson, Bruce bru...@qualcomm.com wrote: Hi All Does anyone know if there are build flags that allow the felix subproject jars (for example eventadmin or http) to be built without including the org.osgi.* classes that from part of the standard compendium? Thanks Bruce -- *Toni Menzel - http://www.okidokiteam.com*
