[jira] Commented: (GERONIMO-2743) [Code donation] J2G Conversion tool
[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/GERONIMO-2743?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel#action_12477347 ] Paul McMahan commented on GERONIMO-2743: One of the questions on the IP clearance form is: "Check and make sure that the files that have been donated have been updated to reflect the new ASF copyright." These java source files don't contain an ASF copyright header: src/dependence-plugin/src/org/apache/apps/j2gmigrator/compatibility/Anybody.java src/dependence-plugin/src/org/apache/apps/j2gmigrator/compatibility/DigestCallback.java src/dependence-plugin/src/org/apache/apps/j2gmigrator/compatibility/GeronimoLoginModule.java src/dependence-plugin/src/org/apache/apps/j2gmigrator/compatibility/GeronimoSimpleGroup.java src/dependence-plugin/src/org/apache/apps/j2gmigrator/compatibility/Nobody.java src/dependence-plugin/src/org/apache/apps/j2gmigrator/compatibility/PasswordHasher.java src2/ejb-migration-plugin/test/org/apache/apps/j2gmigrator/descriptors/ejb/TestEJBDescriptorTool.java src2/enterprise-migration-plugin/test/org/apache/apps/j2gmigrator/descriptors/app/TestApplicationDescriptorTool.java src2/web-migration-plugin/test/org/apache/apps/j2gmigrator/descriptors/web/TestWebDescriptorTool.java src2/xml-conversion-helper/test/org/apache/apps/j2gmigrator/descriptors/xmlutil/TestXMLConversionHelper.java src2/xml-conversion-helper/test/org/apache/apps/j2gmigrator/resources/xmlutil/test/XMLConvertionHelperTestCase.java Also, I noticed these non-java files don't contain an ASF copyright header: src/common/build.properties src/common/plugin.xml src/configurator/bin/com/ibm/j2g/Configurator.class src/dependence-plugin/build.properties src/dependence-plugin/plugin.xml src/dependence-plugin/src/org/apache/apps/j2gmigrator/source/dependence/class_analogies.properties src/dependence-plugin/src/org/apache/apps/j2gmigrator/source/dependence/compatible_sources.properties src/dependence-plugin/src/org/apache/apps/j2gmigrator/source/dependence/default_jars.properties src/descriptors-tool/build.properties src/descriptors-tool/plugin.xml src/descriptors-tool/schema/tool.migrations.exsd src/ejb-environment-plugin/build.properties src/ejb-environment-plugin/plugin.xml src/ejb-environment-plugin/src/org/apache/apps/j2gmigrator/sources/env/beans-interfaces.properties src/ejb-environment-plugin/src/org/apache/apps/j2gmigrator/sources/env/beans-references.properties src/ejb-environment-plugin/src/org/apache/apps/j2gmigrator/sources/env/beans-types.properties src/jasper-plugin/build.properties src/jasper-plugin/plugin.xml src/resources-tool/build.properties src/resources-tool/plugin.xml src/resources-tool/schema/tool.migrations.exsd src/scripts/j2g-configure.cmd src/scripts/jdesc2g.cmd src/scripts/jres2g.cmd src/scripts/jsrc2g.cmd src/sources-tool/build.properties src/sources-tool/plugin.xml src/sources-tool/schema/migrations.exsd src2/data-source-plugin/build.properties src2/data-source-plugin/plugin.xml src2/data-source-plugin/src/commons-logging.properties src2/data-source-plugin/test-apps/ds/hsqldb-ds.xml src2/data-source-plugin/test-apps/ds/hsqldb-geronimo-plan.xml src2/data-source-plugin/test-apps/ds/mysql-ds.xml src2/data-source-plugin/test-apps/ds/mysql-geronimo-plan.xml src2/data-source-plugin/test-apps/ds/oracle-ds.xml src2/data-source-plugin/test-apps/ds/oracle-geronimo-plan.xml src2/ejb-cmp-migration-plugin/build.properties src2/ejb-cmp-migration-plugin/plugin.xml src2/ejb-cmp-migration-plugin/src/commons-logging.properties src2/ejb-cmp-migration-plugin/test-resources/ejb-jar.xml src2/ejb-cmp-migration-plugin/test-resources/jbosscmp-jdbc.xml src2/ejb-migration-plugin/build.properties src2/ejb-migration-plugin/plugin.xml src2/ejb-migration-plugin/src/common-logging.properties src2/ejb-migration-plugin/test-resources/jboss.xml src2/enterprise-migration-plugin/.settings/org.eclipse.ltk.core.refactoring.prefs src2/enterprise-migration-plugin/build.properties src2/enterprise-migration-plugin/plugin.xml src2/enterprise-migration-plugin/src/commons-logging.properties src2/enterprise-migration-plugin/test-resources/geronimo-application.xml src2/enterprise-migration-plugin/test-resources/jboss-app.xml src2/jms-plugin/build.properties src2/jms-plugin/plugin.xml src2/jms-plugin/src/commons-logging.properties src2/jms-plugin/test-apps/jms/geronimo-jms-resource-plan.xml src2/jms-plugin/test-apps/jms/jbossmq-destinations-service.xml src2/jms-plugin/test-apps/jms/jms-ds.xml src2/jms-plugin/test-apps/jms/jms-geronimo-plan.xml src2/mail-plugin/build.properties src2/mail-plugin/plugin.xml src2/mail-plugin/src/commons-logging.properties src2/mail-plugin/test-apps/mail/err/mail-service.xml src2/mail-plugin/test-apps/mail/geronimo-mail-service.xml src2/mail-plugin/test-apps/mail/mail-geronimo-plan.xml src2/mail-plugin/test-apps/mail/mail-service.xml src2/security-plugin/build.properties src2/security-plugin/plugin.xml src2/security-plugin/src/common
[jira] Commented: (GERONIMO-2743) [Code donation] J2G Conversion tool
[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/GERONIMO-2743?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel#action_12475973
]
Paul McMahan commented on GERONIMO-2743:
There was some discussion about the package name on dev:
http://www.nabble.com/-VOTE--J2G-Conversion-tool-acceptance-tf3149274.html#a9120007
Specifically, Sachin said:
{quote}
In order to follow proper convention, the package names need to start with the
plugin id and the plugin id should be organization + product + plugin so in our
case...
plugin id: org.apache.geronimo.j2g.someIdForThisSpecificPlugin
and all packages within that plugin should start with the pluginId
{quote}
Since this probably constitutes a significant amount of refactoring (and maybe
even some more discussion) I think it might be best to make the packaging
adjustments after the code is in sandbox.
> [Code donation] J2G Conversion tool
> ---
>
> Key: GERONIMO-2743
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/GERONIMO-2743
> Project: Geronimo
> Issue Type: New Feature
> Security Level: public(Regular issues)
>Affects Versions: 1.1.x
> Environment: MS Windows XP SP2 (although Java based should work on
> any OS supporting Java)
>Reporter: Filip Hanik
>Priority: Minor
> Fix For: 1.1.x
>
> Attachments: CCLA.tif, Covalent-J2G-Tool.pdf,
> J2G-Migration-v2_src_1.0.0.zip, J2G-Migration_2.0.0_src_20070220-1501.zip
>
>
> IBM has together with in a joint effort with Covalent developed a JBoss to
> Geronimo conversion tool. This tool is used when converting applications from
> JBoss to Geronimo, and automatically converts the configuration file from one
> app server to the other.
> We feel that this piece of software adds value to Geronimo and users adopting
> Geronimo and would like to see this effort continue as part of the Geronimo
> project, a plugin or a sub project of Geronimo.
> The initial donation is for version 1.0 of this tool, and while a 1.1 is in
> the making to improve 1.0, 1.1 is not yet complete but will be donated as
> soon as the community feels that this tool belongs at the ASF, more
> specifically within the Geronimo project.
> If you'd think this tool is valuable, but believe it should go through
> incubation, we would hope that a Geronimo committer would step up and
> champion this effort.
> The tool, including IBM's CCLA, can be found at
> http://people.apache.org/~fhanik/j2g/j2g.html (Covalent will file the CCLA
> upon request)
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
-
You can reply to this email to add a comment to the issue online.
[jira] Commented: (GERONIMO-2743) [Code donation] J2G Conversion tool
[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/GERONIMO-2743?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel#action_12475934 ] Filip Hanik commented on GERONIMO-2743: --- Current codebase is packaged as: org.apache.apps.j2gmigrator... we suggest that during the import, the code is restructured as: org.apache.geronimo.j2gmigrator or org.apache.geronimo.devtools.j2gmigrator > [Code donation] J2G Conversion tool > --- > > Key: GERONIMO-2743 > URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/GERONIMO-2743 > Project: Geronimo > Issue Type: New Feature > Security Level: public(Regular issues) >Affects Versions: 1.1.x > Environment: MS Windows XP SP2 (although Java based should work on > any OS supporting Java) >Reporter: Filip Hanik >Priority: Minor > Fix For: 1.1.x > > Attachments: CCLA.tif, Covalent-J2G-Tool.pdf, > J2G-Migration-v2_src_1.0.0.zip, J2G-Migration_2.0.0_src_20070220-1501.zip > > > IBM has together with in a joint effort with Covalent developed a JBoss to > Geronimo conversion tool. This tool is used when converting applications from > JBoss to Geronimo, and automatically converts the configuration file from one > app server to the other. > We feel that this piece of software adds value to Geronimo and users adopting > Geronimo and would like to see this effort continue as part of the Geronimo > project, a plugin or a sub project of Geronimo. > The initial donation is for version 1.0 of this tool, and while a 1.1 is in > the making to improve 1.0, 1.1 is not yet complete but will be donated as > soon as the community feels that this tool belongs at the ASF, more > specifically within the Geronimo project. > If you'd think this tool is valuable, but believe it should go through > incubation, we would hope that a Geronimo committer would step up and > champion this effort. > The tool, including IBM's CCLA, can be found at > http://people.apache.org/~fhanik/j2g/j2g.html (Covalent will file the CCLA > upon request) -- This message is automatically generated by JIRA. - You can reply to this email to add a comment to the issue online.
