Re: Geronimo Performance Report - Input Requested
Matt, I think this looks really good. Excellent analysis and explanations. Just a few comments: - Page numbers on each page would help with references ;-) - Diagram numbers would also be helpful - Would it be possible to get a brief (sentence or two) explanation of each of the runtime parameters and the functions they execute at the server? I'm sure this is included in the daytrader doc but a brief overview in this doc would help set the context. - Were the actual HPG targets specified someplace in the document that I missed? I see them in the graphics but it's kind of difficult to "guess" the precise value from the graphic. - I presume PingServlet2Session is the same as 2SessionEJB in the graphic? - I presume PingServlet2EntityEJBRemote is the same as 2EntityRemote in the graphic? - There were some parameters/results that I didn't see in the graphics (I presume by design but I'm just checking) ... PingServlet2Include, PingServlet2JSP, PingHTTPSession2, PingHTTPSession3, PingServlet2Session2Entity. Since these weren't included in the graphics we don't really know the target that you were measuring against (the HPG value). - typo - PingHHTPSession2 -> PingHTTPSession2 Thanks, Joe Matt Hogstrom wrote: All, I've been spending some quality time with Geronimo over the past couple of weeks gathering some performance data for 1.1.1. I've posted a PDF that I'd like your input on in terms of content, questions, etc. I'd like to wrap this up quickly as I'd like to help with 1.2 so your prompt reply is appreciated. This is a rough draft so there are spelling errors and such so your keen eye is welcome. I have some additional work to do this weekend to validate my comparison metric. Also, I need a better name than HPG (Hogstrom Performance Goal). Thanks in advance for your help. http://people.apache.org/~hogstrom/Geronimo-1.1.1-Performance-Report.pdf Matt Hogstrom [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: Geronimo Performance Report - Input Requested
Hi Matt, It looks great work I want to add one question and few more suggestions. Question: What is the formula of HPG? Is it a secret one? :-) Suggestions: 1. Better we have comparison between IBM and Sun JVMs in this performances. 2. As database could you please consider inbuilt Apache Derby too? 3. Since it shows better performance in web tier than EJB, can't we get a HPG value comparison for light weight container stuff (Spring, Hibernate) ? I hope you will publish these values pretty soon in some popular web sites ;-) . Thanks, Lasantha Ranaweera Matt Hogstrom wrote: All, I've been spending some quality time with Geronimo over the past couple of weeks gathering some performance data for 1.1.1. I've posted a PDF that I'd like your input on in terms of content, questions, etc. I'd like to wrap this up quickly as I'd like to help with 1.2 so your prompt reply is appreciated. This is a rough draft so there are spelling errors and such so your keen eye is welcome. I have some additional work to do this weekend to validate my comparison metric. Also, I need a better name than HPG (Hogstrom Performance Goal). Thanks in advance for your help. http://people.apache.org/~hogstrom/Geronimo-1.1.1-Performance-Report.pdf Matt Hogstrom [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: Geronimo Performance Report - Input Requested
Very nice! Is this with jetty or tomcat? When can we get a speed comparison :-) ? thanks david jencks On Nov 3, 2006, at 9:17 PM, Matt Hogstrom wrote: All, I've been spending some quality time with Geronimo over the past couple of weeks gathering some performance data for 1.1.1. I've posted a PDF that I'd like your input on in terms of content, questions, etc. I'd like to wrap this up quickly as I'd like to help with 1.2 so your prompt reply is appreciated. This is a rough draft so there are spelling errors and such so your keen eye is welcome. I have some additional work to do this weekend to validate my comparison metric. Also, I need a better name than HPG (Hogstrom Performance Goal). Thanks in advance for your help. http://people.apache.org/~hogstrom/Geronimo-1.1.1-Performance- Report.pdf Matt Hogstrom [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: Geronimo Performance Report - Input Requested
Looks good. So this is just one vm and it scaled well to 4 cores? Did scale linearly? I'd love to see how 8 cores scale :) One coment, on page 8 you mention we don't support CORBA on 1.5, but you don't mention that that is one features on the 1.2 list. -dain On Nov 3, 2006, at 9:17 PM, Matt Hogstrom wrote: All, I've been spending some quality time with Geronimo over the past couple of weeks gathering some performance data for 1.1.1. I've posted a PDF that I'd like your input on in terms of content, questions, etc. I'd like to wrap this up quickly as I'd like to help with 1.2 so your prompt reply is appreciated. This is a rough draft so there are spelling errors and such so your keen eye is welcome. I have some additional work to do this weekend to validate my comparison metric. Also, I need a better name than HPG (Hogstrom Performance Goal). Thanks in advance for your help. http://people.apache.org/~hogstrom/Geronimo-1.1.1-Performance- Report.pdf Matt Hogstrom [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: Geronimo Performance Report - Input Requested
All, A couple people have pinged me about a mis-statement on page 8 about the equipment being loaned to the ASF. That statement is incorrect. The equipment was loaned to me to do performance work on Apache Geronimo. It is not on loan to the ASF and I will correct that statement. Thanks for those of you who were discreet in letting me know about that faus paux. Given the confusion about the Azul certification I want to make sure things are correct. I have updated my copy to remove the statement altogether as what I intended to communicate was that I did this work on my own and these are my opinions; your mileage may vary. Thanks for catching this guys. On Nov 4, 2006, at 12:17 AM, Matt Hogstrom wrote: All, I've been spending some quality time with Geronimo over the past couple of weeks gathering some performance data for 1.1.1. I've posted a PDF that I'd like your input on in terms of content, questions, etc. I'd like to wrap this up quickly as I'd like to help with 1.2 so your prompt reply is appreciated. This is a rough draft so there are spelling errors and such so your keen eye is welcome. I have some additional work to do this weekend to validate my comparison metric. Also, I need a better name than HPG (Hogstrom Performance Goal). Thanks in advance for your help. http://people.apache.org/~hogstrom/Geronimo-1.1.1-Performance- Report.pdf Matt Hogstrom [EMAIL PROTECTED] Matt Hogstrom [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: Geronimo Performance Report - Input Requested
"Hogstrom Performance Goal" :) On 11/4/06, Jeff Genender <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Very cool stuff... What is an "HPG"? Jeff Matt Hogstrom wrote: > All, > > I've been spending some quality time with Geronimo over the past couple > of weeks gathering some performance data for 1.1.1. > > I've posted a PDF that I'd like your input on in terms of content, > questions, etc. I'd like to wrap this up quickly as I'd like to help > with 1.2 so your prompt reply is appreciated. This is a rough draft so > there are spelling errors and such so your keen eye is welcome. I have > some additional work to do this weekend to validate my comparison > metric. Also, I need a better name than HPG (Hogstrom Performance Goal). > > Thanks in advance for your help. > > http://people.apache.org/~hogstrom/Geronimo-1.1.1-Performance-Report.pdf > > Matt Hogstrom > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > -- Davanum Srinivas : http://www.wso2.net (Oxygen for Web Service Developers)
Re: Geronimo Performance Report - Input Requested
Very cool stuff... What is an "HPG"? Jeff Matt Hogstrom wrote: > All, > > I've been spending some quality time with Geronimo over the past couple > of weeks gathering some performance data for 1.1.1. > > I've posted a PDF that I'd like your input on in terms of content, > questions, etc. I'd like to wrap this up quickly as I'd like to help > with 1.2 so your prompt reply is appreciated. This is a rough draft so > there are spelling errors and such so your keen eye is welcome. I have > some additional work to do this weekend to validate my comparison > metric. Also, I need a better name than HPG (Hogstrom Performance Goal). > > Thanks in advance for your help. > > http://people.apache.org/~hogstrom/Geronimo-1.1.1-Performance-Report.pdf > > Matt Hogstrom > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > >
Geronimo Performance Report - Input Requested
All, I've been spending some quality time with Geronimo over the past couple of weeks gathering some performance data for 1.1.1. I've posted a PDF that I'd like your input on in terms of content, questions, etc. I'd like to wrap this up quickly as I'd like to help with 1.2 so your prompt reply is appreciated. This is a rough draft so there are spelling errors and such so your keen eye is welcome. I have some additional work to do this weekend to validate my comparison metric. Also, I need a better name than HPG (Hogstrom Performance Goal). Thanks in advance for your help. http://people.apache.org/~hogstrom/Geronimo-1.1.1-Performance-Report.pdf Matt Hogstrom [EMAIL PROTECTED]