Re: Shared MIME info update

2014-04-28 Thread Nick Burch

On Mon, 28 Apr 2014, Matthias Krueger wrote:
I ran a diff on tika-mimetypes.xml and the latest Freedesktop share MIME 
info DB release (http://cgit.freedesktop.org/xdg/shared-mime-info/). It 
seems they have diverged quite a lot.


I don't think they've ever been the same. We use their XML format, but not 
their data. Our data comes from a mixture of places, initially the httpd 
mimetypes file, along with lots of bug reports, fixes etc since them. We 
also support one or two types that they don't


Or is licensing in the way (I think they dual license with LGPL anf AFL 
2.0)?


They can take our nice work, but we can't theirs. The Apache License v2 is 
largely a universal donner license. LGPL and friends are largely not - see 
http://www.apache.org/legal/resolved.html#category-x . (It's largely the 
same thing with OpenOffice - LibreOffice are welcome to take fixes from 
Apache OpenOffice, and they do, but AOO can only take LO fixes where the 
contributor explicitly allows their changes to be Apache licensed)


Nick


Shared MIME info update

2014-04-28 Thread Matthias Krueger


Hi all,

I ran a diff on tika-mimetypes.xml and the latest Freedesktop share MIME 
info DB release (http://cgit.freedesktop.org/xdg/shared-mime-info/). It 
seems they have diverged quite a lot. Do you see benefit in bringing 
them closer together again? Or is licensing in the way (I think they 
dual license with LGPL anf AFL 2.0)?


Thanks
Matthias