Re: [Development] IMPORTANT: topic reviews on gerrit disabled
On 11/16/11 16:44, Storm-Olsen Marius (Nokia-MP-Qt/Austin) wrote: On 11/14/11 5:13 PM, ext Oswald Buddenhagen oswald.buddenha...@nokia.com wrote: due to about a dozen bugs, a few of them fairly serious, i went ahead and disabled the topic review functionality. it will come back, but not necessarily this year. :} Have you made a note of those dozen bugs on the wiki, so we can get them looked at properly? it's all in our jira (as far as people could be bothered to report it properly), and the upstream topic review issue (51) links to those i knew of as of monday or so. ___ Development mailing list Development@qt-project.org http://lists.qt-project.org/mailman/listinfo/development
Re: [Development] IMPORTANT: topic reviews on gerrit disabled
On Wed, Nov 16, 2011 at 10:44 AM, marius.storm-ol...@nokia.com wrote: On 11/14/11 5:13 PM, ext Oswald Buddenhagen oswald.buddenha...@nokia.com wrote: moin, due to about a dozen bugs, a few of them fairly serious, i went ahead and disabled the topic review functionality. it will come back, but not necessarily this year. :} Have you made a note of those dozen bugs on the wiki, so we can get them looked at properly? That would be extremely useful for us, as we are developing against the topic branch Gerrit changes, and are working on fixing bugs and issues before we start using the topic review functionality. Some of them are linked to in the Gerrit issue tracker already. Thanks, Marcus ___ Development mailing list Development@qt-project.org http://lists.qt-project.org/mailman/listinfo/development
[Development] IMPORTANT: topic reviews on gerrit disabled
moin, due to about a dozen bugs, a few of them fairly serious, i went ahead and disabled the topic review functionality. it will come back, but not necessarily this year. :} how to work without the functionality (i.e., how we worked up to a few weeks ago): you just have to talk more (shock!). put the necessary info into the first change of the topic: tell the invited reviewers that the subsequent changes (under dependencies = needed by) actually belong to a topic, and tell them not to submit/stage anything themselves (which is good practice anyway, to allow other reviewers to have a say). to see the whole topic (and some more), just click the author in the change list. staging becomes a bit annoying for the authors again, but then, that feature wasn't *that* commonly used anyway, so i'm positive we'll survive it. ps: i'm not sure what about the existing topics. just try to continue to use them ... -- Oswald Buddenhagen Software Developer Nokia, Qt Development Frameworks ___ Development mailing list Development@qt-project.org http://lists.qt-project.org/mailman/listinfo/development
