[digitalradio] Anecdotes about FCC inadvertent hostility toward ham radio digital modes?

2010-03-06 Thread vinceinwaukesha
I've recently read several digital ops repeatedly ominously state hams should 
never ask the FCC about digital issues because the FCCs answer might be 
extremely bad for the hobby, aka, never tickle a sleeping dragon.

This sounds new to me, outside of the digital world, hams constantly pester the 
FCC with all kinds of imaginative questions and proposals.  Digital is new to 
me (well, relatively new, for a 3rd gen ham for twenty years, anyway).  I hear 
it repeated over and over from some digital hams.  So that indicates there 
might be a bad story from ye olden days of ham digital regulation.

All I'm asking for is something like back in '67 after a perfectly innocent 
question about maritime mobile RTTY onair identification, the horrible end 
result was radioFAX transmission was temporarily banned because of lack of CW 
ids.  I'm only bugging you all, because I have no idea what to google for, 
once I have a couple keywords I can find the details of the event on my own.

73 de N9NFB



Re: [digitalradio] Anecdotes about FCC inadvertent hostility toward ham radio digital modes?

2010-03-06 Thread w2xj
I think the comment was broader based. Never go to the FCC for anything. 
They want to be as hands off amateur radio as possible. They expect you 
to interpret the rules and act accordingly, that is part of what your 
qualification to hold a licensee is about.


vinceinwaukesha wrote:
 I've recently read several digital ops repeatedly ominously state hams should 
 never ask the FCC about digital issues because the FCCs answer might be 
 extremely bad for the hobby, aka, never tickle a sleeping dragon.

 This sounds new to me, outside of the digital world, hams constantly pester 
 the FCC with all kinds of imaginative questions and proposals.  Digital is 
 new to me (well, relatively new, for a 3rd gen ham for twenty years, anyway). 
  I hear it repeated over and over from some digital hams.  So that indicates 
 there might be a bad story from ye olden days of ham digital regulation.

 All I'm asking for is something like back in '67 after a perfectly innocent 
 question about maritime mobile RTTY onair identification, the horrible end 
 result was radioFAX transmission was temporarily banned because of lack of CW 
 ids.  I'm only bugging you all, because I have no idea what to google for, 
 once I have a couple keywords I can find the details of the event on my own.

 73 de N9NFB