Re: [Dovecot] migration to dovecot pop3

2012-12-21 Thread Rajesh M


 On 12/19/2012 6:59 PM, Joseph Tam wrote:
 Rajesh M writes:

 i am planning to migrate from qmail pop3 to dovecot pop3

 the number of users on the server is large over 5000
 ...
 also data volume is large - over 3.5 tb -- ie many users several 1000s
 of
 emails in their inbox

 If you stay on the list, you might find some people here whose
 mail metrics are several orders of magnitude larger than this.

 1) will the migration cause all the emails on the server to re-download
 ...
 4) has anybody migrated from qmail pop3 to dovecot pop3 successfully
 without emails being downloaded again

 A proper migration will avoid this.  Google is your friend

 http://lmgtfy.com/q=POP+qmail+to+dovecot+migration

 The top hits provide exactly what you're looking for.

 2) can dovecot be configured to allow only one download at a time -
 pop3
 locking with time out setting that can be customized

 We migrated 5000+ from qpopper years ago. Dovecot is sooo much better on
 system load. Yes, locking and timeouts are in the config file.


 3) can dovecot pop3 be configured so that it will allow download of
 emails
 only of the last say 15 days ie even if the same pop3 user is
 configure on
 another machine it will download only messages of the last 15 days

 That's not part of pop3, so no, it's not possible with dovecot alone.
 You could probably work out a plugin to move read mail after x days, or
 there may be one out there ? Or some imap robot could do it..
 Ken A.
 Pacific.Net


 I can't answer this, but if this is an attempt to prevent mass download,
 the answer to 1+4 makes these questions irrelevant.

 Joseph Tam jtam.h...@gmail.com


 --
 Ken Anderson
 Pacific Internet - http://www.pacific.net
 Latest Pacific.Net Status - http://twitter.com/pacnetstatus


thanks joseph and ken for your replies

ken, if possible can you please give me some more information concerning
the servers that you use.

i am using qmailtoaster my server has over 3 tb of data.

Q1) which email server software are you using for your 5000+ users

Q2) what is your server hardware configuration for handling 5000+ users

Q3) do you users store several 1000's of emails in their inboxes.

Q4) i want to try out by running dovecot pop3 on a separate port other
than 110 while qmail toaster pop3 continues to run on port 110 and try
downloading from specific a test mailbox. do you forsee any problems in
this ?

thank you once again for your kind help.

rajesh






Re: [Dovecot] migration to dovecot pop3

2012-12-20 Thread Ken A


On 12/19/2012 6:59 PM, Joseph Tam wrote:
 Rajesh M writes:
 
 i am planning to migrate from qmail pop3 to dovecot pop3

 the number of users on the server is large over 5000
 ...
 also data volume is large - over 3.5 tb -- ie many users several 1000s of
 emails in their inbox
 
 If you stay on the list, you might find some people here whose
 mail metrics are several orders of magnitude larger than this.
 
 1) will the migration cause all the emails on the server to re-download
 ...
 4) has anybody migrated from qmail pop3 to dovecot pop3 successfully
 without emails being downloaded again
 
 A proper migration will avoid this.  Google is your friend
 
 http://lmgtfy.com/q=POP+qmail+to+dovecot+migration
 
 The top hits provide exactly what you're looking for.
 
 2) can dovecot be configured to allow only one download at a time - pop3
 locking with time out setting that can be customized

We migrated 5000+ from qpopper years ago. Dovecot is sooo much better on
system load. Yes, locking and timeouts are in the config file.


 3) can dovecot pop3 be configured so that it will allow download of
 emails
 only of the last say 15 days ie even if the same pop3 user is
 configure on
 another machine it will download only messages of the last 15 days

That's not part of pop3, so no, it's not possible with dovecot alone.
You could probably work out a plugin to move read mail after x days, or
there may be one out there ? Or some imap robot could do it..
Ken A.
Pacific.Net


 I can't answer this, but if this is an attempt to prevent mass download,
 the answer to 1+4 makes these questions irrelevant.
 
 Joseph Tam jtam.h...@gmail.com
 

-- 
Ken Anderson
Pacific Internet - http://www.pacific.net
Latest Pacific.Net Status - http://twitter.com/pacnetstatus


[Dovecot] migration to dovecot pop3

2012-12-19 Thread Rajesh M
hi

i am planning to migrate from qmail pop3 to dovecot pop3

the number of users on the server is large over 5000

also data volume is large - over 3.5 tb -- ie many users several 1000s of
emails in their inbox

email clients used are outlook / outlook express / windows mail, etc

my questions

1) will the migration cause all the emails on the server to re-download

2) can dovecot be configured to allow only one download at a time - pop3
locking with time out setting that can be customized

3) can dovecot pop3 be configured so that it will allow download of emails
only of the last say 15 days ie even if the same pop3 user is configure on
another machine it will download only messages of the last 15 days

4) has anybody migrated from qmail pop3 to dovecot pop3 successfully
without emails being downloaded again

thankyou very much in advance

rajesh






Re: [Dovecot] migration to dovecot pop3

2012-12-19 Thread Joseph Tam

Rajesh M writes:


i am planning to migrate from qmail pop3 to dovecot pop3

the number of users on the server is large over 5000
...
also data volume is large - over 3.5 tb -- ie many users several 1000s of
emails in their inbox


If you stay on the list, you might find some people here whose
mail metrics are several orders of magnitude larger than this.


1) will the migration cause all the emails on the server to re-download
...
4) has anybody migrated from qmail pop3 to dovecot pop3 successfully
without emails being downloaded again


A proper migration will avoid this.  Google is your friend

http://lmgtfy.com/q=POP+qmail+to+dovecot+migration

The top hits provide exactly what you're looking for.


2) can dovecot be configured to allow only one download at a time - pop3
locking with time out setting that can be customized

3) can dovecot pop3 be configured so that it will allow download of emails
only of the last say 15 days ie even if the same pop3 user is configure on
another machine it will download only messages of the last 15 days


I can't answer this, but if this is an attempt to prevent mass download,
the answer to 1+4 makes these questions irrelevant.

Joseph Tam jtam.h...@gmail.com