Re: imapsieve: script not triggered
Hello!
Sorry for replying on this quite old thread, but I just found the issue in my
config and would like to share it if anyone else is having the same problem.
My passdb is ldap-based and I included a possibility to enable extra
mail_plugins via LDAP (I used it for debug purposes).
There was the line:
pass_attrs = userPassword=password,=userdb_mail_plugins=%{ldap:mailPlugins}
Which caused the problem.
It seems like these setting does not added enabled plugins to IMAP but
overwrote all other mail_plugins settings. Unfortunately just adding
“$mail_plugins” does not work here as well, so I had to add all my plugins here
manually.
Hope this help someone!
Best,
Andreas
> On 8. May 2018, at 08:53, Andreas Krischer wrote:
>
>> Check that sieve-test actually shows it would do what you expect it to do.
>
> sieve-test just shows: learn-spam: error: the imapsieve extension cannot be
> used outside IMAP.
>
> Andreas
>
>> Am 07.05.2018 um 20:56 schrieb Aki Tuomi > >:
>>
>>
>>
>> On 2018-05-07 20:58, Andreas Krischer wrote:
>>> Hi, folks!
>>>
>>> My problem:
>>> I set up dovecot with imapsieve to execute a script whenever a user copies
>>> a mail to his Spam folder (spam autolearning). Unfortunately this script is
>>> never executed regardless what I’m configuring for imapsieve. It looks like
>>> dovecot doesn’t really load the plugin…
>>>
>>> The "dovecot -n" output is attached.
>>>
>>> I already tried setting imapsieve_mailbox1_name to *, but even this does
>>> not execute the script… Also I tried a mailbox without mail_crypt enabled,
>>> no success as well.
>>>
>>> In the attached mail.log (mail_debug=yes) you can see, that
>>> imap_sieve_plugin is loaded, but it isn’t really executed.
>>>
>>> The normal (LMTP) sieve is working - if a mail is incoming the sieve module
>>> shows it work in mail.log:
>>>
>>> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name
>>> ): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve:
>>> file storage: Storage path `/var/vmail/myhost.name/postmaster/sieve' not
>>> found
>>> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name
>>> ): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve:
>>> file storage: Storage path
>>> `/var/vmail/myhost.name/postmaster/.dovecot.sieve' not found
>>> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name
>>> ): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve:
>>> storage: No default script location configured
>>> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name
>>> ): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve:
>>> User has no personal script
>>> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name
>>> ): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve:
>>> file storage: Using script storage path: /etc/dovecot/sieve/after/
>>> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name
>>> ): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve:
>>> file script: Opened script `spam' from `/etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.sieve'
>>> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name
>>> ): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve:
>>> executed after user's Sieve script(1): /etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.sieve
>>> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name
>>> ): Debug: Mailbox : Opened mail
>>> UID=1 because: header Message-ID (Cache file is unusable)
>>> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name
>>> ): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve:
>>> Opening script 1 of 1 from `/etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.sieve'
>>> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name
>>> ): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve:
>>> Loading script /etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.sieve
>>> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name
>>> ): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve:
>>> Script binary /etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.svbin successfully loaded
>>> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name
>>> ): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve:
>>> binary save: not saving binary /etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.svbin, because
>>> it is already stored
>>> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name
>>> ): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve:
>>> Executing script from `/etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.svbin'
>>>
>>>
>>> I already spent hours on this problem so please let me know if you have any
>>> idea what the problem could be… :(
>>>
>>> Thanks in advance!
>>>
>>> Andreas
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>
>> Check that sieve-test actually shows it would do what you expect it to do.
>>
>> Aki
Re: imapsieve: script not triggered
* Andreas Krischer 2018.05.07 19:58: > sieve_global_extensions = +vnd.dovecot.pipe Hi, my working configuration looks like this: sieve_global_extensions = +vnd.dovecot.pipe +vnd.dovecot.execute Regards Thomas signature.asc Description: PGP signature
Re: imapsieve: script not triggered
> Check that sieve-test actually shows it would do what you expect it to do. sieve-test just shows: learn-spam: error: the imapsieve extension cannot be used outside IMAP. Andreas > Am 07.05.2018 um 20:56 schrieb Aki Tuomi : > > > > On 2018-05-07 20:58, Andreas Krischer wrote: >> Hi, folks! >> >> My problem: >> I set up dovecot with imapsieve to execute a script whenever a user copies a >> mail to his Spam folder (spam autolearning). Unfortunately this script is >> never executed regardless what I’m configuring for imapsieve. It looks like >> dovecot doesn’t really load the plugin… >> >> The "dovecot -n" output is attached. >> >> I already tried setting imapsieve_mailbox1_name to *, but even this does not >> execute the script… Also I tried a mailbox without mail_crypt enabled, no >> success as well. >> >> In the attached mail.log (mail_debug=yes) you can see, that >> imap_sieve_plugin is loaded, but it isn’t really executed. >> >> The normal (LMTP) sieve is working - if a mail is incoming the sieve module >> shows it work in mail.log: >> >> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: >> YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: file storage: Storage path >> `/var/vmail/myhost.name/postmaster/sieve' not found >> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: >> YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: file storage: Storage path >> `/var/vmail/myhost.name/postmaster/.dovecot.sieve' not found >> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: >> YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: storage: No default script location configured >> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: >> YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: User has no personal script >> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: >> YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: file storage: Using script storage path: >> /etc/dovecot/sieve/after/ >> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: >> YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: file script: Opened script `spam' from >> `/etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.sieve' >> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: >> YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: executed after user's Sieve script(1): >> /etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.sieve >> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: >> Mailbox : Opened mail UID=1 because: header Message-ID (Cache >> file is unusable) >> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: >> YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: Opening script 1 of 1 from >> `/etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.sieve' >> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: >> YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: Loading script >> /etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.sieve >> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: >> YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: Script binary >> /etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.svbin successfully loaded >> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: >> YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: binary save: not saving binary >> /etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.svbin, because it is already stored >> May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: >> YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: Executing script from >> `/etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.svbin' >> >> >> I already spent hours on this problem so please let me know if you have any >> idea what the problem could be… :( >> >> Thanks in advance! >> >> Andreas >> >> >> > > Check that sieve-test actually shows it would do what you expect it to do. > > Aki
Re: imapsieve: script not triggered
On 2018-05-07 20:58, Andreas Krischer wrote: Hi, folks! My problem: I set up dovecot with imapsieve to execute a script whenever a user copies a mail to his Spam folder (spam autolearning). Unfortunately this script is never executed regardless what I’m configuring for imapsieve. It looks like dovecot doesn’t really load the plugin… The "dovecot -n" output is attached. I already tried setting imapsieve_mailbox1_name to *, but even this does not execute the script… Also I tried a mailbox without mail_crypt enabled, no success as well. In the attached mail.log (mail_debug=yes) you can see, that imap_sieve_plugin is loaded, but it isn’t really executed. The normal (LMTP) sieve is working - if a mail is incoming the sieve module shows it work in mail.log: May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: file storage: Storage path `/var/vmail/myhost.name/postmaster/sieve' not found May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: file storage: Storage path `/var/vmail/myhost.name/postmaster/.dovecot.sieve' not found May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: storage: No default script location configured May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: User has no personal script May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: file storage: Using script storage path: /etc/dovecot/sieve/after/ May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: file script: Opened script `spam' from `/etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.sieve' May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: executed after user's Sieve script(1): /etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.sieve May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: Mailbox : Opened mail UID=1 because: header Message-ID (Cache file is unusable) May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: Opening script 1 of 1 from `/etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.sieve' May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: Loading script /etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.sieve May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: Script binary /etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.svbin successfully loaded May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: binary save: not saving binary /etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.svbin, because it is already stored May 7 17:54:04 dovecot dovecot: lmtp(postmas...@myhost.name): Debug: YEm9ILyS8FqSaAAAujt/SA: sieve: Executing script from `/etc/dovecot/sieve/after/spam.svbin' I already spent hours on this problem so please let me know if you have any idea what the problem could be… :( Thanks in advance! Andreas Check that sieve-test actually shows it would do what you expect it to do. Aki
