Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
(sorry for the top posting) It looks like I've found a fix. Look at http://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=578883 Thanks, Mounir Damien Sandras wrote: > Le mercredi 01 avril 2009 à 19:52 -0400, Mounir Lamouri a écrit : >> Hi, >> >> I'm the -not yet official- Gentoo package maintainer of ekiga-3 and I >> have an issue I can't resolve. This issue looks to be linked with >> ekiga-3.2 (or opal-3.6.1 ?). >> >> Here is the symptoms : >> - I launch ekiga-3.2 and a SIP service I have is registering correctly >> _but_ ekiga.net SIP service doesn't work. >> - I can use my other SIP service but I can't use ekiga.net SIP service. >> >> You can argue I'm using Gentoo and some compilation flag just break it BUT: >> - When I try to use ekiga at my univeristy both SIP services are working. >> and >> - My girlfriend, at home, can use ekiga-3.0.2 for Windows with the >> ekiga.net SIP service. >> >> In my last place (just moved in) I was not able to make ekiga-3.1 >> registering to ekiga.net but ekiga-3.0.2 was. >> >> I'm surely not alone with this issue. >> Two weeks ago, a user write on this list complaining about the same >> issue [1] and no one give him an answer. >> In the Gentoo bug dedicated to ekiga-3, some guys complained about the >> same issue [2]. >> >> I think ekiga or opal changed something about connection but I can't get >> what. I can't change my router configuration because I'm using a >> residential connection. However, even if it's linked to some port >> forwarding, we can consider having it working with 3.0.2 and not working >> with 3.1/3.2 is surely a regression bug. >> >> Can someone give a hint about this issues ? >> >> Thank you, >> Mounir / volkmar >> >> [1] http://mail.gnome.org/archives/ekiga-list/2009-March/msg00190.html >> [2] http://bugs.gentoo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=238554#c110 (starting from >> this comment) > > What is the reason why it does not register? Can you post a -d 4 > output ? ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
2009/4/9 Mounir Lamouri : > > @Bent : you should re-try without the debug flag just to be sure. > I will do that. Bent ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
2009/4/9 Damien Sandras : > > Probably not using 'debug' removes a few flags that are really required. > That's up to the Gentoo packager to fix that. > I will use the logging capabilities of Portage (the Gentoo package manager) to take a look at the differences between the debug and the non-debug versions. I should be able to get at both the ./configure calls and the summaries that opal and ekiga give at the end of the configure phase. More later. Bent ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
Damien Sandras wrote: > Le jeudi 09 avril 2009 à 10:58 +0200, Bent a écrit : >> 2009/4/9 Eugen Dedu : >> >>> Bent, you say that you have stun enabled, which is not the case for Mounir. >>> Bent, could you send us your -d 4 as well? Mounir, could you resend the >>> output (it is not available anymore on the site)? >> As per Mounir's request I rebuilt ekiga (and ptlib & opal) with the >> debug option enabled and the funny thing is that now ekiga registers >> perfectly with ekiga.net. What is going on here??? It is probably not >> worth sending the d -4 output now? >> >> Today is a holiday here in enmark, and we are having a family lunch in >> a couple of hours, so I will not be able to work much more on this >> today. Please bear with me. >> > > Probably not using 'debug' removes a few flags that are really required. > That's up to the Gentoo packager to fix that. It is not. I can't register in debug nor in release. @Bent : you should re-try without the debug flag just to be sure. > I think that you should be able to execute Ekiga -d 4 even with a > non-debug build. > > The debug build should be useful to track down crashes. The normal build > should still allow to debug sip traces. Actually, with a regular ptlib installed yes. But the Gentoo ptlib package remove the tracing by default except if debug has been enabled. I will work on it in a few days. I've no time for the moment. Thanks, Mounir ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
Le jeudi 09 avril 2009 à 10:58 +0200, Bent a écrit : > 2009/4/9 Eugen Dedu : > > > Bent, you say that you have stun enabled, which is not the case for Mounir. > > Bent, could you send us your -d 4 as well? Mounir, could you resend the > > output (it is not available anymore on the site)? > > As per Mounir's request I rebuilt ekiga (and ptlib & opal) with the > debug option enabled and the funny thing is that now ekiga registers > perfectly with ekiga.net. What is going on here??? It is probably not > worth sending the d -4 output now? > > Today is a holiday here in enmark, and we are having a family lunch in > a couple of hours, so I will not be able to work much more on this > today. Please bear with me. > Probably not using 'debug' removes a few flags that are really required. That's up to the Gentoo packager to fix that. I think that you should be able to execute Ekiga -d 4 even with a non-debug build. The debug build should be useful to track down crashes. The normal build should still allow to debug sip traces. -- _ Damien Sandras (o- //\Ekiga Softphone : http://www.ekiga.org/ v_/_ Be IP : http://www.beip.be/ FOSDEM : http://www.fosdem.org/ SIP Phone : sip:dsand...@ekiga.net ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
2009/4/9 Eugen Dedu : > Bent, you say that you have stun enabled, which is not the case for Mounir. > Bent, could you send us your -d 4 as well? Mounir, could you resend the > output (it is not available anymore on the site)? As per Mounir's request I rebuilt ekiga (and ptlib & opal) with the debug option enabled and the funny thing is that now ekiga registers perfectly with ekiga.net. What is going on here??? It is probably not worth sending the d -4 output now? Today is a holiday here in enmark, and we are having a family lunch in a couple of hours, so I will not be able to work much more on this today. Please bear with me. Kind regards Bent ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
Damien Sandras wrote: Le mercredi 01 avril 2009 à 19:52 -0400, Mounir Lamouri a écrit : Hi, I'm the -not yet official- Gentoo package maintainer of ekiga-3 and I have an issue I can't resolve. This issue looks to be linked with ekiga-3.2 (or opal-3.6.1 ?). Here is the symptoms : - I launch ekiga-3.2 and a SIP service I have is registering correctly _but_ ekiga.net SIP service doesn't work. - I can use my other SIP service but I can't use ekiga.net SIP service. You can argue I'm using Gentoo and some compilation flag just break it BUT: - When I try to use ekiga at my univeristy both SIP services are working. and - My girlfriend, at home, can use ekiga-3.0.2 for Windows with the ekiga.net SIP service. In my last place (just moved in) I was not able to make ekiga-3.1 registering to ekiga.net but ekiga-3.0.2 was. I'm surely not alone with this issue. Two weeks ago, a user write on this list complaining about the same issue [1] and no one give him an answer. In the Gentoo bug dedicated to ekiga-3, some guys complained about the same issue [2]. I think ekiga or opal changed something about connection but I can't get what. I can't change my router configuration because I'm using a residential connection. However, even if it's linked to some port forwarding, we can consider having it working with 3.0.2 and not working with 3.1/3.2 is surely a regression bug. Can someone give a hint about this issues ? Thank you, Mounir / volkmar [1] http://mail.gnome.org/archives/ekiga-list/2009-March/msg00190.html [2] http://bugs.gentoo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=238554#c110 (starting from this comment) What is the reason why it does not register? Can you post a -d 4 output ? Bent, you say that you have stun enabled, which is not the case for Mounir. Bent, could you send us your -d 4 as well? Mounir, could you resend the output (it is not available anymore on the site)? -- Eugen ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
Le mercredi 01 avril 2009 à 19:52 -0400, Mounir Lamouri a écrit : > Hi, > > I'm the -not yet official- Gentoo package maintainer of ekiga-3 and I > have an issue I can't resolve. This issue looks to be linked with > ekiga-3.2 (or opal-3.6.1 ?). > > Here is the symptoms : > - I launch ekiga-3.2 and a SIP service I have is registering correctly > _but_ ekiga.net SIP service doesn't work. > - I can use my other SIP service but I can't use ekiga.net SIP service. > > You can argue I'm using Gentoo and some compilation flag just break it BUT: > - When I try to use ekiga at my univeristy both SIP services are working. > and > - My girlfriend, at home, can use ekiga-3.0.2 for Windows with the > ekiga.net SIP service. > > In my last place (just moved in) I was not able to make ekiga-3.1 > registering to ekiga.net but ekiga-3.0.2 was. > > I'm surely not alone with this issue. > Two weeks ago, a user write on this list complaining about the same > issue [1] and no one give him an answer. > In the Gentoo bug dedicated to ekiga-3, some guys complained about the > same issue [2]. > > I think ekiga or opal changed something about connection but I can't get > what. I can't change my router configuration because I'm using a > residential connection. However, even if it's linked to some port > forwarding, we can consider having it working with 3.0.2 and not working > with 3.1/3.2 is surely a regression bug. > > Can someone give a hint about this issues ? > > Thank you, > Mounir / volkmar > > [1] http://mail.gnome.org/archives/ekiga-list/2009-March/msg00190.html > [2] http://bugs.gentoo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=238554#c110 (starting from > this comment) What is the reason why it does not register? Can you post a -d 4 output ? -- _ Damien Sandras (o- //\Ekiga Softphone : http://www.ekiga.org/ v_/_ Be IP : http://www.beip.be/ FOSDEM : http://www.fosdem.org/ SIP Phone : sip:dsand...@ekiga.net ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
2009/4/8 Mounir Lamouri : > > Did you build ekiga with USE="debug" ? > Otherwise, ekiga -d doesn't work. > It dawned upon me in the shower this morning that that was the case. I'll rebuild ekiga. ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
Bent wrote: > An interesting(?) addendum: > > ekiga -d 4 > > does not produce any output whatsoever. Did you build ekiga with USE="debug" ? Otherwise, ekiga -d doesn't work. Thanks, Mounir ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
An interesting(?) addendum: ekiga -d 4 does not produce any output whatsoever. Bent ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
I can only sustain Mounir's observations. I have build an Ekiga 3.2.0 using Mounir's Gentoo ebuild and the behavior is exactly as described by Mounir. It registers immediately and without problems at my own Asterisk. The attempt to register with ekiga.net fails. The Ekiga status line simply says *Could not register be...@ekiga.net' A trace with wireshark is more revealing: Ekiga sends a REGISTER frame *with the private address*. Ekiga.net replies with a '606 Not Acceptable' which is quite OK in this situation. But why is the private address used? STUN *is* enabled in the configuration but apparently doesn't do its job. Any comments, anybody? Bent PS I have all kinds of problems with both audio and video, but I will come back to them later. All of this (including the registration) works well in ekiga 3.0.2 All in all it appears that 3.2.0 was released a bit prematurely. ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
Mounir Lamouri wrote: Eugen Dedu wrote: Mounir Lamouri wrote: No answer since some days (and output sent a few days ago). Should I file a bug ? I have not sent your output when "you arrive at home"... I sent it but the attached file was very large and I receive a "message needs to be moderated" message. I suppose it never has. You should find the log here : http://dpaste.com/25304/ Hi Mounir, I looked at our output. First, I see several assertion failed inside, from gmconf /apps/ekiga keys. Do you know how does it happen that this key for ex. is not string??? What is its value? ** (ekiga:24853): CRITICAL **: entry_get_string: assertion `gmconf key /apps/ekiga/general/personal_data/short_status is of type GM_CONF_STRING' failed Second, I think the problem is that the address you request registration from is private, look: 2009/04/03 18:04:03.386 0:00.980 subscriber:0x495b54b0 SIP Sending PDU (550 bytes) to: rem=udp$86.64.162.35:5060,local=udp$192.168.1.62:5060,if=192.168.1.62%wlan0 REGISTER sip:ekiga.net SIP/2.0 Route: CSeq: 2 REGISTER Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 192.168.1.62:5060;branch=z9hG4bK42270903-091f-de11-8176-00112494cbef;rport Ekiga cannot accept private addresses. It seems the same problem was with Ren Min. It is important I think to understand: - why this happens - how to inform the user about that <- I will think about that Note that mee too I use a internet box (freebox, as you) and use private address for my machine and the freebox does NAT, however, my line is: Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 82.238.108.175:5060;branch=z9hG4bK8a32fd1c--de11-83ec-001b639fea73;rport so it does not put my private address, but my public one. I notice also in your output that stun is not used. Could you look at preferences, general, general settings that disable net detection is off? Anyway, the problem with your setup is that all the gmconf keys seem unreadable (see the assertions above)!! Before doing anything else, could you save your ekiga gmconf keys (/apps/ekiga) to have this "bug" reproducible? Cheers, Eugen ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
On Tue, Apr 7, 2009 at 2:37 AM, Damien Sandras wrote: > Le lundi 06 avril 2009 à 21:07 +0200, Julien Puydt a écrit : >> Mounir Lamouri a écrit : >> > No answer since some days (and output sent a few days ago). >> > Should I file a bug ? >> >> Yes : no answer means nobody has found the time to answer. Bugzilla will >> make sure it's not lost. > > No : bugzilla is for bugs, not for setup help. If nobody answered, that > means nobody had the time to answer. How can you consider something to be (only) setup related when it was working with previous versions (3.0.2 and 2.*) and when it is concerning not one or two people but more ? I'm sure it's related to setup somehow (otherwise it will not work from university) but there must be something that has been changed somewhere in ekiga opal or ptlib that make the registration failing. Thanks, Mounir ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
Le lundi 06 avril 2009 à 21:07 +0200, Julien Puydt a écrit : > Mounir Lamouri a écrit : > > No answer since some days (and output sent a few days ago). > > Should I file a bug ? > > Yes : no answer means nobody has found the time to answer. Bugzilla will > make sure it's not lost. No : bugzilla is for bugs, not for setup help. If nobody answered, that means nobody had the time to answer. -- _ Damien Sandras (o- //\Ekiga Softphone : http://www.ekiga.org/ v_/_ Be IP : http://www.beip.be/ FOSDEM : http://www.fosdem.org/ SIP Phone : sip:dsand...@ekiga.net ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
Eugen Dedu wrote: > Mounir Lamouri wrote: >> No answer since some days (and output sent a few days ago). >> Should I file a bug ? > > I have not sent your output when "you arrive at home"... > I sent it but the attached file was very large and I receive a "message needs to be moderated" message. I suppose it never has. You should find the log here : http://dpaste.com/25304/ Thanks, Mounir ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
Mounir Lamouri wrote: No answer since some days (and output sent a few days ago). Should I file a bug ? I have not sent your output when "you arrive at home"... -- Eugen ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
Mounir Lamouri a écrit : No answer since some days (and output sent a few days ago). Should I file a bug ? Yes : no answer means nobody has found the time to answer. Bugzilla will make sure it's not lost. Thanks, Snark on #ekiga ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
No answer since some days (and output sent a few days ago). Should I file a bug ? Thanks, Mounir ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
Hi, On Fri, Apr 3, 2009 at 12:03 PM, Bent wrote: > Hi Mounir > > What overlay is Ekiga 3 in? The version on packages.gentoo.org is > 2.0.12. I'm a Gentoo user too and have my own Asterisk, so I have some > freedom in how to test e.g. Ekiga. You will found ekiga 3.0.2 and ekiga 3.2.0 in the voip overlay (layman -a voip). They are masked (as opal and ptlib versions) so you will have to unmask net-libs/ptlib net-libs/opal and net-im/ekiga > I have Ekiga 3.0.2 (build from the sources on ekiga.org) running and > am willing to give Ekiga 3.1 some testing om my setup if I could get a > suitable ebuild for it. Hope the ebuilds we provide in the voip overlay will help you. Thanks, Mounir ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
Hi Mounir What overlay is Ekiga 3 in? The version on packages.gentoo.org is 2.0.12. I'm a Gentoo user too and have my own Asterisk, so I have some freedom in how to test e.g. Ekiga. I have Ekiga 3.0.2 (build from the sources on ekiga.org) running and am willing to give Ekiga 3.1 some testing om my setup if I could get a suitable ebuild for it. Kind regards, Bent ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
On Thu, Apr 2, 2009 at 6:48 AM, Eugen Dedu wrote: > For [2]: should the xcap patch be applied upstream? What is the relation > between (first comments of) [2] and connection issues? Actually, some comment below this one are complaining about connection issues. > Could you attach the -d 4 output for 3.2.0? I will when I will be back home but when I was investigating about this issue, I didn't find anything useful. I hope you will. Thanks, Mounir ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
Re: [Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
Mounir Lamouri wrote: Hi, I'm the -not yet official- Gentoo package maintainer of ekiga-3 and I have an issue I can't resolve. This issue looks to be linked with ekiga-3.2 (or opal-3.6.1 ?). Here is the symptoms : - I launch ekiga-3.2 and a SIP service I have is registering correctly _but_ ekiga.net SIP service doesn't work. - I can use my other SIP service but I can't use ekiga.net SIP service. You can argue I'm using Gentoo and some compilation flag just break it BUT: - When I try to use ekiga at my univeristy both SIP services are working. and - My girlfriend, at home, can use ekiga-3.0.2 for Windows with the ekiga.net SIP service. In my last place (just moved in) I was not able to make ekiga-3.1 registering to ekiga.net but ekiga-3.0.2 was. I'm surely not alone with this issue. Two weeks ago, a user write on this list complaining about the same issue [1] and no one give him an answer. In the Gentoo bug dedicated to ekiga-3, some guys complained about the same issue [2]. I think ekiga or opal changed something about connection but I can't get what. I can't change my router configuration because I'm using a residential connection. However, even if it's linked to some port forwarding, we can consider having it working with 3.0.2 and not working with 3.1/3.2 is surely a regression bug. Can someone give a hint about this issues ? Thank you, Mounir / volkmar [1] http://mail.gnome.org/archives/ekiga-list/2009-March/msg00190.html [2] http://bugs.gentoo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=238554#c110 (starting from this comment) Hi Mounir, In [1] the problem, as shown in the answers, is that it tries to register a private address. The question (bug?) is why does it try to register with this address? I have just replied to that post, hoping it can be solved... For [2]: should the xcap patch be applied upstream? What is the relation between (first comments of) [2] and connection issues? Could you attach the -d 4 output for 3.2.0? -- Eugen ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
[Ekiga-list] Could not register (Requested terminated) w/ ekiga-3.2
Hi, I'm the -not yet official- Gentoo package maintainer of ekiga-3 and I have an issue I can't resolve. This issue looks to be linked with ekiga-3.2 (or opal-3.6.1 ?). Here is the symptoms : - I launch ekiga-3.2 and a SIP service I have is registering correctly _but_ ekiga.net SIP service doesn't work. - I can use my other SIP service but I can't use ekiga.net SIP service. You can argue I'm using Gentoo and some compilation flag just break it BUT: - When I try to use ekiga at my univeristy both SIP services are working. and - My girlfriend, at home, can use ekiga-3.0.2 for Windows with the ekiga.net SIP service. In my last place (just moved in) I was not able to make ekiga-3.1 registering to ekiga.net but ekiga-3.0.2 was. I'm surely not alone with this issue. Two weeks ago, a user write on this list complaining about the same issue [1] and no one give him an answer. In the Gentoo bug dedicated to ekiga-3, some guys complained about the same issue [2]. I think ekiga or opal changed something about connection but I can't get what. I can't change my router configuration because I'm using a residential connection. However, even if it's linked to some port forwarding, we can consider having it working with 3.0.2 and not working with 3.1/3.2 is surely a regression bug. Can someone give a hint about this issues ? Thank you, Mounir / volkmar [1] http://mail.gnome.org/archives/ekiga-list/2009-March/msg00190.html [2] http://bugs.gentoo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=238554#c110 (starting from this comment) ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
