Re:olympic cruelty ?

2000-09-01 Thread Mary Thurman
This message is from: Mary Thurman [EMAIL PROTECTED]


--- Karen McCarthy [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 This message is from: Karen McCarthy
 [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  
 Just had to jump into the fray...having evented up
 to Prelim level ages ago, 
 and knowing what amount of training these horses and
 riders go though, to 
 malign the whole sport because of overwrought
 reporting of a few 
 unfortuinate accidents is really unfair. 
 Yes, there are a few bad actors in every equestrian
 sport, at every level, 
 and always will be.  
 Need to mention that TB racing on the whole is
 really pretty unsavory - in 
 college I worked a couple of summers on the Calif
 Fair circuit 
 Don't forget that there is a reason that there is a
 huge market for all the 
 joint and soft tissue related products...  Used to
be 
 a horse was in his prime as a using ranch horse, say
 from age 7+  Nowadays a 
 horse of this age is a rarity  
 I am not saying that if a horse is carefully brought
 along it will always be 
 100% sound. No, there will always be physical side
 effects,  
 As I see it, the crime being comitted here folks, is
 that these horses are 
 being asked to do high level tasks, in a minimum of
 time, due primarily to 
 our crowded lives, and our desire to have it all,
 right NOW.
 When you see someone competing sucessfully year
 after year, at the upper 
 levels with their own horses, the same horses, for
 themselves and not some 
 barn or sponsor, you just know that their horses are
 really living up to 
 their full competitive potential - happily, soundly.

Karen,

Very well put.  Hooray for you for having the 'guts'
to say what many of us have suspected or known for
years.  Nothing is EVER black or white - accidents do
happen no matter how well trained or well prepared you
are.  But the number of unsound horses - young(under 8
years old) horses - is really a crime these days! 
Seems no one has 'time to take time' any more   - to
quote one well-known clinician.  A horse is supposed
to last you a lifetime, not be 'used up' in a couple
of years and 'thrown away' in favor of a younger,
faster, prettier one. 

No apology needed here for your trip to the 'soap
box'.

Mary  

=
Mary Thurman
Raintree Farms
[EMAIL PROTECTED]



__
Do You Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail - Free email you can access from anywhere!
http://mail.yahoo.com/



Re:olympic cruelty ?

2000-08-31 Thread Karen McCarthy

This message is from: Karen McCarthy [EMAIL PROTECTED]




...  I adore watching dressage and
also team penning and cutting.  I want to see the reining competition..


Just had to jump into the fray...having evented up to Prelim level ages ago, 
and knowing what amount of training these horses and riders go though, to 
malign the whole sport because of overwrought reporting of a few 
unfortuinate accidents is really unfair.I really think the sport of eventing 
has been tightened up in the past 10 years.
Yes, there are a few bad actors in every equestrian sport, at every level, 
and always will be. Keeping your nose clean and not placing unrealistic 
demands on you and your horse is half the equation in training for any 
competitive sport, along with a quality horse and good skills.
Need to mention that TB racing on the whole is really pretty unsavory - in 
college I worked a couple of summers on the Calif Fair circuit, and geez! 
that was a real eye opening experience, to say the least. I worked for one 
trainer who was as rotten as they come (quit at day 3), then I was very 
lucky to work for a hispanic trainer who limited his barn to 6 horses only, 
and really spent quality time not just conditioning these young horses, (he 
specialised in maiden horses), but training them, basiclly giving them a 
whole education, not just a quick trip to the gate. His horses were a joy to 
work with,good ground manners, he recognised their indiviuality, etc.
Don't forget that there is a reason that there is a huge market for all the 
joint and soft tissue related products...take the very popular sport of 
reining and working cowhorse events. How many aged events do you see that 
are highly promoted? Not many horses left to enter these events! Used to be 
a horse was in his prime as a using ranch horse, say from age 7+  Nowadays a 
horse of this age is a rarity - as they just don't last that long, due to 
starting them as 2 year olds in order to make the futurities, which is so 
ironiclly named, as what kind of a future is it, as a 4 year old horse with 
blown hocks???
I am not saying that if a horse is carefully brought along it will always be 
100% sound. No, there will always be physical side effects, but not on such 
a huge scale as is seen in todays competitive world.
As I see it, the crime being comitted here folks, is that these horses are 
being asked to do high level tasks, in a minimum of time, due primarily to 
our crowded lives, and our desire to have it all, right NOW.
When you see someone competing sucessfully year after year, at the upper 
levels with their own horses, the same horses, for themselves and not some 
barn or sponsor, you just know that their horses are really living up to 
their full competitive potential - happily, soundly.


OK, end of sermon on the soapbox..

Karen
Carson City,NV
_
Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com.

Share information about yourself, create your own public profile at 
http://profiles.msn.com.