[FOSSology] NOMOS - how to find differences compared to license templates?

2011-04-15 Thread Dabrowski, Ivo
Dear all,

FOSSology is a great tool to identify license texts in source code. The - now 
deprecated - bSAM algorithm allows to analyze the differences between license 
templates and the actual license texts in source code files. I couldn't find 
the corresponding functionality using the NOMOS agent.

How can I find additions or deletions in the source code license texts compared 
to the stored license templates using NOMOS? For example, if there is an 
additional not included in legally critical places? As stated on your how to 
interpret site under Percent of Match, verification should be possible.

Thank you and best regards

Ivo Dabrowski


___
fossology mailing list
fossology@fossology.org
http://fossology.org/mailman/listinfo/fossology


Re: [FOSSology] NOMOS - how to find differences compared to license templates?

2011-04-15 Thread Raino Lintulampi
Hi Ivo,
 How can I find additions or deletions in the source code license texts
 compared to the stored license templates using NOMOS? For example, if there
 is an additional not included in legally critical places? As stated on
 your how to interpret site under Percent of Match, verification should
 be possible.

You can't. Nomos does not use templates but short text strings
from licenses. See http://www.fossology.org/nomos for further
information.

What could be done with nomos is similar approach as is used
with copyright agent. With copyright agent you can view the
identified text string location in the file. In rare cases that kind of
feature would have helped when it has been unclear why nomos
claimed the file to have f.ex. GPL license. (GPL reference text
has been in the middle or end of the file). But that would not tell
how the text in file differs from the reference license text.

My experience is that nomos is working very well. Old bsam results
are left in database so if you have doubt you can make comparison
with bsam results and nomos results.

Best regards
Raino

 Thank you and best regards

 Ivo Dabrowski


 ___
 fossology mailing list
 fossology@fossology.org
 http://fossology.org/mailman/listinfo/fossology


___
fossology mailing list
fossology@fossology.org
http://fossology.org/mailman/listinfo/fossology


Re: [FOSSology] NOMOS - how to find differences compared to license templates?

2011-04-15 Thread Laser, Mary
Thanks for answering this email Raino.  You are right on the mark.

Mary

 -Original Message-
 From: fossology-boun...@fossology.org [mailto:fossology-
 boun...@fossology.org] On Behalf Of Raino Lintulampi
 Sent: Friday, April 15, 2011 5:25 AM
 To: Dabrowski, Ivo
 Cc: fossology@fossology.org
 Subject: Re: [FOSSology] NOMOS - how to find differences compared to
 license templates?
 
 Hi Ivo,
  How can I find additions or deletions in the source code license
 texts
  compared to the stored license templates using NOMOS? For example, if
 there
  is an additional not included in legally critical places? As stated
 on
  your how to interpret site under Percent of Match, verification
 should
  be possible.
 
 You can't. Nomos does not use templates but short text strings
 from licenses. See http://www.fossology.org/nomos for further
 information.
 
 What could be done with nomos is similar approach as is used
 with copyright agent. With copyright agent you can view the
 identified text string location in the file. In rare cases that kind of
 feature would have helped when it has been unclear why nomos
 claimed the file to have f.ex. GPL license. (GPL reference text
 has been in the middle or end of the file). But that would not tell
 how the text in file differs from the reference license text.
 
 My experience is that nomos is working very well. Old bsam results
 are left in database so if you have doubt you can make comparison
 with bsam results and nomos results.
 
 Best regards
 Raino
 
  Thank you and best regards
 
  Ivo Dabrowski
 
 
  ___
  fossology mailing list
  fossology@fossology.org
  http://fossology.org/mailman/listinfo/fossology
 
 
 ___
 fossology mailing list
 fossology@fossology.org
 http://fossology.org/mailman/listinfo/fossology
___
fossology mailing list
fossology@fossology.org
http://fossology.org/mailman/listinfo/fossology