Plain text posting

2002-07-09 Thread vizion communication

Hi

I have noticed an increased tendency of a few people to post
to plain text lists using attachments.

Quite apart from minor irritations such as increased
bandwidth and the necessity to open attachments some people
seem to have the mistaken impression that the practise of
sending messages via a PGP signed attachments somehow adds
to general recipient security rather than diminish it by
encouraging careless attachment usage.

It may be important to remember the general principle that
the customary opening of attachments is inherently more
risky than a plain text message for the recipent even when
PGP signed. The less secure the operating system of the
immediate recipent the more risky the practice. Viruses,
which may not be able to infect a primary recipient often
reach their targets by being forwared from a primary to a
secondary recipent on a more vulnerable platform.

PGP only tells us that the message has not changed in
transit. A malformed/abusive/virus laden attachment is still
malformed/abusive/virus laden even if PGP signed.

Can we please stick to plain text UNLESS the material cannot
reasonably be transmitted without being in attachment form.
There is no benefit to be gained from attachments otherwise.

Thanks

David


To Unsubscribe: send mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with unsubscribe freebsd-stable in the body of the message



Re: Plain text posting

2002-07-09 Thread Robin . Melville

At 7:48 am -0700 9/7/02, vizion communication wrote:
Hi
[...snip...]
Can we please stick to plain text UNLESS the material cannot
reasonably be transmitted without being in attachment form.
There is no benefit to be gained from attachments otherwise.

I heartily concur. An additional problem is in message digests where 
the relationship between the attachment and the original message is 
lost. One finds onself scrolling through reams of base64.

Robin.


-- 
Robin Melville, Information manager
Addiction  Forensic Information Service
Nottingham Healthcare NHS Tust
Tel:  +44 (0)115 952 9478   Fax:  +44 (0)115 952 9421
email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Pages: http://www.nadt.org.uk/

To Unsubscribe: send mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with unsubscribe freebsd-stable in the body of the message