Re: [gentoo-dev] Suggestion: Trying to locate and remove unused dev- & media-libs?
Am Freitag, 8. Januar 2021, 14:26:32 EET schrieb Joonas Niilola: > # Now my question is, does anyone find any of these packages useful? > Should we go ahead and last-rite them, since it doesn't seem useful to > carry these in Gentoo? The ones broken are heading towards last-riting > nevertheless. We have done such cleanups in the past. Libraries without consumers in the Gentoo tree make in general only limited sense. That said, if they build and have an active maintainer, why not keep them for now. This is more or less a cost/benefit question. > > # So the final list of "useless" libs is: > dev-libs/atcore > dev-libs/bcm2835 > dev-libs/bitset > dev-libs/boost-mpl-cartesian_product > dev-libs/caliper > dev-libs/clhpp > dev-libs/distorm64 > dev-libs/editline > dev-libs/faxpp > dev-libs/go-usb > dev-libs/gtx > dev-libs/igraph > dev-libs/ilbc-rfc3951 > dev-libs/injeqt > dev-libs/jthread > dev-libs/kqoauth > dev-libs/libdivsufsort > dev-libs/libdnsres > dev-libs/libezV24 > dev-libs/libgcrypt-compat > dev-libs/libpcre-debian > dev-libs/libtomfloat > dev-libs/libtompoly > dev-libs/libtreadstone > dev-libs/log4sh > dev-libs/nss-pem > dev-libs/OpenSRF > dev-libs/pigpio > dev-libs/processor-trace > dev-libs/rapidxml > dev-libs/redland-bindings > dev-libs/rinutils > dev-libs/rocm-hostcall > dev-libs/smack > dev-libs/squareball > dev-libs/ustr > dev-libs/vc-intrinsics > dev-libs/xbyak > dev-libs/zookeeper-c > media-libs/cimg > media-libs/elles_icc_profiles > media-libs/esdl > media-libs/fluidsynth-dssi > media-libs/freeverb3 > media-libs/gmtk > media-libs/gnonlin > media-libs/guilib > media-libs/intel-mediasdk > media-libs/kodi-platform > media-libs/libggigcp > media-libs/libggimisc > media-libs/libgroove > media-libs/liblingoteach > media-libs/libyami > media-libs/memphis > media-libs/noise-suppression-for-voice > media-libs/raul > media-libs/sdl-terminal > media-libs/volpack > > > -- juippis -- Andreas K. Hüttel dilfri...@gentoo.org Gentoo Linux developer (council, qa, toolchain, base-system, perl, libreoffice) signature.asc Description: This is a digitally signed message part.
Re: [gentoo-dev] Suggestion: Trying to locate and remove unused dev- & media-libs?
On Freitag, 8. Januar 2021 13:26:32 CET Joonas Niilola wrote: > # So the final list of "useless" libs is: > dev-libs/atcore This has IUSE="gui", EAPI=7 and kde proj as maintainer. Please keep. Regards signature.asc Description: This is a digitally signed message part.
Re: [gentoo-dev] Suggestion: Trying to locate and remove unused dev- & media-libs?
On 1/8/21 5:42 PM, Thomas Deutschmann wrote: > Hi, > > I wonder how you composed this list. If you just checked if there is > any revdep, the check was probably useless: > > For example, > >> dev-libs/cyberjack > > is up-to-date, has an active dev as maintainer and is required for any > ReinerSCT chipcard reader. > > Hey, I admit the motivation didn't come clear from the first post. I believe majority of listed packages to be leftovers from previous removals, thus being "useless" to us now. I also admit to checking git logs for only a handful of packages, and left few active+useful ones out from the list already. This is a genuine inquiry to find out if these libs are somehow useful for someone, not a "last-rites call for action" post ;) Although I probably will continue to look for the really outdated, EAPI-5 etc ones after a certain period of time. -- juippis OpenPGP_signature Description: OpenPGP digital signature
Re: [gentoo-dev] Suggestion: Trying to locate and remove unused dev- & media-libs?
On Fri, Jan 8, 2021 at 7:27 AM Joonas Niilola wrote: > dev-libs/clhpp We want to keep this, though I admit I don't recall why nothing depends on it.
Re: [gentoo-dev] Suggestion: Trying to locate and remove unused dev- & media-libs?
Hi, please forget my previous mail. I was informed that I misread your mail, sorry about that! -- Regards, Thomas Deutschmann / Gentoo Linux Developer fpr: C4DD 695F A713 8F24 2AA1 5638 5849 7EE5 1D5D 74A5 OpenPGP_signature Description: OpenPGP digital signature
Re: [gentoo-dev] Suggestion: Trying to locate and remove unused dev- & media-libs?
Hi, I wonder how you composed this list. If you just checked if there is any revdep, the check was probably useless: For example, dev-libs/cyberjack is up-to-date, has an active dev as maintainer and is required for any ReinerSCT chipcard reader. -- Regards, Thomas Deutschmann / Gentoo Linux Developer fpr: C4DD 695F A713 8F24 2AA1 5638 5849 7EE5 1D5D 74A5 OpenPGP_signature Description: OpenPGP digital signature
Re: [gentoo-dev] Suggestion: Trying to locate and remove unused dev- & media-libs?
On Fri, 8 Jan 2021 14:26:32 +0200 Joonas Niilola wrote: > dev-libs/libgcrypt-compat > dev-libs/libpcre-debian These are maintained by me and I'd like to keep them. They can be pulled in by running the esteam tool in steam-overlay for games that need them. They could potentially be used for other old or Debian-oriented binary packages too. -- James Le Cuirot (chewi) Gentoo Linux Developer pgp25epsm8vEo.pgp Description: OpenPGP digital signature
[gentoo-dev] Suggestion: Trying to locate and remove unused dev- & media-libs?
# With the help of jkroon I went through all dev-libs/* and media-libs/* packages and located each one without reverse deps, # List of dev-libs/* and media-libs/* without any revdeps: dev-libs/atcore dev-libs/bcm2835 dev-libs/bemenu dev-libs/bitset dev-libs/boost-mpl-cartesian_product dev-libs/caliper dev-libs/c-capnproto dev-libs/cgilib dev-libs/clhpp dev-libs/cloog dev-libs/cyberjack dev-libs/distorm64 dev-libs/editline dev-libs/faxpp dev-libs/go-usb dev-libs/granite dev-libs/gtx dev-libs/igraph dev-libs/ilbc-rfc3951 dev-libs/injeqt dev-libs/jthread dev-libs/keystone dev-libs/kqoauth dev-libs/libdivecomputer dev-libs/libdivsufsort dev-libs/libdnsres dev-libs/libdynd dev-libs/libezV24 dev-libs/libgcrypt-compat dev-libs/libgpiod dev-libs/liblzw dev-libs/libmelf dev-libs/libpcre-debian dev-libs/libtomfloat dev-libs/libtompoly dev-libs/libtreadstone dev-libs/libusbhp dev-libs/light dev-libs/log4sh dev-libs/nss-pem dev-libs/OpenSRF dev-libs/pigpio dev-libs/processor-trace dev-libs/qrosscore dev-libs/rapidxml dev-libs/redland-bindings dev-libs/replicant dev-libs/rinutils dev-libs/rocm-hostcall dev-libs/smack dev-libs/squareball dev-libs/stp dev-libs/tvision dev-libs/ucommon dev-libs/ustr dev-libs/vc-intrinsics dev-libs/weston dev-libs/xbyak dev-libs/zlog dev-libs/zookeeper-c media-libs/cimg media-libs/elles_icc_profiles media-libs/esdl media-libs/fluidsynth-dssi media-libs/freeverb3 media-libs/gmtk media-libs/gnonlin media-libs/guilib media-libs/icclib media-libs/intel-mediasdk media-libs/jbig2enc media-libs/kodi-platform media-libs/libbsb media-libs/libggigcp media-libs/libggimisc media-libs/libgroove media-libs/libicns media-libs/liblingoteach media-libs/libmpeg3 media-libs/libmpris2client media-libs/libsixel media-libs/libyami media-libs/memphis media-libs/noise-suppression-for-voice media-libs/phat media-libs/raul media-libs/sdl-terminal media-libs/taglib-extras media-libs/tse3 media-libs/volpack # Following packages did not compile: dev-libs/caliper https://bugs.gentoo.org/737106 (dev-libs/papi, a build-dep is broken) dev-libs/zookeeper-c https://bugs.gentoo.org/747592 media-libs/intel-mediasdk https://bugs.gentoo.org/740070 # Already package.masked: dev-libs/ilbc-rfc3951 dev-libs/OpenSRF dev-libs/ustr # Following packages appear in optfeature or elog otherwise: (none) # These packages install binaries, emerged with USE="tools": dev-libs/bemenu dev-libs/c-capnproto dev-libs/cgilib dev-libs/cloog dev-libs/cyberjack dev-libs/granite dev-libs/keystone dev-libs/libdivecomputer dev-libs/libdynd dev-libs/libgpiod dev-libs/liblzw dev-libs/libmelf dev-libs/libusbhp (/usr/bin/hptest) dev-libs/light dev-libs/qrosscore dev-libs/replicant dev-libs/stp dev-libs/tvision dev-libs/ucommon dev-libs/weston dev-libs/zlog media-libs/icclib media-libs/jbig2enc media-libs/libbsb media-libs/libicns media-libs/libmpeg3 media-libs/libmpris2client media-libs/libsixel media-libs/phat media-libs/taglib-extras media-libs/tse3 # So the final list of "useless" libs is: dev-libs/atcore dev-libs/bcm2835 dev-libs/bitset dev-libs/boost-mpl-cartesian_product dev-libs/caliper dev-libs/clhpp dev-libs/distorm64 dev-libs/editline dev-libs/faxpp dev-libs/go-usb dev-libs/gtx dev-libs/igraph dev-libs/ilbc-rfc3951 dev-libs/injeqt dev-libs/jthread dev-libs/kqoauth dev-libs/libdivsufsort dev-libs/libdnsres dev-libs/libezV24 dev-libs/libgcrypt-compat dev-libs/libpcre-debian dev-libs/libtomfloat dev-libs/libtompoly dev-libs/libtreadstone dev-libs/log4sh dev-libs/nss-pem dev-libs/OpenSRF dev-libs/pigpio dev-libs/processor-trace dev-libs/rapidxml dev-libs/redland-bindings dev-libs/rinutils dev-libs/rocm-hostcall dev-libs/smack dev-libs/squareball dev-libs/ustr dev-libs/vc-intrinsics dev-libs/xbyak dev-libs/zookeeper-c media-libs/cimg media-libs/elles_icc_profiles media-libs/esdl media-libs/fluidsynth-dssi media-libs/freeverb3 media-libs/gmtk media-libs/gnonlin media-libs/guilib media-libs/intel-mediasdk media-libs/kodi-platform media-libs/libggigcp media-libs/libggimisc media-libs/libgroove media-libs/liblingoteach media-libs/libyami media-libs/memphis media-libs/noise-suppression-for-voice media-libs/raul media-libs/sdl-terminal media-libs/volpack # Now my question is, does anyone find any of these packages useful? Should we go ahead and last-rite them, since it doesn't seem useful to carry these in Gentoo? The ones broken are heading towards last-riting nevertheless. -- juippis OpenPGP_signature Description: OpenPGP digital signature
