Re: How to `git blame` individual characters?

[Christian Couder]

Hi,

On Tue, Mar 27, 2018 at 2:18 AM, Jan Keromnes  wrote:
> Dear Git developers,
>
> I'd like to understand what would be required to run `git blame` on
> individual characters instead of full lines. Could you please point me
> in the right direction?

You might want to take a look at cregit
(https://github.com/cregit/cregit) and maybe at other work from the
people who developed it.

There are links related to this tool in:
https://git.github.io/rev_news/2017/05/17/edition-27/

> Someone asked a similar question about "Word-by-word blame/annotate"
> on StackOverflow a few years ago, and one of the replies said:
>
>> Git tracks changes snapshot by snapshot. The line-based format is calculated 
>> on-the-fly, and it would also be possible to have a word-based format.
>
> Source: https://stackoverflow.com/q/17758008/3461173
>
> This leaves me hopeful that a character-based format can somehow be
> achieved. Here is a fake example to illustrate what I'm looking for:
>
> $ cat myscript.js
> for (int foo = 0; foo <= 11; foo++) { console.log(foo); }
> $ git blame --character-based --pseudo-json myscript.js
> [
> { "commit": "abcd1234", "summary": "Implement loop",
> "characters": "for (int " },
> { "commit": "bcd1234a", "summary": "Rename iterator",
> "characters": "foo" },
> { "commit": "abcd1234", "summary": "Implement loop",
> "characters": " = 0; " },
> { "commit": "bcd1234a", "summary": "Rename iterator",
> "characters": "foo" },
> { "commit": "abcd1234", "summary": "Implement loop",
> "characters": " <= " },
> { "commit": "cd1234ab", "summary": "Go up to 11",
> "characters": "11" },
> { "commit": "abcd1234", "summary": "Implement loop",
> "characters": "; " },
> { "commit": "bcd1234a", "summary": "Rename iterator",
> "characters": "foo" },
> { "commit": "abcd1234", "summary": "Implement loop",
> "characters": "++) { console.log(" },
> { "commit": "bcd1234a", "summary": "Rename iterator",
> "characters": "foo" },
> { "commit": "abcd1234", "summary": "Implement loop",
> "characters": ")" },
> { "commit": "d1234abc", "summary": "Add missing
> semicolon", "characters": ";" },
> { "commit": "abcd1234", "summary": "Implement loop",
> "characters": " }" }
> ]
>
> What would be the most direct way to achieve such a character-based
> blame/annotate? Should I write some sort of Git extension, or hack
> into Git's source code?

I think the "Token-based authorship information from Git" article
(https://lwn.net/Articles/698425/) is about that.

> E.g. I looked for an option in `git-blame` or `git-annotate` to change
> the "next line boundary" from "carret return" (line-based blame) to
> "any whitespace" (word-based blame) or "character-by-character"
> (character-based blame), but I didn't find it. Could this be
> implemented in `blame.c`? If so, which methods would need tweaking?

I don't think this is implemented in Git. Do you really need that in git itself?

How to `git blame` individual characters?

[Jan Keromnes]

Dear Git developers,

I'd like to understand what would be required to run `git blame` on
individual characters instead of full lines. Could you please point me
in the right direction?

Someone asked a similar question about "Word-by-word blame/annotate"
on StackOverflow a few years ago, and one of the replies said:

> Git tracks changes snapshot by snapshot. The line-based format is calculated 
> on-the-fly, and it would also be possible to have a word-based format.

Source: https://stackoverflow.com/q/17758008/3461173

This leaves me hopeful that a character-based format can somehow be
achieved. Here is a fake example to illustrate what I'm looking for:

$ cat myscript.js
for (int foo = 0; foo <= 11; foo++) { console.log(foo); }
$ git blame --character-based --pseudo-json myscript.js
[
{ "commit": "abcd1234", "summary": "Implement loop",
"characters": "for (int " },
{ "commit": "bcd1234a", "summary": "Rename iterator",
"characters": "foo" },
{ "commit": "abcd1234", "summary": "Implement loop",
"characters": " = 0; " },
{ "commit": "bcd1234a", "summary": "Rename iterator",
"characters": "foo" },
{ "commit": "abcd1234", "summary": "Implement loop",
"characters": " <= " },
{ "commit": "cd1234ab", "summary": "Go up to 11",
"characters": "11" },
{ "commit": "abcd1234", "summary": "Implement loop",
"characters": "; " },
{ "commit": "bcd1234a", "summary": "Rename iterator",
"characters": "foo" },
{ "commit": "abcd1234", "summary": "Implement loop",
"characters": "++) { console.log(" },
{ "commit": "bcd1234a", "summary": "Rename iterator",
"characters": "foo" },
{ "commit": "abcd1234", "summary": "Implement loop",
"characters": ")" },
{ "commit": "d1234abc", "summary": "Add missing
semicolon", "characters": ";" },
{ "commit": "abcd1234", "summary": "Implement loop",
"characters": " }" }
]

What would be the most direct way to achieve such a character-based
blame/annotate? Should I write some sort of Git extension, or hack
into Git's source code?

E.g. I looked for an option in `git-blame` or `git-annotate` to change
the "next line boundary" from "carret return" (line-based blame) to
"any whitespace" (word-based blame) or "character-by-character"
(character-based blame), but I didn't find it. Could this be
implemented in `blame.c`? If so, which methods would need tweaking?

Many thanks!
Jan