[GNU-linux-libre] Gnuplot

2012-12-26 Thread Alexandru Cojocaru
Is Gnuplot really Free Software?

From their FAQ 
(http://www.gnuplot.info/faq/faq.html#SECTION00037000):
 ...
 Gnuplot is freeware in the sense that
 you don't have to pay for it. However
 it is *not* freeware in the sense that
 you would be allowed to distribute a
 modified version of your gnuplot freely.
 ...

From their `Copyright' file:
 ...
 Permission to modify the software is granted,
 but not the right to distribute the complete
 modified source code.  Modifications are to
 be distributed as patches to the released version.
 ...

Is the above limitation on the Freedom 2 acceptable?


Best regards,
Cojocaru Alexandru



Re: [GNU-linux-libre] Gnuplot

2012-12-26 Thread Jason Self
Alexandru Cojocaru xo...@gmx.com wrote ..
 Is Gnuplot really Free Software?

 Permission to modify the software is granted, but not the right to
 distribute the complete modified source code.  Modifications are to
 be distributed as patches to the released version. 

I seem to recall that other programs have had similar requirements and
have been considered free. It's really just a packaging issue: Your
modifications live in a separate file and are applied at build time.
This seems to mesh well with this section from the Free Software
Definition:

...rules about how to package a modified version are acceptable, if
they don't substantively limit your freedom to release modified
versions, or your freedom to make and use modified versions privately.
Thus, it is acceptable for the license to require that you change the
name of the modified version, remove a logo, or identify your
modifications as yours. As long as these requirements are not so
burdensome that they effectively hamper you from releasing your
changes, they are acceptable; you're already making other changes to
the program, so you won't have trouble making a few more.