Re: softwarecombinations paper again Re: LGPL vs. GPL

2008-08-09 Thread Alfred M. Szmidt
But if you use code that is copyrighted, say by linking or
otherwise

   Writing a plug-in for the GIMP does not do anything prohibited by
   copyright. Even if you include header files and such, that comes
   under there's just one way to do it, which makes it OK. So you
   don't need permission and you don't need to distribute it under any
   particular license.

If the program depends on the other program in some manner, then yes
you do.

   Some GPL theorists would like it if making a program
   that inter-operates at the code level with another
   program would entangle its source in the copyrights
   of that program, but in fact that does not happen.

Ofcourse it does happen.



___
gnu-misc-discuss mailing list
gnu-misc-discuss@gnu.org
http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/gnu-misc-discuss


Re: softwarecombinations paper again Re: LGPL vs. GPL

2008-08-09 Thread Tim Smith
In article [EMAIL PROTECTED],
 Alfred M. Szmidt [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 But if you use code that is copyrighted, say by linking or
 otherwise
 
Writing a plug-in for the GIMP does not do anything prohibited by
copyright. Even if you include header files and such, that comes
under there's just one way to do it, which makes it OK. So you
don't need permission and you don't need to distribute it under any
particular license.
 
 If the program depends on the other program in some manner, then yes
 you do.

Depends on is does not automatically require copyright permission.  If 
work X depends on Y, in the sense that X is useless without Y, and X 
interfaces at run time to Y and Y's data, that *can* be OK.  See, for 
example, the various video game cases, where third parties made cheat 
add-ons for video games, without permission of the game makers.

The relevant question is whether or not X is a derivative work of Y, not 
whether or not it depends on...in some manner.

-- 
--Tim Smith
___
gnu-misc-discuss mailing list
gnu-misc-discuss@gnu.org
http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/gnu-misc-discuss