Re: [Goanet] Re: Re: Posts on Goa

2006-01-24 Thread Mario Goveia
--- Radhakrishnan Nair <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> 
> But what's unique about some Goan bhatkars of
vintage variety 
> is their seemingly disproportionate and illogical
loyalty to
> the Portuguese. The moment the letter 'P' is
uttered, they put 
> the blinkers on and begin to brag about the three
bridges and 
> a radio station the Portuguese had managed to build
in 450 
> years. I always restrained myself (for fear of
losing a few 
> good friends) from saying that the bridges survived
because 
> nothing heavier than bullock carts passed over them!
> 
Mario adds:
>
Hey, Radha, don't forget the Mercedes Benzes and
Citroens that also used the 3 bridges!  However, to be
fair, I have met a few who have since given up the
ghost on ever being "Portuguese" again.
>
As we have seen in some of the posts on this very
thread, the Portuguese were somehow extremely
successful in convincing a small section of Goans into
thinking that they too were really "Portuguese".  That
"overseas province" concept was a brilliant piece of
sophistry that enabled them to buy over a decade of
additional colonial economic bliss of cheap sources of
raw materials and a captive market.
>
The attitude was similar to many Anglo-Indians, with
the caveat that the Anglo-Indians at least had some
British blood in them, and while they considered
themselves "different" for obvious reasons, most did
not necessarily consider themselves "elite" in the
same way as the "bhatkars" and "fidalgos" did.  The
real die-hards in both communities moved to the
"motherland".  
>




[Goanet] Re: Re: Posts on Goa

2006-01-23 Thread Radhakrishnan Nair
(Dr Gilbert Lawrance wrote: Please do not be too harsh on the miniscule 
minority of Bhatkars and Fidalgos in Goa (pre-1961).  They were really like 
"A one-eyed person, who is a king among the blind".)


Harsh, doctor? Never. Having had occasions to interact with them closely, 
I've found most of them to be perfect gentlemen -- suave, cultured and 
generous to a fault. They make excellent friends.  I've enjoyed their 
gracious hospitality and always believed that it was the prevailing social 
milieu that turned their borebears into villains -- much like the zamindars 
elsewhere in India. Nairs are despised in Kerala for the very same reason, 
so I do empathise with them.


But what's unique about some Goan bhatkars of vintage variety is their 
seemingly disproportionate and illogical loyalty to the Portuguese. The 
moment the letter 'P' is uttered, they put the blinkers on and begin to brag 
about the three bridges and a radio station the Portuguese had managed to 
build in 450 years. I always restrained myself (for fear of losing a few 
good friends) from saying that the bridges survived because nothing heavier 
than bullock carts passed over them!


I'm only coaxing them to accept the reality and stop living in the past 
because I sincerely believe that their intellectual vigour and loyalty can 
be true assets to modern India. There's hope. The younger generation is not 
so obsessed with their Portuguese past as the oldies.


Cheers, RKN