Re: [Goanet] Deconstructing tourism image of Goa

2008-03-27 Thread Gilbert Lawrence
Very well written article! Congratulation to the author Maria Couto and The 
Hindu newspaper for publishing it. Now that Goa has the national and the 
international spotlight, Goans seeking improvements in their native land should 
not rest till the problems are solved. However, the problems are not going to 
be analyzed and solved by the politicians who have permitted it to be created 
by the vested elements, and with the police to go-along. 
 
Goa needs a tourist board (if it does not have one) at the district and at 
the national level. These boards should consist of those with an economic 
interest as well as representatives of various NGOs and Civic Action Groups. 
The tourist board meetings should be OPEN FORUMS. 
 
India Abroad a weekly news-magazine for Indians in the USA had a full-page 
article on the Scarlett episode. The photograph accompanying the article was 
Anjuna beach with stray dogs, rag tag flea market, and an atmosphere right on 
the beach. It was not impressive. No wonder, the high-end tourists do not come 
here and the high-end vendors does not market here. There is no tax base to pay 
/ provide any basic services, including police protection. I think the tourist 
lobby should / would like to see this attraction ended. 
 
The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) has to be involved to break the 
foreign links which appear to run the drug trade as users (junkies and 
recreational), pushers, mules (transport), and lab operators. In the news 
report, Goa has become the manufacturing center and the point for national and 
international shipping of drugs. Tourists, especially children, are used to 
transport, as they are not severely punished if caught, because of their age. 
 
One poster to goanet, had suggested using a national TV investigative program 
like Thedelka (I think). Yet, today with cell phones cameras, and You-Tube 
web links, much corruption can be exposed by ordinary citizens. I had 
previously suggested any business dealing with drugs in any form on its 
premises should be shut down for a month. And three shutdowns calls for the 
termination of the business. 
 
There is no question that tourism, civil society and native culture can survive 
and all can prosper. This is accomplished all across the world - from Hawaii to 
Monaco to Singapore and closer to home - in Rajasthan. It should succeed in Goa 
too, if all cooperate and build on success instead of the same-old wringing of 
hands. 
 
Native Goans have to honestly ask themselves: Are the tourists really changing 
Goan culture (as Maria Couto and others suggest)? Or are the tourists and 
politicians just an excuse for changes in the Goan society that does not 
appreciate the importance of preserving their traditions? If Goans did realize 
the importance of preserving their traditions and culture, the diaspora Goans 
in the US and Canada would be preserving their traditions (LIKE MANY OTHER 
ethnic groups). Starting with Mario, few other recent posts on goanet over the 
last few days have shed some light on preserving Goan culture. 
 
Regards, GL 
 
 Vidyadhar Gadgil 
From: The Hindu, 24 March 2008 
 
Deconstructing tourism image of Goa by Maria Aurora Couto There is a dilemma 
posed by the tourism industry - one of the main sources of employment. Our 
environment, the main attraction for tourists, requires an embargo on polluting 
industries. Income earned in foreign exchange is taken by the Centre and does 
not form part of the subventions from the Centre to the State. 
 
Tourism must survive but so must Goan society. A higher level of policing is 
called for, with more women constables, preventive intelligence, a parametric 
and high level surveillance which should elicit the full cooperation of 
non-governmental organisations and civic action groups who feel left out of the 
system as helpless spectators of a tragedy.


  

Never miss a thing.  Make Yahoo your home page. 
http://www.yahoo.com/r/hs


[Goanet] Deconstructing tourism image of Goa

2008-03-24 Thread Vidyadhar Gadgil
---
  2008 International Goan Convention
Toronto, Canada

 Early Bird Discount Registration closes March 31, 2008

  http://www.2008goanconvention.com/regform_print.html
---

The Hindu, 24 March 2008

Deconstructing tourism image of Goa

Maria Aurora Couto

The recent tragedy in Goa exposes degradation of coastline and
human resource.


The immense media focus on young Scarlette Keeling’s death has
exposed the degradation that has seeped into the fabric of Goan
society, predominantly along the coastal belt in north Goa.
However, her tragic death only points to a disease that has
afflicted Goa for more than a decade. It is to be hoped that the
sequence of developments will expose a nexus of perpetrators who
have raped the pristine beaches, and lured a significant section
of the youth into drugs. It is a disease spread through the very
construction of the image of Goa as a tourist paradise, a party
place, Goa-where-anything-goes. And the pickings have been rich
for the powerful, their underlings and the middlemen spread across
the globe, within the nation and of course within Goa.

Historically there has been an image of Goa and Goans constructed
by British historians and travellers such as Richard Burton in the
19th century. They despised the failure of Portuguese colonialism
and hence despised Goan culture — of which they knew nothing. They
created the stereotype of a mixed race, of temple dancers, women
of easy virtue, hard drinkers, a people with no history and no
culture. This stereotype has been reworked in our time by Nirad C.
Chaudhuri and V.S. Naipaul, and in Bollywood films. Yet we Goans
know we are by and large a law-abiding society, with strong family
values. The temples and churches are overflowing, the festivals
are celebrated with a typically Goan combination of élan and deep
spirituality, and our village life is vibrant and active.

Writers and artists have chosen to make Goa their home. Amitav
Ghosh, who now has a home in Goa, feels it is the special quality
of the Goan people, their warmth and cosmopolitanism, that draws
people here.

Contradictory perspectives
How, then, does one make sense of these two contradictory
perspectives? What is of concern to me is that the image of Goa
constructed to sell tourism has been sedulously cultivated to
reinvent for modern times the perverted stereotype constructed
since the 19th century or earlier. The notoriety, the quiet wink
and knowing look that have been inseparable from the idea of Goa
in certain circles, appears to have been co-opted to sell tourism
with a kind of tacit understanding that much will be condoned. And
these same forces collude to keep the party going, to ignore the
crimes, and the despair of a law-abiding population that finds
itself trapped between a description of its homeland as one of the
best States in the country in terms of human resource development
yet also is host to paedophiles, drug pushers, and most recently,
gambling, to lure yet another kind of tourist, a State with a high
rate of literacy second only to Kerala yet with a 40 per cent
dropout rate, and an equal percentage of the educated unemployed.

I lived in Goa in 1962 soon after its liberation when people
flocked from our metropolitan cities to buy foreign goods and
cheap liquor. Goa itself was not taken seriously except as a place
to have a good time. The scene is no better today. There is a
sense in which the national tourist ‘others’ the Goan. We are an
open society, cosmopolitan, with fewer inhibitions in the sense
that we are informal, love music and dance, with time for leisure
built into a hardworking day. And perhaps more crucially, there is
an easy informality between the sexes, which is wildly
misunderstood by the Indian tourist, in particular, who often
arrives to let go of his own inhibitions, drawn by the media image
of “in Goa anything goes.”

Figures show that the consumption of liquor by tourists in a day
in the high season is more than is consumed by Goans in a whole
year — although drunkenness is now disrupting family life more
than ever before.

Goa has suffered many shocks which have rocked the stability of
its society, which is essentially feudal, and its ancient system
of land-holding known as communidade. Both received a mortal blow
from insensitive land reforms. As a result, rich agricultural
lands are lying fallow — and a great deal of it has been converted
by unscrupulous politicians into settlement zones. Hence there has
been a huge diversion of agricultural land to satisfy the greed of
national and international players for real estate. One reads of a
sale in Delhi earlier this month at an “Extensive Goa Property
Show.” Goans know nothing about this, nor do they know to whom the
land belongs. Simultaneously, a signature campaign is