[Goanet] Discussion on Official Language in the Goa Assembly

2008-08-25 Thread pratap naik
Discussion on Official Language Act 1987 in the Goa Assembly
 
On Monday, 25 August 2008, in Goa Legislative Assembly during ‘Demands’ 8 
members Including the Chief Minister Digambar Kamat spoke on the Official 
Language Act 1987.  The demand for discussion of this topic was laid before the 
house by Mr. Manohar Parrikar, Leader of the Opposition.  
Dy. Speaker Mr. Mauvin Godinho was the first person to speak on this topic. He 
was followed by Mrs. Victoria Feranandes (St. Cruz), Mr. Agnelo Fernandes 
(Calangute), Mr. Alexio Reginaldo Lourenço (Curtorim), Mr. Manohar Parrikar, 
Mr. Dayanand Mandrekar (Siolim),  Mr. Francisco Silveira and Chief Minister.  
All the speakers were in favour of giving its due place to Roman script in the 
Official Language Act.  Parrikar was the best speaker. He had done thorough 
home work. One could see this the way he spoke and presented the matter in the 
house. He suggested to form a committee comprising MLAs , Marathi protagonists 
and Roman script Protagonists and within two months to come to a consensus on 
the language issue and to settle it based on the views of the majority.   Three 
of the Catholic MLAs who spoke in favour of Roman script were using terms like 
“Romani  bhas”, “Romi bhas”, “Romi Konknni”. They did not know there are no 
such notions.
 In Goa Konknni is written in two scripts, Devanagari and Roman scripts and 
they use two different dialects, namely, Antruzi and Bardeshi.  Mandrekar made 
a statement that Devanagari script is the mother of all scripts and it is the 
script of Sanskrit. He and many others do not know the history of Indian 
scripts. Brahmi was the first Indian script and all other Indian scripts were 
modification of it. Devanagari script evolved only in 900 A. D.  Since Sanskrit 
was written in many scripts, in 1857 the British decided to make the Devanagari 
script the official script of Sanskrit to teach it as a subject in Calcutta, 
Madras and Bombay Universities. Sanskrit was and is written in a number of 
script. 
While replying to the Demands, the CM said that he is ready to discuss this 
issue and to find satisfactory solution once and for all for the good of Goa 
and Goans.  On Friday 29th August Parrikar’s private member resolution to 
constitute a committee of representatives of  MLS, supporters of Roman script 
and supporters of Marathi will be discussed in the house.  One has to wait and 
see what the government will do to settle the long standing demand of Roman 
script supporters.  
 
Pratap Naik, S.J.
 
 


  Share files, take polls, and make new friends - all under one roof. Go to 
http://in.promos.yahoo.com/groups/


Re: [Goanet] Discussion on Official Language in the Goa Assembly

2008-08-25 Thread Ancy D'Souza
Very happy to see that finally the script issue is being discussed in
the parliment. Konkani can servive only if Roman, Devnagiri and
Kannada scripts are given due respect. In Goa Roman and Devnagiri both
scripts should get equal status. People should be given allowed to
choose the script they want to use.
I assure my full hearted from Mumbai support in the movement to give
equal status to Roman script along with Devnairi in Goa.
With regards
Ancy Paladka

Ancy S. D'Souza, Paladka
E2-139 Diwan Apt III
Vasai Road East
Thane Dist - 401 210
Tel: 0250-2390225
Cell: 9320733213
Email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]


On 8/25/08, pratap naik [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 Discussion on Official Language Act 1987 in the Goa Assembly
 On Monday, 25 August 2008, in Goa Legislative Assembly during 'Demands' 8 
 members Including the Chief Minister Digambar Kamat spoke on the Official 
 Language Act 1987.  The demand for discussion of this topic was laid before 
 the house by Mr. Manohar Parrikar, Leader of the Opposition.

 Dy. Speaker Mr. Mauvin Godinho was the first person to speak on this topic. 
 He was followed by Mrs. Victoria Feranandes (St. Cruz), Mr. Agnelo Fernandes 
 (Calangute), Mr. Alexio Reginaldo Lourenço (Curtorim), Mr. Manohar Parrikar, 
 Mr. Dayanand Mandrekar (Siolim),  Mr. Francisco Silveira and Chief Minister.  
 All the speakers were in favour of giving its due place to Roman script in 
 the Official Language Act.  Parrikar was the best speaker. He had done 
 thorough home work. One could see this the way he spoke and presented the 
 matter in the house. He suggested to form a committee comprising MLAs , 
 Marathi protagonists and Roman script Protagonists and within two months to 
 come to a consensus on the language issue and to settle it based on the views 
 of the majority.   Three of the Catholic MLAs who spoke in favour of Roman 
 script were using terms like Romani  bhas, Romi bhas, Romi Konknni. 
 They did not know there are no such notions. In Goa Konknni is written in two 
 scripts, Devanagari and Roman scripts and they use two different dialects, 
 namely, Antruzi and Bardeshi.  Mandrekar made a statement that Devanagari 
 script is the mother of all scripts and it is the script of Sanskrit. He and 
 many others do not know the history of Indian scripts. Brahmi was the first 
 Indian script and all other Indian scripts were modification of it. 
 Devanagari script evolved only in 900 A. D.  Since Sanskrit was written in 
 many scripts, in 1857 the British decided to make the Devanagari script the 
 official script of Sanskrit to teach it as a subject in Calcutta, Madras and 
 Bombay Universities. Sanskrit was and is written in a number of script.

 While replying to the Demands, the CM said that he is ready to discuss this 
 issue and to find satisfactory solution once and for all for the good of Goa 
 and Goans.  On Friday 29th August Parrikar's private member resolution to 
 constitute a committee of representatives of  MLS, supporters of Roman script 
 and supporters of Marathi will be discussed in the house.  One has to wait 
 and see what the government will do to settle the long standing demand of 
 Roman script supporters.



 Pratap Naik, S.J.