Re: [Goanet] Mull ani Bull (ML ani Caste)

2013-09-01 Thread Jose Colaco
Mervyn Lobo wrote:

'I am based in Toronto, Canada. I can assure you that caste is a huge factor in 
the peculiar type of Christianity as practiced by Goans. 

.. caste and Christianity go hand in glove in India.'

COMMENT:

1: Request my good friend Mervyn, to please clarify what he means by huge 
factor in the peculiar type of Christianity as practiced. Please specify what 
they allegedly PRACTICE.

2: I believe I have written this. zillion times.

3: Revision aside, the major facet of Casteism is DISCRIMINATION.

4: It is mainly: a COLOR based discrimination. Am still trying to figure out 
how the Huns became Rajputs, If the Ship wrecked Jews became Chitpawan 
Brahmins, How Shivaji eventually was able to overcome Brahmin objection before 
becoming Chatrapati..etc

5: Caste discrimination is incompatible with Christianity.

6: Tomorrow, Mervyn might travel to another island country favoured by 
Canadians and write about Santeria Catholics.

7: Those Goans who practice discrimination based on their alleged ancestral 
pre-conversion Hindu caste, have NOT YET converted. They are best classified as 
individuals who are attending Christian worship services while practicing the 
Hindu Caste System. One day, they might resolve to shun this Apartheid practice 
and convert to Christianity.

jc



Re: [Goanet] Mull ani Bull (ML ani Caste)

2013-09-01 Thread Mervyn Lobo
Jose Colaco wrote:

 1: Request my good friend Mervyn, to please clarify what he means by huge 

 factor in the peculiar type of Christianity as practiced. Please specify 
 what they allegedly PRACTICE.
-snip-
 7: Those Goans who practice discrimination based on their alleged ancestral 
 pre-conversion Hindu caste, have NOT YET converted. They are best classified 
 as 
 individuals who are attending Christian worship services while practicing the 
 Hindu Caste System. One day, they might resolve to shun this Apartheid 
 practice 
 and convert to Christianity.



Doc,
We are on the same page. You find the caste system absurd and so do I. 

You also feel that one cannot be Christian and practice the caste system, and 
so do I.

The caste system was jettisoned by my fore parents. I had no exposer to it 
until I read about it on Goanet. The more I read about the caste system, the 
easier it comes for me to understand how easily a person can be deluded into 
caste, superstitious, mythology and religious believes. 

Mervyn