Re: [Goanet] Shilpa Shetty racism row escalates; Indian Govt gets in on the act.

2007-01-20 Thread Sachin Phadte

  http://www.GOANET.org 


This month's Goanet operations sponsored by Mrs. Daisy Faleiro


I think it was correct on part of the Indian government to take up the 
issue. Even if it is a case of class and not race, as Cornel has mentioned, 
there has to be a certain amount of decorum.

I hope that the Indian government also takes up the issue of the proposal by 
the German government for a ban on the display of swastika, because it was 
misused by the Nazis.

Sachin Phadte.

_
Get up-to-date with movies, music and TV. Its happening on MSN Entertainment 
http://content.msn.co.in/Entertainment/Default



Re: [Goanet] Shilpa Shetty racism row escalates; Indian Govt gets in on the act.

2007-01-18 Thread Cornel DaCosta

  http://www.GOANET.org 


This month's Goanet operations sponsored by Mrs. Daisy Faleiro


Hi Gabe
Thanks for your post. And now, just a very quick response from me.

I have never watched Big Brother because it is definitely not my kind of TV 
but I have a rough idea what it is all about.

Re the current furore, I'd say that, I followed the subsequent TV footage 
closely and also what some of the press has said. My view is that:

1. The issue was more about class than race although there definitely was a 
racist edge to it. The four working class women could not cope with the well 
educated middle class Shilpa and a wealthy celebrity actress at that. But 
also, Shilpa knew little about UK working class culture and also perhaps 
about the nature of the programme. Hence, there was a considerable class and 
cultural dissonance. Some of the things said by the WC women was clearly 
indicative of sheer ignorance and prejudice. However, I am unclear how 
Shilpa actually got on to this programme.

2. I first heard on the car radio about thousands of people ringing in to 
complain that Shilpa had been at the receiving end of racist bullying. That 
so many ordinary Brits could do this unsolicited is indicative of a general 
liberal tone in Britain without dismissing low level racism always round the 
corner.

3. I am impressed by the observation that no ethnic minority person is 
buying any bull about racism. The message is clear to all and sundry that 
there is no place for racism today. Of course this was reiterated strongly 
in the live Parliament debate. I therefore think that this 'spat' on TV 
will be fruitful and productive for the better.

4. Gordon Brown had his work cut out for him on the India visit. 
Increasingly, the UK needs India as a major trading and entrepreneurial 
partner and it is really nice to see India/Indians with power at the elbow. 
At present, the UK is the fourth or fifth major industrial power in the 
world. That India will do better than this, hopefully within my lifetime, 
gives me immense joy. That this should also happen despite all the 
plundering that Britain did in India is already a reason for celebration for 
me.

5. The people demonstrating in India and burning effigies need to be 
reminded that India has an utterly dreadful record for caste-based racism. 
India reeks of caste-based racism and needs to sort this out before 
lecturing anyone else about racism---a reminder for Goans in Goa and the 
Diaspora too.

Just a few comments as I believe that people on Goanet would like some quick 
thoughts on the matter from the coalface.
Cornel

- Original Message - 
From: Gabe Menezes [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: Goa's premiere mailing list, estb. 1994! goanet@lists.goanet.org
Sent: Wednesday, January 17, 2007 5:58 PM
Subject: [Goanet] Shilpa Shetty racism row escalates;Indian Govt gets in 
on...  http://www.GOANET.org 

 The Times of India Online
 Printed from timesofindia.indiatimes.com  World Rest of World
 Shilpa Shetty racism row escalates
 Rashmee Roshan Lall
 [ 17 Jan, 2007 1952hrs ISTTIMES NEWS NETWORK ]

 LONDON: The controversy over alleged racism towards Shilpa Shetty by
 fellow-contestants of a British reality TV show escalated on Wednesday
 with Prime Minister Tony Blair and the Indian government weighing in,
 albeit with cautious platitudes and a further 10,000 complaints
 flooding into the television regulatory authority and Channel 4.







[Goanet] Shilpa Shetty racism row escalates; Indian Govt gets in on the act.

2007-01-17 Thread Gabe Menezes

  http://www.GOANET.org 


This month's Goanet operations sponsored by Mrs. Daisy Faleiro



 To sponsor Goanet operations, contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]


The Times of India Online
Printed from timesofindia.indiatimes.com  World Rest of World
Shilpa Shetty racism row escalates
Rashmee Roshan Lall
[ 17 Jan, 2007 1952hrs ISTTIMES NEWS NETWORK ]

LONDON: The controversy over alleged racism towards Shilpa Shetty by
fellow-contestants of a British reality TV show escalated on Wednesday
with Prime Minister Tony Blair and the Indian government weighing in,
albeit with cautious platitudes and a further 10,000 complaints
flooding into the television regulatory authority and Channel 4.

The total number of complaints now stands at 15,000, making Shetty's
ordeal the most complained-about television show in history.

Angry members of the 1.3-million strong British Indian community told
this paper they were mobilizing furiously to keep up the pressure on
the authorities to take action over the degrading and demeaning
behaviour towards Shetty just because she's Indian, young, beautiful,
successful and well-educated.

While a passionate internet campaign to save Shilpa gathered pace,
cynical TV pundits said the Bollywood star's unexpected first-name
recognition in Britain may actually pay her huge celebrity dividends
once her ordeal ends.

Though C4 largely remained mum about the issue, it backed away from
its previous belittling description of Shetty's bullying at the hands
of three other women contestants as girlie rivalry.

The channel continues to insist Shetty was not called a Paki by one
of the male contestants.

Police in the English county of Hertfordshire, locale of the Big
Brother house, confirmed they are to investigate e mails sent to
Channel 4 containing threats against Celebrity Big Brother housemates.
Police also confirmed receipt of a complaint about racist behaviour in
the house.

Pressure was mounting on C4 to do something about the programme,
which has two weeks still to run, with the show's sponsor Carphone
Warehouse reconsidering its three-million-pound largesse on issues of
taste and decency.

In an unprecedented development for a show that is consistently seen
to be as successful as it is shallow and sexually-degraded, bookmakers
said on Wednesday that they had cut the odds of Celebrity Big Brother
not lasting its scheduled run from 20/1 to 5/2.

British television channels added an interview with Sunanda, Shetty's
mother, in their wall-to-wall coverage of the story. Sunanda, who said
Shetty had agreed not to do any lip-to-lip kissing with male or
females on the show...to cook or eat beef, added that her daughter
was secure inside.


Meanwhile, in a sign of spiralling interest across two continents in
the shenanigans of Shetty's Big Brother housemates, Goan-origin Labour
MP asked Blair in parliament to condemn the outright racism and
xenophobia on the show. Vaz also pointedly asked Blair to remind
broadcasters such as C4 of their duty not to publish any such
prejudices to millions.

Blair responded by admitting he had not seen the programme in question
but unreservedly condemned racism in any form.

British establishment interest in Shetty's woes came as hundreds of
South Asians here started to speak out in sympathy for the actress,
with the additional biting rider that her racial harassment was a
harrowing reminder of the situation they faced in the UK.

Speaking for many British Indians, actress, comedian and writer Meera
Syal lambasted C4's bland response to days of racially-charged
bullying of Shetty. Syal said the show had slipped into vile
spectacle and there is a very thin line between what is
entertainment and a vile spectacle and I think we are in that area
now. She said, What this treatment of Shilpa has done is remind a
lot of Asian people in Britain of the type of uncomfortable treatment
they've received themselves over the years. This is bullying.

She added, I certainly wouldn't have taken as much as Shilpa has
taken. I'm just wondering if on their (C4's) last series (of Big
Brother), for example, the Tourette's sufferer had been called a
'spaz' (or a spastic) on a regular basis, whether they would have let
that continue.

Vaz, whose Leicester East constituency has a heavy concentration of
East African Indians, admitted he had been moved to employ political
dark arts such as parliamentary early day motions because his appalled
constituents had set up a clamour. Vaz's motion read: This House
views with concern the comments made about Big Brother contestant
Shilpa Shetty by other housemates; believes that Big Brother has a
role to play in preventing racist behaviour