RE: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims
Rekan . Kalau yang diceriterakan oleh Dody bener maka BENER juga sinyalemen si Abah di awal diskusi mengenai hal ini, bahwa tuntutan yang diajukan PEMERINTAH RI TIDAK didasarkan suatu yang firm ,alias asal tereak.??? Tapi mungkin harus ada penyimbang informasi , mugkin ada yang punya contact number .(aku lupa namanya ) Susilo, kan dia Kepala Balitbang Kementirian Perikanan dan Kelautan .Mungkin dia mempunai informasi versi Pemerintah. Ehm , menyedihkan juga yach hik hik hik pengen nagis deh aku. Si Abah __ Cak Ipul, Terakhir saya ketemu Pak CEO belum ada surat klaim secara formal karena pihak pusat menunggu jumlah ganti rugi yang diberikan pihak daerah. Ini dikarenakan pihak pusat menekan pihak daerah untuk segera memberikan angka sampai batas akhirnya bulan agustus kemarin. Sementara pihak daerah tentu kesulitan memberikan angka karena tidak adanya penyelidikan terintegrasi dari pusat, daerah, PTTEP, dan instansi terkait lainnya. Surat terakhir dari YPTB menyebutkan untuk tidak perlu dilakukan perundingan sebelum tim yang beranggotakan pihak-pihak yang saya sebutkan diatas terbentuk dan menentukan jumlah ganti rugi yang sesuai. Oleh sebab itu saya sendiri cukup bingung dengan adanya angka terakhir dari pihak pusat yang saya yakin bukan dari YPTB atau pihak daerah. Just off the record saja bahwa kemarin pihak pusat menghubungi PTTEP untuk mengusahakan pertemuan tertutup tetapi ternyata rencana ini diketahui oleh masyarkat sebelum pertemuan dilakukan di tempat netral di Singapura. Besar kemungkinan pihak dari Indonesia sendiri (pihak pusat?) yang membocorkan akan adanya pertemuan tertutup ini. salam, -doddy- -Original Message- From: mohammad syaiful [mailto:mohammadsyai...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 03 September, 2010 10:02 AM To: iagi-net@iagi.or.id Subject: Re: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims om doddy, mau konfirmasi saja. jadi pemerintah indonesia sempat presentasi menggunakan power point seperti pada umumnya dan di file presentasi itulah klaim ganti rugi diajukan? jadi tidak ada surat klaim utk minta ganti rugi secara formal? wah, blaen nek ngene negoroku... salam, syaiful * seringkali dapat sms juga dari ferdi tanoni; info informal memang menunjukkan bahwa 'tim resmi' dari pusat enggan utk bekerja, entah apa sebabnya; entah apa juga ada gunanya kalo pakai bendera iagi, lha yg lebih tinggi aja nggak mempan, hiks... On Fri, Sep 3, 2010 at 8:38 AM, Doddy Suryanto dod...@pttep.com wrote: Updated...fresh from the oven Menyedihkan sudah minta ganti ruginya lewat power point ditambah tanpa bukti-bukti pendukung yang ilmiah. Masih bagus kerjanya YPTB dan pemda setempat yang masih mau menyertakan bukti tumpahan minyak. Seperti Mas Andang utarakan, andai contoh tumpahan minyak yang dikirim YPTB ke corelab disertakan dalam proposal ganti rugi, mungkin PTTEP AA akan berfikir kembali kalau tumpahan minyaknya tidak sampai ke Indonesia. Sebenarnya contoh tumpahan minyak juga dikirim ke Leeders and Consulting Australia Pty. Ltd. melalui senator Rachel Siewert dan diteruskan ke Australia Investigation Committee. Analisis membuktikan bahwa komposisi contoh tumpahan minyak sama dengan minyak yang ada di lapangan Montara. -doddy- PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims PTTEP Australia (PTTEP AA), a subsidiary of the Thai-listed PTT Exploration and Production Public Company Limited today (2 September 2010) confirmed the Government of Indonesia that it has not accepted any claims for compensation relating to the claimed impacts of oil released from the company's Montara field in the Timor Sea last year. PTTEP CEO and President Anon Sirisaengtaksin said that the letter of claim and attached documents contained no verifiable evidence to support the claim. In July and August 2010, representatives from PTTEP AA met in Perth with an Indonesian government delegation on the issue. The latest round of talks took place on 26 August when the Government of Indonesia submitted the letter claiming for compensation with a PowerPoint summary of claim. No verifiable scientific evidence was provided with the claim summary or has yet been provided to support the claims made in the presentation. It was agreed that all data and evidence would need to be analyzed by appropriate parties before PTTEP will consider the claim. PTTEP believes that the Montara incident had no effect on Indonesia because the company was able to control the situation. It also joined hands with agencies under the Government of Australia to continuously monitor and evaluate the effect of the oil released from Montara field and found that it was limited to areas around the field. An independent scientific study which was recently released by the Environmental Protection Authority of Western Australia showed
[iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims
Updated...fresh from the oven Menyedihkan sudah minta ganti ruginya lewat power point ditambah tanpa bukti-bukti pendukung yang ilmiah. Masih bagus kerjanya YPTB dan pemda setempat yang masih mau menyertakan bukti tumpahan minyak. Seperti Mas Andang utarakan, andai contoh tumpahan minyak yang dikirim YPTB ke corelab disertakan dalam proposal ganti rugi, mungkin PTTEP AA akan berfikir kembali kalau tumpahan minyaknya tidak sampai ke Indonesia. Sebenarnya contoh tumpahan minyak juga dikirim ke Leeders and Consulting Australia Pty. Ltd. melalui senator Rachel Siewert dan diteruskan ke Australia Investigation Committee. Analisis membuktikan bahwa komposisi contoh tumpahan minyak sama dengan minyak yang ada di lapangan Montara. -doddy- PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims PTTEP Australia (PTTEP AA), a subsidiary of the Thai-listed PTT Exploration and Production Public Company Limited today (2 September 2010) confirmed the Government of Indonesia that it has not accepted any claims for compensation relating to the claimed impacts of oil released from the company's Montara field in the Timor Sea last year. PTTEP CEO and President Anon Sirisaengtaksin said that the letter of claim and attached documents contained no verifiable evidence to support the claim. In July and August 2010, representatives from PTTEP AA met in Perth with an Indonesian government delegation on the issue. The latest round of talks took place on 26 August when the Government of Indonesia submitted the letter claiming for compensation with a PowerPoint summary of claim. No verifiable scientific evidence was provided with the claim summary or has yet been provided to support the claims made in the presentation. It was agreed that all data and evidence would need to be analyzed by appropriate parties before PTTEP will consider the claim. PTTEP believes that the Montara incident had no effect on Indonesia because the company was able to control the situation. It also joined hands with agencies under the Government of Australia to continuously monitor and evaluate the effect of the oil released from Montara field and found that it was limited to areas around the field. An independent scientific study which was recently released by the Environmental Protection Authority of Western Australia showed that no oil from Montara reached the WA coast. The company is funding, in cooperation with the Australia Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts (DEWHA), scientific studies from the long term environmental monitoring program. The various studies are being conducted by a range of recognized tertiary and private research groups. The result will be released to the public when completed by DEWHA.
Re: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims
om doddy, mau konfirmasi saja. jadi pemerintah indonesia sempat presentasi menggunakan power point seperti pada umumnya dan di file presentasi itulah klaim ganti rugi diajukan? jadi tidak ada surat klaim utk minta ganti rugi secara formal? wah, blaen nek ngene negoroku... salam, syaiful * seringkali dapat sms juga dari ferdi tanoni; info informal memang menunjukkan bahwa 'tim resmi' dari pusat enggan utk bekerja, entah apa sebabnya; entah apa juga ada gunanya kalo pakai bendera iagi, lha yg lebih tinggi aja nggak mempan, hiks... On Fri, Sep 3, 2010 at 8:38 AM, Doddy Suryanto dod...@pttep.com wrote: Updated...fresh from the oven Menyedihkan sudah minta ganti ruginya lewat power point ditambah tanpa bukti-bukti pendukung yang ilmiah. Masih bagus kerjanya YPTB dan pemda setempat yang masih mau menyertakan bukti tumpahan minyak. Seperti Mas Andang utarakan, andai contoh tumpahan minyak yang dikirim YPTB ke corelab disertakan dalam proposal ganti rugi, mungkin PTTEP AA akan berfikir kembali kalau tumpahan minyaknya tidak sampai ke Indonesia. Sebenarnya contoh tumpahan minyak juga dikirim ke Leeders and Consulting Australia Pty. Ltd. melalui senator Rachel Siewert dan diteruskan ke Australia Investigation Committee. Analisis membuktikan bahwa komposisi contoh tumpahan minyak sama dengan minyak yang ada di lapangan Montara. -doddy- PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims PTTEP Australia (PTTEP AA), a subsidiary of the Thai-listed PTT Exploration and Production Public Company Limited today (2 September 2010) confirmed the Government of Indonesia that it has not accepted any claims for compensation relating to the claimed impacts of oil released from the company's Montara field in the Timor Sea last year. PTTEP CEO and President Anon Sirisaengtaksin said that the letter of claim and attached documents contained no verifiable evidence to support the claim. In July and August 2010, representatives from PTTEP AA met in Perth with an Indonesian government delegation on the issue. The latest round of talks took place on 26 August when the Government of Indonesia submitted the letter claiming for compensation with a PowerPoint summary of claim. No verifiable scientific evidence was provided with the claim summary or has yet been provided to support the claims made in the presentation. It was agreed that all data and evidence would need to be analyzed by appropriate parties before PTTEP will consider the claim. PTTEP believes that the Montara incident had no effect on Indonesia because the company was able to control the situation. It also joined hands with agencies under the Government of Australia to continuously monitor and evaluate the effect of the oil released from Montara field and found that it was limited to areas around the field. An independent scientific study which was recently released by the Environmental Protection Authority of Western Australia showed that no oil from Montara reached the WA coast. The company is funding, in cooperation with the Australia Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts (DEWHA), scientific studies from the long term environmental monitoring program. The various studies are being conducted by a range of recognized tertiary and private research groups. The result will be released to the public when completed by DEWHA. -- Mohammad Syaiful - Explorationist, Consultant Geologist Mobile: 62-812-9372808 Emails: msyai...@etti.co.id (business) mohammadsyai...@gmail.com Technical Manager of Exploration Think Tank Indonesia (ETTI) PP-IAGI 2008-2011: ketua umum: LAMBOK HUTASOIT, lam...@gc.itb.ac.id sekjen: MOHAMMAD SYAIFUL, mohammadsyai...@gmail.com * 2 sekretariat (Jkt Bdg), 5 departemen, banyak biro... Ayo siapkan diri! Hadirilah PIT ke-39 IAGI, Senggigi, Lombok NTB, 22-25 November 2010 - To unsubscribe, send email to: iagi-net-unsubscribe[at]iagi.or.id To subscribe, send email to: iagi-net-subscribe[at]iagi.or.id Visit IAGI Website: http://iagi.or.id Pembayaran iuran anggota ditujukan ke: Bank Mandiri Cab. Wisma Alia Jakarta No. Rek: 123 0085005314 Atas nama: Ikatan Ahli Geologi Indonesia (IAGI) Bank BCA KCP. Manara Mulia No. Rekening: 255-1088580 A/n: Shinta Damayanti IAGI-net Archive 1: http://www.mail-archive.com/iagi-net%40iagi.or.id/ IAGI-net Archive 2: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/iagi - DISCLAIMER: IAGI disclaims all warranties with regard to information posted on its mailing lists, whether posted by IAGI or others. In no event shall IAGI or its members be liable for any, including but not limited to direct or indirect damages, or damages of any kind
[iagi-net-l] iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims
Sebelum menghitung claim, batas negara perairan sudah clear belum ya? Karena semestinya menghitung area yg terkena limpahan minyak mengacu ke batas negara. Moga2 pemerintah kita mengantisipasi hal ini dengan cepat. Jangan sampai nanti ada pembakaran bendera Thailand oleh rakyat setempat yg dirugikan. Hanya karena pemerintah kita yang tidak bisa menunjukkan bukti yang kuat, seperti kasus terakhir dengan Malaysia, karena GPS mati. RS -Original Message- From: Doddy Suryanto [mailto:dod...@pttep.com.epintl.com] Sent: Fri 9/3/2010 9:38 AM To: iagi-net@iagi.or.id Subject: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims Updated...fresh from the oven Menyedihkan sudah minta ganti ruginya lewat power point ditambah tanpa bukti-bukti pendukung yang ilmiah. Masih bagus kerjanya YPTB dan pemda setempat yang masih mau menyertakan bukti tumpahan minyak. Seperti Mas Andang utarakan, andai contoh tumpahan minyak yang dikirim YPTB ke corelab disertakan dalam proposal ganti rugi, mungkin PTTEP AA akan berfikir kembali kalau tumpahan minyaknya tidak sampai ke Indonesia. Sebenarnya contoh tumpahan minyak juga dikirim ke Leeders and Consulting Australia Pty. Ltd. melalui senator Rachel Siewert dan diteruskan ke Australia Investigation Committee. Analisis membuktikan bahwa komposisi contoh tumpahan minyak sama dengan minyak yang ada di lapangan Montara. -doddy- PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims PTTEP Australia (PTTEP AA), a subsidiary of the Thai-listed PTT Exploration and Production Public Company Limited today (2 September 2010) confirmed the Government of Indonesia that it has not accepted any claims for compensation relating to the claimed impacts of oil released from the company's Montara field in the Timor Sea last year. PTTEP CEO and President Anon Sirisaengtaksin said that the letter of claim and attached documents contained no verifiable evidence to support the claim. In July and August 2010, representatives from PTTEP AA met in Perth with an Indonesian government delegation on the issue. The latest round of talks took place on 26 August when the Government of Indonesia submitted the letter claiming for compensation with a PowerPoint summary of claim. No verifiable scientific evidence was provided with the claim summary or has yet been provided to support the claims made in the presentation. It was agreed that all data and evidence would need to be analyzed by appropriate parties before PTTEP will consider the claim. PTTEP believes that the Montara incident had no effect on Indonesia because the company was able to control the situation. It also joined hands with agencies under the Government of Australia to continuously monitor and evaluate the effect of the oil released from Montara field and found that it was limited to areas around the field. An independent scientific study which was recently released by the Environmental Protection Authority of Western Australia showed that no oil from Montara reached the WA coast. The company is funding, in cooperation with the Australia Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts (DEWHA), scientific studies from the long term environmental monitoring program. The various studies are being conducted by a range of recognized tertiary and private research groups. The result will be released to the public when completed by DEWHA. -- This message has been scanned for viruses and dangerous content by MailScanner, and is believed to be clean. -- This message has been scanned for viruses and dangerous content by MailScanner, and is believed to be clean.
Re: [iagi-net-l] iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims
tampaknya mas sigit belum tahu lokasi montara... On Fri, Sep 3, 2010 at 10:09 AM, Sigit si...@epintl.com wrote: Sebelum menghitung claim, batas negara perairan sudah clear belum ya? Karena semestinya menghitung area yg terkena limpahan minyak mengacu ke batas negara. Moga2 pemerintah kita mengantisipasi hal ini dengan cepat. Jangan sampai nanti ada pembakaran bendera Thailand oleh rakyat setempat yg dirugikan. Hanya karena pemerintah kita yang tidak bisa menunjukkan bukti yang kuat, seperti kasus terakhir dengan Malaysia, karena GPS mati. RS -Original Message- From: Doddy Suryanto [mailto:dod...@pttep.com.epintl.com] Sent: Fri 9/3/2010 9:38 AM To: iagi-net@iagi.or.id Subject: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims Updated...fresh from the oven Menyedihkan sudah minta ganti ruginya lewat power point ditambah tanpa bukti-bukti pendukung yang ilmiah. Masih bagus kerjanya YPTB dan pemda setempat yang masih mau menyertakan bukti tumpahan minyak. Seperti Mas Andang utarakan, andai contoh tumpahan minyak yang dikirim YPTB ke corelab disertakan dalam proposal ganti rugi, mungkin PTTEP AA akan berfikir kembali kalau tumpahan minyaknya tidak sampai ke Indonesia. Sebenarnya contoh tumpahan minyak juga dikirim ke Leeders and Consulting Australia Pty. Ltd. melalui senator Rachel Siewert dan diteruskan ke Australia Investigation Committee. Analisis membuktikan bahwa komposisi contoh tumpahan minyak sama dengan minyak yang ada di lapangan Montara. -doddy- PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims PTTEP Australia (PTTEP AA), a subsidiary of the Thai-listed PTT Exploration and Production Public Company Limited today (2 September 2010) confirmed the Government of Indonesia that it has not accepted any claims for compensation relating to the claimed impacts of oil released from the company's Montara field in the Timor Sea last year. PTTEP CEO and President Anon Sirisaengtaksin said that the letter of claim and attached documents contained no verifiable evidence to support the claim. In July and August 2010, representatives from PTTEP AA met in Perth with an Indonesian government delegation on the issue. The latest round of talks took place on 26 August when the Government of Indonesia submitted the letter claiming for compensation with a PowerPoint summary of claim. No verifiable scientific evidence was provided with the claim summary or has yet been provided to support the claims made in the presentation. It was agreed that all data and evidence would need to be analyzed by appropriate parties before PTTEP will consider the claim. PTTEP believes that the Montara incident had no effect on Indonesia because the company was able to control the situation. It also joined hands with agencies under the Government of Australia to continuously monitor and evaluate the effect of the oil released from Montara field and found that it was limited to areas around the field. An independent scientific study which was recently released by the Environmental Protection Authority of Western Australia showed that no oil from Montara reached the WA coast. The company is funding, in cooperation with the Australia Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts (DEWHA), scientific studies from the long term environmental monitoring program. The various studies are being conducted by a range of recognized tertiary and private research groups. The result will be released to the public when completed by DEWHA. -- This message has been scanned for viruses and dangerous content by MailScanner, and is believed to be clean. -- This message has been scanned for viruses and dangerous content by MailScanner, and is believed to be clean. -- Mohammad Syaiful - Explorationist, Consultant Geologist Mobile: 62-812-9372808 Emails: msyai...@etti.co.id (business) mohammadsyai...@gmail.com Technical Manager of Exploration Think Tank Indonesia (ETTI) PP-IAGI 2008-2011: ketua umum: LAMBOK HUTASOIT, lam...@gc.itb.ac.id sekjen: MOHAMMAD SYAIFUL, mohammadsyai...@gmail.com * 2 sekretariat (Jkt Bdg), 5 departemen, banyak biro... Ayo siapkan diri! Hadirilah PIT ke-39 IAGI, Senggigi, Lombok NTB, 22-25 November 2010 - To unsubscribe, send email to: iagi-net-unsubscribe[at]iagi.or.id To subscribe, send email to: iagi-net-subscribe[at]iagi.or.id Visit IAGI Website: http://iagi.or.id Pembayaran iuran anggota ditujukan ke: Bank Mandiri Cab. Wisma Alia Jakarta No. Rek: 123 0085005314 Atas nama: Ikatan Ahli Geologi Indonesia (IAGI) Bank BCA KCP. Manara Mulia No. Rekening: 255-1088580 A/n: Shinta Damayanti IAGI-net Archive 1: http://www.mail
Re: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims
Ikut rembug Pak. Terkait dengan klaim pemerintah RI terhadap oil spill di Laut Timor memang agak membingungkan saya. Mengapa saya katakan demikian? Karena masih banyak aspek-aspek yang harus diperhatikan sebelum mengajukan klaim. Contohnya : bukti-bukti ilmiah dan adanya peta-peta yang menunjukkan bahwa wilayah RI juga terkena dampaknya. Tapi, pemerintah kita cenderung menganggap enteng, terutama soal batas negara dan perlunya peta area yang terkena dampak oil spill. Menurut saya, sebelum klaim ya lebih baik disiapkan bukti-bukti yang nyata agar kedua pihak (pemerintah RI dan PTTEP) bisa menemukan solusi yang tepat. Jangan asal klaim saja tanpa argumen yang kuat. Salam, Wendi A -- From: Doddy Suryanto dod...@pttep.com Sent: Friday, 03 September, 2010 8:38 To: iagi-net@iagi.or.id Subject: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims Updated...fresh from the oven Menyedihkan sudah minta ganti ruginya lewat power point ditambah tanpa bukti-bukti pendukung yang ilmiah. Masih bagus kerjanya YPTB dan pemda setempat yang masih mau menyertakan bukti tumpahan minyak. Seperti Mas Andang utarakan, andai contoh tumpahan minyak yang dikirim YPTB ke corelab disertakan dalam proposal ganti rugi, mungkin PTTEP AA akan berfikir kembali kalau tumpahan minyaknya tidak sampai ke Indonesia. Sebenarnya contoh tumpahan minyak juga dikirim ke Leeders and Consulting Australia Pty. Ltd. melalui senator Rachel Siewert dan diteruskan ke Australia Investigation Committee. Analisis membuktikan bahwa komposisi contoh tumpahan minyak sama dengan minyak yang ada di lapangan Montara. -doddy- PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims PTTEP Australia (PTTEP AA), a subsidiary of the Thai-listed PTT Exploration and Production Public Company Limited today (2 September 2010) confirmed the Government of Indonesia that it has not accepted any claims for compensation relating to the claimed impacts of oil released from the company's Montara field in the Timor Sea last year. PTTEP CEO and President Anon Sirisaengtaksin said that the letter of claim and attached documents contained no verifiable evidence to support the claim. In July and August 2010, representatives from PTTEP AA met in Perth with an Indonesian government delegation on the issue. The latest round of talks took place on 26 August when the Government of Indonesia submitted the letter claiming for compensation with a PowerPoint summary of claim. No verifiable scientific evidence was provided with the claim summary or has yet been provided to support the claims made in the presentation. It was agreed that all data and evidence would need to be analyzed by appropriate parties before PTTEP will consider the claim. PTTEP believes that the Montara incident had no effect on Indonesia because the company was able to control the situation. It also joined hands with agencies under the Government of Australia to continuously monitor and evaluate the effect of the oil released from Montara field and found that it was limited to areas around the field. An independent scientific study which was recently released by the Environmental Protection Authority of Western Australia showed that no oil from Montara reached the WA coast. The company is funding, in cooperation with the Australia Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts (DEWHA), scientific studies from the long term environmental monitoring program. The various studies are being conducted by a range of recognized tertiary and private research groups. The result will be released to the public when completed by DEWHA. PP-IAGI 2008-2011: ketua umum: LAMBOK HUTASOIT, lam...@gc.itb.ac.id sekjen: MOHAMMAD SYAIFUL, mohammadsyai...@gmail.com * 2 sekretariat (Jkt Bdg), 5 departemen, banyak biro... Ayo siapkan diri! Hadirilah PIT ke-39 IAGI, Senggigi, Lombok NTB, 22-25 November 2010 - To unsubscribe, send email to: iagi-net-unsubscribe[at]iagi.or.id To subscribe, send email to: iagi-net-subscribe[at]iagi.or.id Visit IAGI Website: http://iagi.or.id Pembayaran iuran anggota ditujukan ke: Bank Mandiri Cab. Wisma Alia Jakarta No. Rek: 123 0085005314 Atas nama: Ikatan Ahli Geologi Indonesia (IAGI) Bank BCA KCP. Manara Mulia No. Rekening: 255-1088580 A/n: Shinta Damayanti IAGI-net Archive 1: http://www.mail-archive.com/iagi-net%40iagi.or.id/ IAGI-net Archive 2: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/iagi - DISCLAIMER: IAGI disclaims all warranties with regard to information posted on its mailing lists, whether posted by IAGI or others. In no event shall IAGI or its members be liable for any, including
RE: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims
Cak Ipul, Terakhir saya ketemu Pak CEO belum ada surat klaim secara formal karena pihak pusat menunggu jumlah ganti rugi yang diberikan pihak daerah. Ini dikarenakan pihak pusat menekan pihak daerah untuk segera memberikan angka sampai batas akhirnya bulan agustus kemarin. Sementara pihak daerah tentu kesulitan memberikan angka karena tidak adanya penyelidikan terintegrasi dari pusat, daerah, PTTEP, dan instansi terkait lainnya. Surat terakhir dari YPTB menyebutkan untuk tidak perlu dilakukan perundingan sebelum tim yang beranggotakan pihak-pihak yang saya sebutkan diatas terbentuk dan menentukan jumlah ganti rugi yang sesuai. Oleh sebab itu saya sendiri cukup bingung dengan adanya angka terakhir dari pihak pusat yang saya yakin bukan dari YPTB atau pihak daerah. Just off the record saja bahwa kemarin pihak pusat menghubungi PTTEP untuk mengusahakan pertemuan tertutup tetapi ternyata rencana ini diketahui oleh masyarkat sebelum pertemuan dilakukan di tempat netral di Singapura. Besar kemungkinan pihak dari Indonesia sendiri (pihak pusat?) yang membocorkan akan adanya pertemuan tertutup ini. salam, -doddy- -Original Message- From: mohammad syaiful [mailto:mohammadsyai...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 03 September, 2010 10:02 AM To: iagi-net@iagi.or.id Subject: Re: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims om doddy, mau konfirmasi saja. jadi pemerintah indonesia sempat presentasi menggunakan power point seperti pada umumnya dan di file presentasi itulah klaim ganti rugi diajukan? jadi tidak ada surat klaim utk minta ganti rugi secara formal? wah, blaen nek ngene negoroku... salam, syaiful * seringkali dapat sms juga dari ferdi tanoni; info informal memang menunjukkan bahwa 'tim resmi' dari pusat enggan utk bekerja, entah apa sebabnya; entah apa juga ada gunanya kalo pakai bendera iagi, lha yg lebih tinggi aja nggak mempan, hiks... On Fri, Sep 3, 2010 at 8:38 AM, Doddy Suryanto dod...@pttep.com wrote: Updated...fresh from the oven Menyedihkan sudah minta ganti ruginya lewat power point ditambah tanpa bukti-bukti pendukung yang ilmiah. Masih bagus kerjanya YPTB dan pemda setempat yang masih mau menyertakan bukti tumpahan minyak. Seperti Mas Andang utarakan, andai contoh tumpahan minyak yang dikirim YPTB ke corelab disertakan dalam proposal ganti rugi, mungkin PTTEP AA akan berfikir kembali kalau tumpahan minyaknya tidak sampai ke Indonesia. Sebenarnya contoh tumpahan minyak juga dikirim ke Leeders and Consulting Australia Pty. Ltd. melalui senator Rachel Siewert dan diteruskan ke Australia Investigation Committee. Analisis membuktikan bahwa komposisi contoh tumpahan minyak sama dengan minyak yang ada di lapangan Montara. -doddy- PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims PTTEP Australia (PTTEP AA), a subsidiary of the Thai-listed PTT Exploration and Production Public Company Limited today (2 September 2010) confirmed the Government of Indonesia that it has not accepted any claims for compensation relating to the claimed impacts of oil released from the company's Montara field in the Timor Sea last year. PTTEP CEO and President Anon Sirisaengtaksin said that the letter of claim and attached documents contained no verifiable evidence to support the claim. In July and August 2010, representatives from PTTEP AA met in Perth with an Indonesian government delegation on the issue. The latest round of talks took place on 26 August when the Government of Indonesia submitted the letter claiming for compensation with a PowerPoint summary of claim. No verifiable scientific evidence was provided with the claim summary or has yet been provided to support the claims made in the presentation. It was agreed that all data and evidence would need to be analyzed by appropriate parties before PTTEP will consider the claim. PTTEP believes that the Montara incident had no effect on Indonesia because the company was able to control the situation. It also joined hands with agencies under the Government of Australia to continuously monitor and evaluate the effect of the oil released from Montara field and found that it was limited to areas around the field. An independent scientific study which was recently released by the Environmental Protection Authority of Western Australia showed that no oil from Montara reached the WA coast. The company is funding, in cooperation with the Australia Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts (DEWHA), scientific studies from the long term environmental monitoring program. The various studies are being conducted by a range of recognized tertiary and private research groups. The result will be released to the public when completed by DEWHA. -- Mohammad Syaiful - Explorationist, Consultant Geologist Mobile: 62-812-9372808 Emails: msyai...@etti.co.id (business) mohammadsyai...@gmail.com Technical Manager of Exploration Think Tank
RE: [iagi-net-l] iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims
Mas Syaiful, Saya tau lokasinya, dan sangat mudah diliat di google. Hanya saya baca di Jakarta Post hari ini tentang claim Indonesia yang direject, yang saya nggak tau adalah areal yang terkena limbah tersebut. Berikut berita lengkapnya: http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2010/08/31/firm-rejects-ri%E2%80%99s-claim-spill-damage.html Di Jakarta Post di sebut: Indonesias team displayed maps of areas impacted by the oil spill which allegedly covered 70,341 square kilometer in the Timor Sea, affecting nine regencies in the area. The map of affected areas was determined by satellite images and water samples collected in several locations. The impacted areas can be visibly seen,Masnellyarti said. Polluted water samples taken from the Timor Sea matched the oil finger print taken from Montaras rig, she added. Nah yang 70,341 sqkm tsb areanya dimana saja, apa sampai melewati batas negara. Kalau betul, apakah batasnya sudah jelas. Atau saya salah? Sorry kalau salah. RS -Original Message- From: mohammad syaiful [mailto:mohammadsyai...@gmail.com] Sent: Fri 9/3/2010 11:15 AM To: iagi-net@iagi.or.id Subject: Re: [iagi-net-l] iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims tampaknya mas sigit belum tahu lokasi montara... On Fri, Sep 3, 2010 at 10:09 AM, Sigit si...@epintl.com wrote: Sebelum menghitung claim, batas negara perairan sudah clear belum ya? Karena semestinya menghitung area yg terkena limpahan minyak mengacu ke batas negara. Moga2 pemerintah kita mengantisipasi hal ini dengan cepat. Jangan sampai nanti ada pembakaran bendera Thailand oleh rakyat setempat yg dirugikan. Hanya karena pemerintah kita yang tidak bisa menunjukkan bukti yang kuat, seperti kasus terakhir dengan Malaysia, karena GPS mati. RS -Original Message- From: Doddy Suryanto [mailto:dod...@pttep.com.epintl.com] Sent: Fri 9/3/2010 9:38 AM To: iagi-net@iagi.or.id Subject: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims Updated...fresh from the oven Menyedihkan sudah minta ganti ruginya lewat power point ditambah tanpa bukti-bukti pendukung yang ilmiah. Masih bagus kerjanya YPTB dan pemda setempat yang masih mau menyertakan bukti tumpahan minyak. Seperti Mas Andang utarakan, andai contoh tumpahan minyak yang dikirim YPTB ke corelab disertakan dalam proposal ganti rugi, mungkin PTTEP AA akan berfikir kembali kalau tumpahan minyaknya tidak sampai ke Indonesia. Sebenarnya contoh tumpahan minyak juga dikirim ke Leeders and Consulting Australia Pty. Ltd. melalui senator Rachel Siewert dan diteruskan ke Australia Investigation Committee. Analisis membuktikan bahwa komposisi contoh tumpahan minyak sama dengan minyak yang ada di lapangan Montara. -doddy- PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims PTTEP Australia (PTTEP AA), a subsidiary of the Thai-listed PTT Exploration and Production Public Company Limited today (2 September 2010) confirmed the Government of Indonesia that it has not accepted any claims for compensation relating to the claimed impacts of oil released from the company's Montara field in the Timor Sea last year. PTTEP CEO and President Anon Sirisaengtaksin said that the letter of claim and attached documents contained no verifiable evidence to support the claim. In July and August 2010, representatives from PTTEP AA met in Perth with an Indonesian government delegation on the issue. The latest round of talks took place on 26 August when the Government of Indonesia submitted the letter claiming for compensation with a PowerPoint summary of claim. No verifiable scientific evidence was provided with the claim summary or has yet been provided to support the claims made in the presentation. It was agreed that all data and evidence would need to be analyzed by appropriate parties before PTTEP will consider the claim. PTTEP believes that the Montara incident had no effect on Indonesia because the company was able to control the situation. It also joined hands with agencies under the Government of Australia to continuously monitor and evaluate the effect of the oil released from Montara field and found that it was limited to areas around the field. An independent scientific study which was recently released by the Environmental Protection Authority of Western Australia showed that no oil from Montara reached the WA coast. The company is funding, in cooperation with the Australia Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts (DEWHA), scientific studies from the long term environmental monitoring program. The various studies are being conducted by a range of recognized tertiary and private research groups. The result will be released to the public when completed by DEWHA. -- This message has been scanned for viruses and dangerous content by MailScanner, and is believed to be clean. -- This message has been
Re: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims
suwun infonya, om doddy. lebih jauh, apakah pihak pusat dalam hal ini adalah menteri perhubungan atau yg lainnya? saya yakin, banyak di antara kita yg belum tahu, siapakah tim yg disebut dari pusat tsb. salam, syaiful 2010/9/3 Doddy Suryanto dod...@pttep.com: Cak Ipul, Terakhir saya ketemu Pak CEO belum ada surat klaim secara formal karena pihak pusat menunggu jumlah ganti rugi yang diberikan pihak daerah. Ini dikarenakan pihak pusat menekan pihak daerah untuk segera memberikan angka sampai batas akhirnya bulan agustus kemarin. Sementara pihak daerah tentu kesulitan memberikan angka karena tidak adanya penyelidikan terintegrasi dari pusat, daerah, PTTEP, dan instansi terkait lainnya. Surat terakhir dari YPTB menyebutkan untuk tidak perlu dilakukan perundingan sebelum tim yang beranggotakan pihak-pihak yang saya sebutkan diatas terbentuk dan menentukan jumlah ganti rugi yang sesuai. Oleh sebab itu saya sendiri cukup bingung dengan adanya angka terakhir dari pihak pusat yang saya yakin bukan dari YPTB atau pihak daerah. Just off the record saja bahwa kemarin pihak pusat menghubungi PTTEP untuk mengusahakan pertemuan tertutup tetapi ternyata rencana ini diketahui oleh masyarkat sebelum pertemuan dilakukan di tempat netral di Singapura. Besar kemungkinan pihak dari Indonesia sendiri (pihak pusat?) yang membocorkan akan adanya pertemuan tertutup ini. salam, -doddy- -Original Message- From: mohammad syaiful [mailto:mohammadsyai...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 03 September, 2010 10:02 AM To: iagi-net@iagi.or.id Subject: Re: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims om doddy, mau konfirmasi saja. jadi pemerintah indonesia sempat presentasi menggunakan power point seperti pada umumnya dan di file presentasi itulah klaim ganti rugi diajukan? jadi tidak ada surat klaim utk minta ganti rugi secara formal? wah, blaen nek ngene negoroku... salam, syaiful * seringkali dapat sms juga dari ferdi tanoni; info informal memang menunjukkan bahwa 'tim resmi' dari pusat enggan utk bekerja, entah apa sebabnya; entah apa juga ada gunanya kalo pakai bendera iagi, lha yg lebih tinggi aja nggak mempan, hiks... On Fri, Sep 3, 2010 at 8:38 AM, Doddy Suryanto dod...@pttep.com wrote: Updated...fresh from the oven Menyedihkan sudah minta ganti ruginya lewat power point ditambah tanpa bukti-bukti pendukung yang ilmiah. Masih bagus kerjanya YPTB dan pemda setempat yang masih mau menyertakan bukti tumpahan minyak. Seperti Mas Andang utarakan, andai contoh tumpahan minyak yang dikirim YPTB ke corelab disertakan dalam proposal ganti rugi, mungkin PTTEP AA akan berfikir kembali kalau tumpahan minyaknya tidak sampai ke Indonesia. Sebenarnya contoh tumpahan minyak juga dikirim ke Leeders and Consulting Australia Pty. Ltd. melalui senator Rachel Siewert dan diteruskan ke Australia Investigation Committee. Analisis membuktikan bahwa komposisi contoh tumpahan minyak sama dengan minyak yang ada di lapangan Montara. -doddy- PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims PTTEP Australia (PTTEP AA), a subsidiary of the Thai-listed PTT Exploration and Production Public Company Limited today (2 September 2010) confirmed the Government of Indonesia that it has not accepted any claims for compensation relating to the claimed impacts of oil released from the company's Montara field in the Timor Sea last year. PTTEP CEO and President Anon Sirisaengtaksin said that the letter of claim and attached documents contained no verifiable evidence to support the claim. In July and August 2010, representatives from PTTEP AA met in Perth with an Indonesian government delegation on the issue. The latest round of talks took place on 26 August when the Government of Indonesia submitted the letter claiming for compensation with a PowerPoint summary of claim. No verifiable scientific evidence was provided with the claim summary or has yet been provided to support the claims made in the presentation. It was agreed that all data and evidence would need to be analyzed by appropriate parties before PTTEP will consider the claim. PTTEP believes that the Montara incident had no effect on Indonesia because the company was able to control the situation. It also joined hands with agencies under the Government of Australia to continuously monitor and evaluate the effect of the oil released from Montara field and found that it was limited to areas around the field. An independent scientific study which was recently released by the Environmental Protection Authority of Western Australia showed that no oil from Montara reached the WA coast. The company is funding, in cooperation with the Australia Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts (DEWHA), scientific studies from the long term environmental monitoring program. The various studies are being conducted by a range of recognized tertiary
Re: [iagi-net-l] iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims
semoga batas negara wis nggak masalah, sam. bahkan salah satu 'pejabat' yg juga geolog, almarhum bapak bona situmorang, yg ikut menuntaskan masalah batas negara antara indonesia dengan aussie. kalo belum beres, misalnya, wah. jadi urusan 3 negara yg ruwet... salam, syaiful On Fri, Sep 3, 2010 at 10:49 AM, Sigit si...@epintl.com wrote: Mas Syaiful, Saya tau lokasinya, dan sangat mudah diliat di google. Hanya saya baca di Jakarta Post hari ini tentang claim Indonesia yang direject, yang saya nggak tau adalah areal yang terkena limbah tersebut. Berikut berita lengkapnya: http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2010/08/31/firm-rejects-ri%E2%80%99s-claim-spill-damage.html Di Jakarta Post di sebut: Indonesia’s team displayed maps of areas impacted by the oil spill which allegedly covered 70,341 square kilometer in the Timor Sea, affecting nine regencies in the area. The map of affected areas was determined by satellite images and water samples collected in several locations. “The impacted areas can be visibly seen,”Masnellyarti said. Polluted water samples taken from the Timor Sea matched the oil finger print taken from Montara’s rig, she added. Nah yang 70,341 sqkm tsb areanya dimana saja, apa sampai melewati batas negara. Kalau betul, apakah batasnya sudah jelas. Atau saya salah? Sorry kalau salah. RS -Original Message- From: mohammad syaiful [mailto:mohammadsyai...@gmail.com] Sent: Fri 9/3/2010 11:15 AM To: iagi-net@iagi.or.id Subject: Re: [iagi-net-l] iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims tampaknya mas sigit belum tahu lokasi montara... On Fri, Sep 3, 2010 at 10:09 AM, Sigit si...@epintl.com wrote: Sebelum menghitung claim, batas negara perairan sudah clear belum ya? Karena semestinya menghitung area yg terkena limpahan minyak mengacu ke batas negara. Moga2 pemerintah kita mengantisipasi hal ini dengan cepat. Jangan sampai nanti ada pembakaran bendera Thailand oleh rakyat setempat yg dirugikan. Hanya karena pemerintah kita yang tidak bisa menunjukkan bukti yang kuat, seperti kasus terakhir dengan Malaysia, karena GPS mati. RS -Original Message- From: Doddy Suryanto [mailto:dod...@pttep.com.epintl.com] Sent: Fri 9/3/2010 9:38 AM To: iagi-net@iagi.or.id Subject: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims Updated...fresh from the oven Menyedihkan sudah minta ganti ruginya lewat power point ditambah tanpa bukti-bukti pendukung yang ilmiah. Masih bagus kerjanya YPTB dan pemda setempat yang masih mau menyertakan bukti tumpahan minyak. Seperti Mas Andang utarakan, andai contoh tumpahan minyak yang dikirim YPTB ke corelab disertakan dalam proposal ganti rugi, mungkin PTTEP AA akan berfikir kembali kalau tumpahan minyaknya tidak sampai ke Indonesia. Sebenarnya contoh tumpahan minyak juga dikirim ke Leeders and Consulting Australia Pty. Ltd. melalui senator Rachel Siewert dan diteruskan ke Australia Investigation Committee. Analisis membuktikan bahwa komposisi contoh tumpahan minyak sama dengan minyak yang ada di lapangan Montara. -doddy- PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims PTTEP Australia (PTTEP AA), a subsidiary of the Thai-listed PTT Exploration and Production Public Company Limited today (2 September 2010) confirmed the Government of Indonesia that it has not accepted any claims for compensation relating to the claimed impacts of oil released from the company's Montara field in the Timor Sea last year. PTTEP CEO and President Anon Sirisaengtaksin said that the letter of claim and attached documents contained no verifiable evidence to support the claim. In July and August 2010, representatives from PTTEP AA met in Perth with an Indonesian government delegation on the issue. The latest round of talks took place on 26 August when the Government of Indonesia submitted the letter claiming for compensation with a PowerPoint summary of claim. No verifiable scientific evidence was provided with the claim summary or has yet been provided to support the claims made in the presentation. It was agreed that all data and evidence would need to be analyzed by appropriate parties before PTTEP will consider the claim. PTTEP believes that the Montara incident had no effect on Indonesia because the company was able to control the situation. It also joined hands with agencies under the Government of Australia to continuously monitor and evaluate the effect of the oil released from Montara field and found that it was limited to areas around the field. An independent scientific study which was recently released by the Environmental Protection Authority of Western Australia showed that no oil from Montara reached the WA coast. The company is funding, in cooperation with the Australia Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts (DEWHA), scientific studies from the long
RE: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims
Pak CEO cuma menyebut Pak F sebagai perwakilan pihak pusat. -doddy- -Original Message- From: mohammad syaiful [mailto:mohammadsyai...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 03 September, 2010 10:53 AM To: iagi-net@iagi.or.id Subject: Re: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims suwun infonya, om doddy. lebih jauh, apakah pihak pusat dalam hal ini adalah menteri perhubungan atau yg lainnya? saya yakin, banyak di antara kita yg belum tahu, siapakah tim yg disebut dari pusat tsb. salam, syaiful 2010/9/3 Doddy Suryanto dod...@pttep.com: Cak Ipul, Terakhir saya ketemu Pak CEO belum ada surat klaim secara formal karena pihak pusat menunggu jumlah ganti rugi yang diberikan pihak daerah. Ini dikarenakan pihak pusat menekan pihak daerah untuk segera memberikan angka sampai batas akhirnya bulan agustus kemarin. Sementara pihak daerah tentu kesulitan memberikan angka karena tidak adanya penyelidikan terintegrasi dari pusat, daerah, PTTEP, dan instansi terkait lainnya. Surat terakhir dari YPTB menyebutkan untuk tidak perlu dilakukan perundingan sebelum tim yang beranggotakan pihak-pihak yang saya sebutkan diatas terbentuk dan menentukan jumlah ganti rugi yang sesuai. Oleh sebab itu saya sendiri cukup bingung dengan adanya angka terakhir dari pihak pusat yang saya yakin bukan dari YPTB atau pihak daerah. Just off the record saja bahwa kemarin pihak pusat menghubungi PTTEP untuk mengusahakan pertemuan tertutup tetapi ternyata rencana ini diketahui oleh masyarkat sebelum pertemuan dilakukan di tempat netral di Singapura. Besar kemungkinan pihak dari Indonesia sendiri (pihak pusat?) yang membocorkan akan adanya pertemuan tertutup ini. salam, -doddy- -Original Message- From: mohammad syaiful [mailto:mohammadsyai...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 03 September, 2010 10:02 AM To: iagi-net@iagi.or.id Subject: Re: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims om doddy, mau konfirmasi saja. jadi pemerintah indonesia sempat presentasi menggunakan power point seperti pada umumnya dan di file presentasi itulah klaim ganti rugi diajukan? jadi tidak ada surat klaim utk minta ganti rugi secara formal? wah, blaen nek ngene negoroku... salam, syaiful * seringkali dapat sms juga dari ferdi tanoni; info informal memang menunjukkan bahwa 'tim resmi' dari pusat enggan utk bekerja, entah apa sebabnya; entah apa juga ada gunanya kalo pakai bendera iagi, lha yg lebih tinggi aja nggak mempan, hiks... On Fri, Sep 3, 2010 at 8:38 AM, Doddy Suryanto dod...@pttep.com wrote: Updated...fresh from the oven Menyedihkan sudah minta ganti ruginya lewat power point ditambah tanpa bukti-bukti pendukung yang ilmiah. Masih bagus kerjanya YPTB dan pemda setempat yang masih mau menyertakan bukti tumpahan minyak. Seperti Mas Andang utarakan, andai contoh tumpahan minyak yang dikirim YPTB ke corelab disertakan dalam proposal ganti rugi, mungkin PTTEP AA akan berfikir kembali kalau tumpahan minyaknya tidak sampai ke Indonesia. Sebenarnya contoh tumpahan minyak juga dikirim ke Leeders and Consulting Australia Pty. Ltd. melalui senator Rachel Siewert dan diteruskan ke Australia Investigation Committee. Analisis membuktikan bahwa komposisi contoh tumpahan minyak sama dengan minyak yang ada di lapangan Montara. -doddy- PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims PTTEP Australia (PTTEP AA), a subsidiary of the Thai-listed PTT Exploration and Production Public Company Limited today (2 September 2010) confirmed the Government of Indonesia that it has not accepted any claims for compensation relating to the claimed impacts of oil released from the company's Montara field in the Timor Sea last year. PTTEP CEO and President Anon Sirisaengtaksin said that the letter of claim and attached documents contained no verifiable evidence to support the claim. In July and August 2010, representatives from PTTEP AA met in Perth with an Indonesian government delegation on the issue. The latest round of talks took place on 26 August when the Government of Indonesia submitted the letter claiming for compensation with a PowerPoint summary of claim. No verifiable scientific evidence was provided with the claim summary or has yet been provided to support the claims made in the presentation. It was agreed that all data and evidence would need to be analyzed by appropriate parties before PTTEP will consider the claim. PTTEP believes that the Montara incident had no effect on Indonesia because the company was able to control the situation. It also joined hands with agencies under the Government of Australia to continuously monitor and evaluate the effect of the oil released from Montara field and found that it was limited to areas around the field. An independent scientific study which was recently released by the Environmental Protection Authority of Western Australia showed that no oil
RE: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims
Menarik juga mengurai puzzle dari Oom Doddy nih, Jadi curious, Menyambung pertanyaan cak Ipul, pihak pusat itu maksudnya kementrian ESDM, Perhubungan, keuangan atau atau apa ya oom? Salam, Yudie Doddy Suryanto dod...@pttep.com To iagi-net@iagi.or.id 09/03/2010 11:02 cc AM Subject RE: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Please respond to Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara iagi-...@iagi.or Compensation Claims .id Pak CEO cuma menyebut Pak F sebagai perwakilan pihak pusat. -doddy- -Original Message- From: mohammad syaiful [mailto:mohammadsyai...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 03 September, 2010 10:53 AM To: iagi-net@iagi.or.id Subject: Re: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims suwun infonya, om doddy. lebih jauh, apakah pihak pusat dalam hal ini adalah menteri perhubungan atau yg lainnya? saya yakin, banyak di antara kita yg belum tahu, siapakah tim yg disebut dari pusat tsb. salam, syaiful 2010/9/3 Doddy Suryanto dod...@pttep.com: Cak Ipul, Terakhir saya ketemu Pak CEO belum ada surat klaim secara formal karena pihak pusat menunggu jumlah ganti rugi yang diberikan pihak daerah. Ini dikarenakan pihak pusat menekan pihak daerah untuk segera memberikan angka sampai batas akhirnya bulan agustus kemarin. Sementara pihak daerah tentu kesulitan memberikan angka karena tidak adanya penyelidikan terintegrasi dari pusat, daerah, PTTEP, dan instansi terkait lainnya. Surat terakhir dari YPTB menyebutkan untuk tidak perlu dilakukan perundingan sebelum tim yang beranggotakan pihak-pihak yang saya sebutkan diatas terbentuk dan menentukan jumlah ganti rugi yang sesuai. Oleh sebab itu saya sendiri cukup bingung dengan adanya angka terakhir dari pihak pusat yang saya yakin bukan dari YPTB atau pihak daerah. Just off the record saja bahwa kemarin pihak pusat menghubungi PTTEP untuk mengusahakan pertemuan tertutup tetapi ternyata rencana ini diketahui oleh masyarkat sebelum pertemuan dilakukan di tempat netral di Singapura. Besar kemungkinan pihak dari Indonesia sendiri (pihak pusat?) yang membocorkan akan adanya pertemuan tertutup ini. salam, -doddy- -Original Message- From: mohammad syaiful [mailto:mohammadsyai...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 03 September, 2010 10:02 AM To: iagi-net@iagi.or.id Subject: Re: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims om doddy, mau konfirmasi saja. jadi pemerintah indonesia sempat presentasi menggunakan power point seperti pada umumnya dan di file presentasi itulah klaim ganti rugi diajukan? jadi tidak ada surat klaim utk minta ganti rugi secara formal? wah, blaen nek ngene negoroku... salam, syaiful * seringkali dapat sms juga dari ferdi tanoni; info informal memang menunjukkan bahwa 'tim resmi' dari pusat enggan utk bekerja, entah apa sebabnya; entah apa juga ada gunanya kalo pakai bendera iagi, lha yg lebih tinggi aja nggak mempan, hiks... On Fri, Sep 3, 2010 at 8:38 AM, Doddy Suryanto dod...@pttep.com wrote: Updated...fresh from the oven Menyedihkan sudah minta ganti ruginya lewat power point ditambah tanpa bukti-bukti pendukung yang ilmiah. Masih bagus kerjanya YPTB dan pemda setempat yang masih mau menyertakan bukti tumpahan minyak. Seperti Mas Andang utarakan, andai contoh tumpahan minyak yang dikirim YPTB ke corelab disertakan dalam proposal ganti rugi, mungkin PTTEP AA akan berfikir kembali kalau tumpahan minyaknya tidak sampai ke Indonesia. Sebenarnya contoh tumpahan minyak juga dikirim ke Leeders and Consulting Australia Pty. Ltd. melalui senator Rachel Siewert dan diteruskan ke Australia Investigation Committee. Analisis membuktikan bahwa komposisi contoh tumpahan minyak sama dengan minyak yang ada di lapangan Montara. -doddy- PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims PTTEP Australia (PTTEP AA), a subsidiary of the Thai-listed PTT Exploration and Production Public Company Limited today (2 September 2010
Re: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims
kalau ini betul, maka sangat menyedihkan... saya kira peran asosiasi profesional: IATMI, IAGI, HAGI perlu konsolidasi untuk membantu pemerintah supaya lebih cerdas sedikit.kalau perlu dikuliti hal-hal seperti ini di depan publik biar pemerintahnya bangun dari mimpi siang tabik, From: Doddy Suryanto dod...@pttep.com To: iagi-net@iagi.or.id Sent: Fri, September 3, 2010 8:38:37 AM Subject: [iagi-net-l] FW: PTTEP News Release: PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims Updated...fresh from the oven Menyedihkan sudah minta ganti ruginya lewat power point ditambah tanpa bukti-bukti pendukung yang ilmiah. Masih bagus kerjanya YPTB dan pemda setempat yang masih mau menyertakan bukti tumpahan minyak. Seperti Mas Andang utarakan, andai contoh tumpahan minyak yang dikirim YPTB ke corelab disertakan dalam proposal ganti rugi, mungkin PTTEP AA akan berfikir kembali kalau tumpahan minyaknya tidak sampai ke Indonesia. Sebenarnya contoh tumpahan minyak juga dikirim ke Leeders and Consulting Australia Pty. Ltd. melalui senator Rachel Siewert dan diteruskan ke Australia Investigation Committee. Analisis membuktikan bahwa komposisi contoh tumpahan minyak sama dengan minyak yang ada di lapangan Montara. -doddy- PTTEP Not Accepted Montara Compensation Claims PTTEP Australia (PTTEP AA), a subsidiary of the Thai-listed PTT Exploration and Production Public Company Limited today (2 September 2010) confirmed the Government of Indonesia that it has not accepted any claims for compensation relating to the claimed impacts of oil released from the company's Montara field in the Timor Sea last year. PTTEP CEO and President Anon Sirisaengtaksin said that the letter of claim and attached documents contained no verifiable evidence to support the claim. In July and August 2010, representatives from PTTEP AA met in Perth with an Indonesian government delegation on the issue. The latest round of talks took place on 26 August when the Government of Indonesia submitted the letter claiming for compensation with a PowerPoint summary of claim. No verifiable scientific evidence was provided with the claim summary or has yet been provided to support the claims made in the presentation. It was agreed that all data and evidence would need to be analyzed by appropriate parties before PTTEP will consider the claim. PTTEP believes that the Montara incident had no effect on Indonesia because the company was able to control the situation. It also joined hands with agencies under the Government of Australia to continuously monitor and evaluate the effect of the oil released from Montara field and found that it was limited to areas around the field. An independent scientific study which was recently released by the Environmental Protection Authority of Western Australia showed that no oil from Montara reached the WA coast. The company is funding, in cooperation with the Australia Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts (DEWHA), scientific studies from the long term environmental monitoring program. The various studies are being conducted by a range of recognized tertiary and private research groups. The result will be released to the public when completed by DEWHA.
