BSD for toolset, GPL for apps

2003-03-25 Thread Donnal Walter
As an academic physician I am working on a set of custom clinical 
applications using Python and wxPython that I wish to make open-source. 
I have started this project by working on a *framework* for such 
applications (called Mindwrapper), and because Python and wxPython both 
have licenses somewhat similar to BSD, I have released the first version 
of Mindwrapper under a BSD license. My intention is to continue 
development of Mindwrapper using BSD.

OTOH, I would like to use a GPL license for the custom clinical 
applications (the set of which I call Prism) that I will develop using 
Mindwrapper. Is this combination of licenses reasonable?

My thinking is this. I want to make sure that the clinical (Prism) 
programs always remain free, but I don't especially care if the 
(Mindwrapper) tool set is used as part of a proprietary product. What I 
clearly do want is for other Python and wxPython developers to feel 
comfortable contributing to Mindwrapper, and my clear sense is that most 
of them prefer BSD-style over GPL-style licenses.

Donnal Walter, M.D.
Arkansas Children's Hospital
--
license-discuss archive is at http://crynwr.com/cgi-bin/ezmlm-cgi?3


Re: BSD for toolset, GPL for apps

2003-03-25 Thread Andy Tai
This should be perfectly fine.  Seems Free (libre)
Software is making great progress in medical
applications!

--- Donnal Walter [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 As an academic physician I am working on a set of
 custom clinical 
 applications using Python and wxPython that I wish
 to make open-source. 
 I have started this project by working on a
 *framework* for such 
 applications (called Mindwrapper), and because
 Python and wxPython both 
 have licenses somewhat similar to BSD, I have
 released the first version 
 of Mindwrapper under a BSD license. My intention is
 to continue 
 development of Mindwrapper using BSD.
 
 OTOH, I would like to use a GPL license for the
 custom clinical 
 applications (the set of which I call Prism) that I
 will develop using 
 Mindwrapper. Is this combination of licenses
 reasonable?
 
 My thinking is this. I want to make sure that the
 clinical (Prism) 
 programs always remain free, but I don't especially
 care if the 
 (Mindwrapper) tool set is used as part of a
 proprietary product. What I 
 clearly do want is for other Python and wxPython
 developers to feel 
 comfortable contributing to Mindwrapper, and my
 clear sense is that most 
 of them prefer BSD-style over GPL-style licenses.
 
 Donnal Walter, M.D.
 Arkansas Children's Hospital


=
Andy Tai, [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Free Software: the software by the people, of the people and for the people! Develop! 
Share! Enhance! Enjoy!
--
license-discuss archive is at http://crynwr.com/cgi-bin/ezmlm-cgi?3