Re: repeated accidental after tie crossing bar

2020-01-24 Thread David Kastrup 
David Kastrup  writes:

> Werner LEMBERG  writes:
>
 some publishers repeat accidentals not only if a tie gets broken
 between staves but also if it crosses a bar line:

 |||
#o|   #o
 \/

 Is there a property in LilyPond to automatically activate this?
>>>
>>> probably:
>>> 
>>> {
>>>   \override Accidental.after-line-breaking = #'()
>>>   cis'1~ cis'
>>> }
>>
>> Thanks for the suggestion.  Unfortunately, it doesn't really work if
>> there are more accidentals following.  For example, this code
>>
>>   {
>> \override Accidental.after-line-breaking = #'()
>> cis'1~ | cis'2 cis'
>>   }
>>
>> yields
>>
>>   ||   |
>> #o|   #o  #o
>>  \/
>>
>> In other words, the repeat accidental is printed, but the note after
>> it gets another accidental.
>
> It works just as well as when breaking across a line.
>
> {
>   cis'1~ \break | cis'2 cis'
> }
>
> also has three accidentals.
>
> Yes, this is a bug (and has been assigned some issue a long time ago)
> but this kind of ripple effect is very hard to avoid.

I mean, this kind of ripple effect is very hard to implement.

-- 
David Kastrup

Re: repeated accidental after tie crossing bar

2020-01-24 Thread David Kastrup 
Werner LEMBERG  writes:

>>> some publishers repeat accidentals not only if a tie gets broken
>>> between staves but also if it crosses a bar line:
>>>
>>> |||
>>>#o|   #o
>>> \/
>>>
>>> Is there a property in LilyPond to automatically activate this?
>>
>> probably:
>> 
>> {
>>   \override Accidental.after-line-breaking = #'()
>>   cis'1~ cis'
>> }
>
> Thanks for the suggestion.  Unfortunately, it doesn't really work if
> there are more accidentals following.  For example, this code
>
>   {
> \override Accidental.after-line-breaking = #'()
> cis'1~ | cis'2 cis'
>   }
>
> yields
>
>   ||   |
> #o|   #o  #o
>  \/
>
> In other words, the repeat accidental is printed, but the note after
> it gets another accidental.

It works just as well as when breaking across a line.

{
  cis'1~ \break | cis'2 cis'
}

also has three accidentals.

Yes, this is a bug (and has been assigned some issue a long time ago)
but this kind of ripple effect is very hard to avoid.

-- 
David Kastrup

Re: repeated accidental after tie crossing bar

2020-01-24 Thread David Kastrup 
Thomas Morley  writes:

> Am Fr., 24. Jan. 2020 um 22:42 Uhr schrieb Werner LEMBERG :
>>
>>
>> Folks,
>>
>>
>> some publishers repeat accidentals not only if a tie gets broken
>> between staves but also if it crosses a bar line:
>>
>> |||
>>#o|   #o
>> \/
>>
>> Is there a property in LilyPond to automatically activate this?
>>
>>
>> Werner
>>
>
> Hi Werner,
>
> probably:
>
> {
>   \override Accidental.after-line-breaking = #'()
>   cis'1~ cis'
> }

That is chutzpah.

-- 
David Kastrup

Re: repeated accidental after tie crossing bar

2020-01-24 Thread Werner LEMBERG 
>> some publishers repeat accidentals not only if a tie gets broken
>> between staves but also if it crosses a bar line:
>>
>> |||
>>#o|   #o
>> \/
>>
>> Is there a property in LilyPond to automatically activate this?
>
> probably:
> 
> {
>   \override Accidental.after-line-breaking = #'()
>   cis'1~ cis'
> }

Thanks for the suggestion.  Unfortunately, it doesn't really work if
there are more accidentals following.  For example, this code

  {
\override Accidental.after-line-breaking = #'()
cis'1~ | cis'2 cis'
  }

yields

  ||   |
#o|   #o  #o
 \/

In other words, the repeat accidental is printed, but the note after
it gets another accidental.

If I do it manually, it works as expected,

  {
cis'1~ | cis'!2 cis'
  }

giving the correct

  ||   |
#o|   #o   o
 \/


Werner

Re: repeated accidental after tie crossing bar

2020-01-24 Thread Thomas Morley 
Am Fr., 24. Jan. 2020 um 22:42 Uhr schrieb Werner LEMBERG :
>
>
> Folks,
>
>
> some publishers repeat accidentals not only if a tie gets broken
> between staves but also if it crosses a bar line:
>
> |||
>#o|   #o
> \/
>
> Is there a property in LilyPond to automatically activate this?
>
>
> Werner
>

Hi Werner,

probably:

{
  \override Accidental.after-line-breaking = #'()
  cis'1~ cis'
}

Best,
  Harm

repeated accidental after tie crossing bar

2020-01-24 Thread Werner LEMBERG 


Folks,


some publishers repeat accidentals not only if a tie gets broken
between staves but also if it crosses a bar line:

|||
   #o|   #o
\/

Is there a property in LilyPond to automatically activate this?


Werner