Re: strange chord

2024-05-12 Thread Werner LEMBERG

> I mean… technically, it’s correct…

Thanks.

> but yuck.

:-)


> If I were customizing the name, I would probably have it say
> Em(addb4).  At the very least it should say Emsusb4.

As chord names noob I have no opinion to that.  I just wanted to
ensure that MR !2335 produces correct results, even if they are
sometimes bizarre, apparently.


Werner


Re: strange chord

2024-05-12 Thread Kieren MacMillan
Hi Werner,

I mean… technically, it’s correct… but yuck.

If I were customizing the name, I would probably have it say Em(addb4).
At the very least it should say Emsusb4.

— Kieren
__

My work day may look different than your work day. Please do not feel obligated 
to read or respond to this email outside of your normal working hours.




Re: strange chord

2024-05-12 Thread Werner LEMBERG

> I tried the following
>
> ```
> \version "2.25.16"
>
> chord = \chordmode { c4:6-^1 }
>
> <<
>   \new ChordNames \chord
>   \chordmode { \chord }
> >>
> ```
>
> and got the attached result.  The displayed chord name looks weird
> to me, but I'm no expert for Jazz chords...  Is it correct?  If not,
> how should it be displayed?

Oops, now attached.


Werner


strange chord

2024-05-12 Thread Werner LEMBERG


I tried the following

```
\version "2.25.16"

chord = \chordmode { c4:6-^1 }

<<
  \new ChordNames \chord
  \chordmode { \chord }
>>
```

and got the attached result.  The displayed chord name looks weird to
me, but I'm no expert for Jazz chords...  Is it correct?  If not, how
should it be displayed?


Werner