Thank you, Yoshio!!
I just applied the change, seems it works! But it doesn't work
correctly. I mean it won't give me traps any more, but the answer is
not correctly. I just tried to multiply two float numbers. But it
gives me 0.
The first time I change the reg.h was to enable apu enable, apu
exception enable and fpu enable. It gives me answer 0.
The second try I did was enabling apu enable and apu exception,
because I notice that inside /arch/powerpc/kernel/fpu.S, it will
enable FPU in load_up_fpu. So I guess I cannot enable FPU all the
time. However, this time it gave me trap again, well, with a
different MSR.
Now my guess is load_up_fpu is not working correctly. I am working on
that.
Shan
On Apr 15, 2008, at 2:20 PM, Yoshio Kashiwagi wrote:
Hi,
The following modification is required if you use APU in user space.
in include/asm-powerpc/reg.h
-#define MSR_USER (MSR_KERNEL|MSR_PR|MSR_EE)
+#define MSR_USER (MSR_KERNEL|MSR_PR|MSR_EE|MSR_VEC)
Yoshio Kashiwagi - Nissin Systems
Thank you very much, Steve and John!
My advisor and I discussed how Linux works with APU/FPU a few days
ago.
And he had the same thoughts with John. My naive guess was it would
automatically decode FP operations and mask the trap. Now it
answers my
second question. I will try it later.
But for my first question, I searched all (almost all) the files,
such
as head.S, entry.S, head_4xx.S, etc. And added following three lines
before mtmsr or MTMSRD �are used
ori � � � �r10, r10, 113 �/* enable fpu */
oris � � �r10, r10, 19 � �/* enable apu */
oris � � �r10, r10, 13 � �/* enable apu exception */
However the MSR in trap prompts keeps the same (2d030) before and
after I added those lines.�
[�� 31.819079] Bad trap at PC: 1458, MSR: 2d030,
vector=800��� Not
tainted
[�� 31.887027]�� Signal: 5
[�� 31.887042]�� Code:�� 0
[�� 31.887058]�� Addr:�� 0
Trace/breakpoint trap
I guess there must be some places, like some interrupts that changed
the MSR that I didn't know. �
And for FP exceptions, it has two bits (two modes) in MSR. I think
they are for such exceptions like divided by zero. Do I need to set
them
also?
In my previous build, I also added PPC_FPU under config 40x in arch/
ppc/Kconfig. It compiled arch/powerpc/kernel/fpu.S in, but didn't
help.
I will try CONFIG_PPC_FPU later.
Shan
On Apr 14, 2008, at 2:32 PM, John Bonesio wrote:
Hi,
The Linux kernel itself doesn't issue floating point instructions
other than to save and restore the fpu state when necessary.
In Linux, the way it saves and restores the fpu state is to make use
of the trap. When the trap (fpu unavailable) occurs, it loads the fpu
state for the current task, sets up the MSR, and returns to re-try the
instruction.
So, getting the trap is normal. If the FPU is not being set up
correctly, then there may be a problem with the restoring of the
state.
When you guild the Linux kernel, you need to have CONFIG_PPC_FPU
enabled. Otherwise the kernel does not setup the fpu exception
handling.
- John
On Monday 14 April 2008 10:35, Stephen Neuendorffer wrote:
I'm not sure exactly what's going on here.� Generally speaking,
if you
have the FPU instantiated in the design and enable the APU in the
msr,
then the processor should decode FP instructions and send them
directly
to the APU with no trap.� I haven't done this myself, or I could
probably give you some better help...
One thing you should be aware of is that the there are gcc compiler
patches which are necessary to get the FPU working properly.�
However,
I
don't think the failure mode that these patches workaround would
cause
a
trap, so my guess is that there is still something else wrong.
Steve
-Original Message-
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
[mailto:linuxppc-embedded-
[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Shanyuan
Gao
Sent: Monday, April 14, 2008 9:18 AM
To: linuxppc-embedded@ozlabs.org
Subject: Problems of using APU/FPU under linux
Hi,
Recently I was trying to make APU/FPU working under Linux on Xilinx
ML410. The standalone programs work perfectly. However under Linux,
when I try to use a floating point operation, like *fmuls*, it will
give me a *trap*.
By studying the user guide from Xilinx and dumping the object files,
I know I need to change the corresponding bits (APU enable, FP
enable, maybe APU Exception enable) in Machine State Register. I
guess I need to enable the bits whenever before the kernel uses
*mtmsr*. However, it doesn't work. I got the same trap with the same
MSR, as I had no APU/FPU before. I also tried to add the FPU.S to ppc
tree, but it doesn't work either.
The questions are
1. I guess there might be some place that changed MSR after all my
changes. But I don't know where. And can I write a kernel module to
change the MSR after booting in Linux? (well, it's hard for me
though)
2. Does it have any exception/interrupt mechanism to direct FP
operation to APU/FPU? Or after enabling APU/FPU
