Re: Compiling log4net with strong name and 3rd party dependencies (also is log4net in a cul-du-sac)

2011-08-08 Thread Curt Arnold
I wrote this message last night in response to the is log4net in a cul-du-sac 
thread, but it got bounced due to a spam guard which I've hopefully satisfied 
this time.   The strong naming key that has been used to sign log4net releases 
has been encrypted and can be decrypted using the private keys of several 
people including myself. I'd be happy to perform the release build or reencrypt 
the strong signing key to another PMC member who wants to help. However, to get 
to that point, it will take people who are motivated to pitch in and get things 
ready for release. Further discussion should be on log4net-dev. 

My message from last night:


I'm not sure if this message got an adequate answer.

For those who want to drive a release forward, I would suggest:

Create a bug report for the next release (check if there is already one)

Make that bug dependent on any issue that you think needs to be resolved before 
the next release

If there are any debatable issues (like dropping support for earlier .NET 
versions), start a vote on the mailing list. If there are interrelated issues, 
perhaps create a page on the logging wiki and have a vote on all the issues in 
the same time.

If there are bugs without test cases or patches, create test cases and patches.

If there are bugs with test case and patches that should be committed, make a 
comment on the bug that it appears ready to go.

Hopefully through this process, we can develop the track record that will allow 
adding some new committers or PMC members.


On Aug 8, 2011, at 4:27 PM, Jim Scott wrote:

 From: Johannes Gustafsson
 Sent: Monday, August 08, 2011 1:20 PM
 To: log4net-u...@logging.apache.org
 Subject: Compiling log4net with strong name and 3rd party dependencies
 Hi,
  
 There are a few bugfixes in the trunk that I need and since there has been no 
 new release for a very long time, I tried to compile it myself. I created a 
 key and have successfully compiled it with no problems. However, I have quite 
 a few 3rd party dependencies that themselves are dependent on log4net. These 
 dependencies can't find load the new assembly that I have created because 
 they require that it is signed with a key that I dont have access to. So this 
 means that I can't use my own version of log4net without recompiling all my 
 dependencies.
  
 Do you have any suggestions to how I can solve this?
  
 Regards,
 /Johannes
  
  
 Yes, this is the same issue we have. I have a few features I would like to 
 add but the thought of having to recompile everything has kept me from doing 
 so.
  



Re: Compiling log4net with strong name and 3rd party dependencies (also is log4net in a cul-du-sac)

2011-08-08 Thread Stefan Bodewig
On 2011-08-09, Curt Arnold wrote:

 For those who want to drive a release forward, I would suggest:

 Create a bug report for the next release (check if there is already
 one)

JIRA already has 1.2.11 as release version and tons of issues assigned
to it.  20 are still open 34 are already in the resolved state.

Some triage may be in order.  34 fixed issues sounds huge and it may
very well be worth pushing back some issues without patches and release
the rest now rather than waiting for the rest.

I'm not sure we need a separate issue for the release itself when JIRA
provides the roadmap view.

 If there are any debatable issues (like dropping support for earlier
 .NET versions), start a vote on the mailing list. If there are
 interrelated issues, perhaps create a page on the logging wiki and
 have a vote on all the issues in the same time.

 If there are bugs without test cases or patches, create test cases and
 patches.

 If there are bugs with test case and patches that should be committed,
 make a comment on the bug that it appears ready to go.

 Hopefully through this process, we can develop the track record that
 will allow adding some new committers or PMC members.

Sounds like a plan.

Stefan


[jira] [Created] (LOG4NET-299) Release Log4Net 1.2.11

2011-08-08 Thread Stefan Bodewig (JIRA)
Release Log4Net 1.2.11
--

 Key: LOG4NET-299
 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/LOG4NET-299
 Project: Log4net
  Issue Type: Task
  Components: Other
Reporter: Stefan Bodewig
 Fix For: 1.2.11


Master issue to track the 1.2.11 release

--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira