Re: [lxc-users] Getting kdump to work on an LXC server

2014-09-12 Thread Rod Bruce
On 09/11/2014 04:07 PM, Serge Hallyn wrote:
 Quoting Rod Bruce (rod.br...@mnsu.edu):
 Greetings,
 I have been working on a problem the last couple of days and I believe I
 have come up with a solution so I thought I would share it with the list
 in case anybody else runs into this or someone has a better solution.


 Problem:
 I have had a server running Ubuntu 14.04 hang a couple of times. I try
 to run everything using standard Ubuntu packages. The server is an LXC
 host with two containers running on it (but several more planned). I
 wanted to get a kernel core dump if it hung again so I started
 investigating kdump/kexec. I installed, configured, and tested
 kdump/kexec on another server and it worked as advertised. However, when
 I tried it on the LXC server it would save the core dump OK but the
 server would fail to reboot or hang at some other point in the process.

 I noticed that when kexec was booting the secondary kernel it was
 starting up all of the services that start on a normal boot, including
 LXC, and that seemed to be causing a problem. When I set the containers
 
 Do you have any idea why it was causing a problem?

I do not.

 
 Now that you are kexecing into runlevel 2, after you do that, are you
 able to start the lxc service and lxc container by hand?

When kexec kicks off the secondary kernel as part of the kdump process
it writes out the kernel core dump and, when that is finished, the
server reboots. This is the result I was working toward. With this
scenario there is not a chance to start lxc.

I will try to simulate this by kexecing manually into runlevel 2 and
then starting up lxc and report back.

 ___
 lxc-users mailing list
 lxc-users@lists.linuxcontainers.org
 http://lists.linuxcontainers.org/listinfo/lxc-users
 


-- 

Rod Bruce
UNIX System and Network Administrator
PALS, A Program of the
Minnesota State Colleges and Universities
rod.br...@mnsu.edu
507.389.2000

Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
___
lxc-users mailing list
lxc-users@lists.linuxcontainers.org
http://lists.linuxcontainers.org/listinfo/lxc-users

Re: [lxc-users] Getting kdump to work on an LXC server

2014-09-11 Thread Serge Hallyn
Quoting Rod Bruce (rod.br...@mnsu.edu):
 Greetings,
 I have been working on a problem the last couple of days and I believe I
 have come up with a solution so I thought I would share it with the list
 in case anybody else runs into this or someone has a better solution.
 
 
 Problem:
 I have had a server running Ubuntu 14.04 hang a couple of times. I try
 to run everything using standard Ubuntu packages. The server is an LXC
 host with two containers running on it (but several more planned). I
 wanted to get a kernel core dump if it hung again so I started
 investigating kdump/kexec. I installed, configured, and tested
 kdump/kexec on another server and it worked as advertised. However, when
 I tried it on the LXC server it would save the core dump OK but the
 server would fail to reboot or hang at some other point in the process.
 
 I noticed that when kexec was booting the secondary kernel it was
 starting up all of the services that start on a normal boot, including
 LXC, and that seemed to be causing a problem. When I set the containers

Do you have any idea why it was causing a problem?

Now that you are kexecing into runlevel 2, after you do that, are you
able to start the lxc service and lxc container by hand?
___
lxc-users mailing list
lxc-users@lists.linuxcontainers.org
http://lists.linuxcontainers.org/listinfo/lxc-users