Re: Proposal updated

[Rob Oakes]

Hi Richard,

On Fri, 2013-05-03 at 00:35 -0500, Vanderbilt wrote:

 There is only one point in your comment that I'm not clear about; if
 I'm understanding you correctly, do you mean the community is not sure
 about whether to use signals/slots so I probably shouldn't include
 that part in my proposal? But Rob said we are using signals/slots;
 it's just the type of signals that is not clear (if I'm understanding
 him correctly). Could you clarify a little bit?

I apologize for the radio silence, I'm still struggling to get my
project wrapped up and delivered. It absolutely must be done today,
though. I will have time this afternoon/over the weekend to respond to
the signal/slot questions on the list.

I'll continue that conversation in the other thread.

Cheers,

Rob

Re: Proposal updated

[Rob Oakes]

Hi Richard,

On Fri, 2013-05-03 at 00:35 -0500, Vanderbilt wrote:

> There is only one point in your comment that I'm not clear about; if
> I'm understanding you correctly, do you mean the community is not sure
> about whether to use signals/slots so I probably shouldn't include
> that part in my proposal? But Rob said we are using signals/slots;
> it's just the type of signals that is not clear (if I'm understanding
> him correctly). Could you clarify a little bit?

I apologize for the radio silence, I'm still struggling to get my
project wrapped up and delivered. It absolutely must be done today,
though. I will have time this afternoon/over the weekend to respond to
the signal/slot questions on the list.

I'll continue that conversation in the other thread.

Cheers,

Rob

Proposal updated

[Vanderbilt]

Hi Richard,

Thank you for your comment. I talked to Rob and I updated my proposal based on 
your and his opinions. I would appreciate if you can take a quick look:

https://google-melange.appspot.com/gsoc/proposal/review/google/gsoc2013/shanx/1

There is only one point in your comment that I'm not clear about; if I'm 
understanding you correctly, do you mean the community is not sure about 
whether to use signals/slots so I probably shouldn't include that part in my 
proposal? But Rob said we are using signals/slots; it's just the type of 
signals that is not clear (if I'm understanding him correctly). Could you 
clarify a little bit?

Thanks,
Ashley

Proposal updated

[Vanderbilt]

Hi Richard,

Thank you for your comment. I talked to Rob and I updated my proposal based on 
your and his opinions. I would appreciate if you can take a quick look:

https://google-melange.appspot.com/gsoc/proposal/review/google/gsoc2013/shanx/1

There is only one point in your comment that I'm not clear about; if I'm 
understanding you correctly, do you mean the community is not sure about 
whether to use signals/slots so I probably shouldn't include that part in my 
proposal? But Rob said we are using signals/slots; it's just the type of 
signals that is not clear (if I'm understanding him correctly). Could you 
clarify a little bit?

Thanks,
Ashley

Re: Proposal updated, please take a look

[Vanderbilt]

Hi Cyrille,

Thank you for your reply. When I mention existing work, I mean Rob's previous 
implementation... I didn't have any implementation myself, sorry! I'll update 
this part of the proposal tomorrow if there be any confusions. 

I really appreciate your opinion; except for the corkboard part, do you think 
there are other parts I should work more on?

Thank you,
Xueqing Shan

On Apr 30, 2013, at 12:57 AM, Cyrille Artho c.ar...@aist.go.jp wrote:

 Hi Xueqing,
 Thank you for the update. You mention that you already have an implementation 
 of a corkboard; do you have that code online somewhere? If we can see code 
 related to a project application, this make a proposal much stronger. Feel 
 free to post the link to the code only on Google Melange if you do not wish 
 to disclose it on the mailing list.
 
 
 Ashley Shan wrote:
 Hi community,
 
 According to Cyrille's suggestions, I have updated my proposal. Here it is:
 
 https://google-melange.appspot.com/gsoc/proposal/review/google/gsoc2013/shanx/1
 
 I was using another email address (shanxueq...@gmail.com
 mailto:shanxueq...@gmail.com) when I registered for GSoC. I would greatly
 appreciate if any prospective mentors can take a look and give me some
 suggestions.
 
 Best,
 Xueqing Shan
 
 *Xueqing Shan*
 Vanderbilt University, '16
 
 -- 
 Regards,
 Cyrille Artho - http://artho.com/
 Always think of something new; this helps you forget your last rotten idea.
-- Seth Frankel
 

Re: Proposal updated, please take a look

[Cyrille Artho]

Hi Xueqing,
As with proposals in general, if you have a simple proof-of-concept program 
(i.e., code that works as a demo), then your proposal will be among the top 
contenders.
I understand that you may not know enough about Qt for this, but maybe you 
can create a demo program on a different platform in that case? Even if the 
functionality very restricted and the code is not reusable, a demo is the 
best way to convince us. :-)



Vanderbilt wrote:

Hi Cyrille,

Thank you for your reply. When I mention existing work, I mean Rob's previous 
implementation... I didn't have any implementation myself, sorry! I'll update this part 
of the proposal tomorrow if there be any confusions.

I really appreciate your opinion; except for the corkboard part, do you think 
there are other parts I should work more on?

Thank you,
Xueqing Shan

On Apr 30, 2013, at 12:57 AM, Cyrille Artho c.ar...@aist.go.jp wrote:


Hi Xueqing,
Thank you for the update. You mention that you already have an implementation 
of a corkboard; do you have that code online somewhere? If we can see code 
related to a project application, this make a proposal much stronger. Feel free 
to post the link to the code only on Google Melange if you do not wish to 
disclose it on the mailing list.


Ashley Shan wrote:

Hi community,

According to Cyrille's suggestions, I have updated my proposal. Here it is:

https://google-melange.appspot.com/gsoc/proposal/review/google/gsoc2013/shanx/1

I was using another email address (shanxueq...@gmail.com
mailto:shanxueq...@gmail.com) when I registered for GSoC. I would greatly
appreciate if any prospective mentors can take a look and give me some
suggestions.

Best,
Xueqing Shan

*Xueqing Shan*
Vanderbilt University, '16


--
Regards,
Cyrille Artho - http://artho.com/
Always think of something new; this helps you forget your last rotten idea.
-- Seth Frankel





--
Regards,
Cyrille Artho - http://artho.com/
The way of the world is to praise dead saints and prosecute live ones.
-- Nathaniel Howe

Re: Proposal updated, please take a look

[Vanderbilt]

Hi Cyrille,

Thank you for your reply. When I mention "existing work", I mean Rob's previous 
implementation... I didn't have any implementation myself, sorry! I'll update 
this part of the proposal tomorrow if there be any confusions. 

I really appreciate your opinion; except for the corkboard part, do you think 
there are other parts I should work more on?

Thank you,
Xueqing Shan

On Apr 30, 2013, at 12:57 AM, Cyrille Artho  wrote:

> Hi Xueqing,
> Thank you for the update. You mention that you already have an implementation 
> of a corkboard; do you have that code online somewhere? If we can see code 
> related to a project application, this make a proposal much stronger. Feel 
> free to post the link to the code only on Google Melange if you do not wish 
> to disclose it on the mailing list.
> 
> 
> Ashley Shan wrote:
>> Hi community,
>> 
>> According to Cyrille's suggestions, I have updated my proposal. Here it is:
>> 
>> https://google-melange.appspot.com/gsoc/proposal/review/google/gsoc2013/shanx/1
>> 
>> I was using another email address (shanxueq...@gmail.com
>> ) when I registered for GSoC. I would greatly
>> appreciate if any prospective mentors can take a look and give me some
>> suggestions.
>> 
>> Best,
>> Xueqing Shan
>> 
>> *Xueqing Shan*
>> Vanderbilt University, '16
> 
> -- 
> Regards,
> Cyrille Artho - http://artho.com/
> Always think of something new; this helps you forget your last rotten idea.
>-- Seth Frankel
> 

Re: Proposal updated, please take a look

[Cyrille Artho]

Hi Xueqing,
As with proposals in general, if you have a simple proof-of-concept program 
(i.e., code that works as a demo), then your proposal will be among the top 
contenders.
I understand that you may not know enough about Qt for this, but maybe you 
can create a demo program on a different platform in that case? Even if the 
functionality very restricted and the code is not reusable, a demo is the 
best way to convince us. :-)



Vanderbilt wrote:

Hi Cyrille,

Thank you for your reply. When I mention "existing work", I mean Rob's previous 
implementation... I didn't have any implementation myself, sorry! I'll update this part 
of the proposal tomorrow if there be any confusions.

I really appreciate your opinion; except for the corkboard part, do you think 
there are other parts I should work more on?

Thank you,
Xueqing Shan

On Apr 30, 2013, at 12:57 AM, Cyrille Artho  wrote:


Hi Xueqing,
Thank you for the update. You mention that you already have an implementation 
of a corkboard; do you have that code online somewhere? If we can see code 
related to a project application, this make a proposal much stronger. Feel free 
to post the link to the code only on Google Melange if you do not wish to 
disclose it on the mailing list.


Ashley Shan wrote:

Hi community,

According to Cyrille's suggestions, I have updated my proposal. Here it is:

https://google-melange.appspot.com/gsoc/proposal/review/google/gsoc2013/shanx/1

I was using another email address (shanxueq...@gmail.com
) when I registered for GSoC. I would greatly
appreciate if any prospective mentors can take a look and give me some
suggestions.

Best,
Xueqing Shan

*Xueqing Shan*
Vanderbilt University, '16


--
Regards,
Cyrille Artho - http://artho.com/
Always think of something new; this helps you forget your last rotten idea.
-- Seth Frankel





--
Regards,
Cyrille Artho - http://artho.com/
The way of the world is to praise dead saints and prosecute live ones.
-- Nathaniel Howe

Proposal updated, please take a look

[Ashley Shan]

Hi community,

According to Cyrille's suggestions, I have updated my proposal. Here it is:

https://google-melange.appspot.com/gsoc/proposal/review/google/gsoc2013/shanx/1

I was using another email address (shanxueq...@gmail.com) when I registered
for GSoC. I would greatly appreciate if any prospective mentors can take a
look and give me some suggestions.

Best,
Xueqing Shan

*Xueqing Shan*
Vanderbilt University, '16

Re: Proposal updated, please take a look

[Cyrille Artho]

Hi Xueqing,
Thank you for the update. You mention that you already have an 
implementation of a corkboard; do you have that code online somewhere? If 
we can see code related to a project application, this make a proposal much 
stronger. Feel free to post the link to the code only on Google Melange if 
you do not wish to disclose it on the mailing list.



Ashley Shan wrote:

Hi community,

According to Cyrille's suggestions, I have updated my proposal. Here it is:

https://google-melange.appspot.com/gsoc/proposal/review/google/gsoc2013/shanx/1

I was using another email address (shanxueq...@gmail.com
mailto:shanxueq...@gmail.com) when I registered for GSoC. I would greatly
appreciate if any prospective mentors can take a look and give me some
suggestions.

Best,
Xueqing Shan

*Xueqing Shan*
Vanderbilt University, '16


--
Regards,
Cyrille Artho - http://artho.com/
Always think of something new; this helps you forget your last rotten idea.
-- Seth Frankel

Proposal updated, please take a look

[Ashley Shan]

Hi community,

According to Cyrille's suggestions, I have updated my proposal. Here it is:

https://google-melange.appspot.com/gsoc/proposal/review/google/gsoc2013/shanx/1

I was using another email address (shanxueq...@gmail.com) when I registered
for GSoC. I would greatly appreciate if any prospective mentors can take a
look and give me some suggestions.

Best,
Xueqing Shan

*Xueqing Shan*
Vanderbilt University, '16

Re: Proposal updated, please take a look

[Cyrille Artho]

Hi Xueqing,
Thank you for the update. You mention that you already have an 
implementation of a corkboard; do you have that code online somewhere? If 
we can see code related to a project application, this make a proposal much 
stronger. Feel free to post the link to the code only on Google Melange if 
you do not wish to disclose it on the mailing list.



Ashley Shan wrote:

Hi community,

According to Cyrille's suggestions, I have updated my proposal. Here it is:

https://google-melange.appspot.com/gsoc/proposal/review/google/gsoc2013/shanx/1

I was using another email address (shanxueq...@gmail.com
) when I registered for GSoC. I would greatly
appreciate if any prospective mentors can take a look and give me some
suggestions.

Best,
Xueqing Shan

*Xueqing Shan*
Vanderbilt University, '16


--
Regards,
Cyrille Artho - http://artho.com/
Always think of something new; this helps you forget your last rotten idea.
-- Seth Frankel