Re: notes/comments (was Re: bilingual documents?)

2001-07-17 Thread Matej Cepl

Yes!!! This is something which I would love to have for a long 
time. Together with importing comments in LaTeX file into LyX as 
notes.

Matej

On 9 Jul 2001, at 13:56, Guenter Milde wrote:

> On Thu, 28 Jun 2001 11:54:16 -0300 wrote Ralph Boland
> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>:
> 
> > Of interest, I also have to send versions of my papers to
> > my supervisor or to co-authors.
> > 
> > It would be very useful to be able to insert comments in the
> > middle of a paragraph.  e.g.  (break sentence in two)
> >(give reference)
> > 
> > I guess margin comments are supposed to provide this
> > facility.  However I would like:
> >   1)  The comment marker to be more visible.
> >  Like the bright yellow and large box of the Note
> >  marker.
> >   2)  The ability to have the comment appear in
> > the text rather than have to open up the marker
> > (like math equations).
> > This ability needs to controllable on an individual
> >  comment basis and on a global basis.
> >   3)  The ability to "go to prev/next comment".  Thus if
> >   someone
> > has marked up my paper with comments I would like to be
> > able to go through them one at a time.  I would want to
> > be able to program a key to do this.
> >   4)   I personally wouldn't want them printed as happens with
> > margin comments.  Personal tastes may vary here.
> > I suppose this could be controllable too.
> >5)  Note that a Note comment cannot be used here because
> >  it doesn't allow math equations etc. to be placed in
> >  them.
> 
> Note, that almost all would be solved, if a Note would allow math
> etc. (I darkly remember, that there was something like
> "open/close all" for floats + the ability to toggle this by
> clicking) ...
> 
> So my suggestion would be to make the note box more like a
> footnote box: i.e. it should not open a separate window but an
> inset (like floats, errors, ert-inset, and footnotes) and should
> (as a footnote or a comment) allow all the lyx-stuff like math,
> figures ... 
> 
> The difference to the "Comment" paragraph style would be like the
> one between LaTeX paragraph and ERT-inset (+ the "Go To Note"
> menu entry in the Navigate menu). 
> 
> Normal keybindings would work (xforms and KDE don't work well
> together, therefore my  key does  in all popup-windows,
> which sometimes is anoying.
> 
> LaTeX export should also export notes (as comments, may be with a
> leading "%Note:") (Then also optional printing is possible with
> the right package ...)
> 
>  What do other people think of this?  Would this be much work or
>  could some
> existing code be reused? Should I have posted to devel?
> 
> Guenter
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> --
> [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> 





Re: notes/comments (was Re: bilingual documents?)

2001-07-09 Thread Guenter Milde

On Thu, 28 Jun 2001 11:54:16 -0300 wrote Ralph Boland <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>:

> Of interest, I also have to send versions of my papers to
> my supervisor or to co-authors.
> 
> It would be very useful to be able to insert comments in the
> middle of a paragraph.  e.g.  (break sentence in two)
>(give reference)
> 
> I guess margin comments are supposed to provide this
> facility.  However I would like:
>   1)  The comment marker to be more visible.
>  Like the bright yellow and large box of the Note marker.
>   2)  The ability to have the comment appear in
> the text rather than have to open up the marker
> (like math equations).
> This ability needs to controllable on an individual
>  comment basis and on a global basis.
>   3)  The ability to "go to prev/next comment".  Thus if someone
> has marked up my paper with comments I would like to
> be able to go through them one at a time.  I would want
> to be able to program a key to do this.
>   4)   I personally wouldn't want them printed as happens with
> margin comments.  Personal tastes may vary here.
> I suppose this could be controllable too.
>5)  Note that a Note comment cannot be used here because
>  it doesn't allow math equations etc. to be placed in them.

Note, that almost all would be solved, if a Note would allow math etc. (I
darkly remember, that there was something like "open/close all" for floats +
the ability to toggle this by clicking) ...

So my suggestion would be to make the note box more like a footnote box:
i.e. it should not open a separate window but an inset (like floats, errors,
ert-inset, and footnotes) and should (as a footnote or a comment) allow all the
lyx-stuff like math, figures ... 

The difference to the "Comment" paragraph style would be like the one between
LaTeX paragraph and ERT-inset (+ the "Go To Note" menu entry in the
Navigate menu). 

Normal keybindings would work (xforms and KDE don't work well together,
therefore my  key does  in all popup-windows, which sometimes is
anoying.

LaTeX export should also export notes (as comments, may be with a leading
"%Note:") (Then also optional printing is possible with the right package ...)

 What do other people think of this?  Would this be much work or could some
existing code be reused? Should I have posted to devel?

Guenter









--
[EMAIL PROTECTED]