Re: [MBZ] USAA V Progressive, roof claim etc

2021-09-12 Thread Andrew Strasfogel via Mercedes
I got a quote on my homeowners insurance from Amica that was almost double
what Geigo is charging me.   And I am zero risk/no accidents/no teenage
drivers.

On Sun, Sep 12, 2021 at 7:24 PM Kaleb Striplin via Mercedes <
mercedes@okiebenz.com> wrote:

> First an update with the roof claims.  For the primary house the roofer
> says wind damage.  Have a couple of spots of missing shingles on the top
> of the roof peak.  Roofer showed me several areas where shingles are
> loose and could blow off.  Tried to get USAA to cover a roof replacement
> but their claim amount goes in at $600 for repair, well under
> deductible.  May or may not try to fight them on that but not sure it
> will go anywhere.  Will just wait till a good hail storm comes along.
>
> On the rental, USAA is paying for a roof replacement, sort of. Their
> estimate is coming in at around $14.2k for complete replacement.  I sent
> this to roofer because to me is seems light. The deductible is $2k and
> apparently the roof is covered ACV rather than replacement value so they
> are depreciating it around $3k.  They then have a $300 recoverable
> depreciation amount that can be paid after repair is done.  They sent a
> check for around $9400, with basically me paying the rest out of pocket,
> so will have to come up with around $5k.  Will have the wife contact
> roofer to see what we need to do to get their number up.  In the mean
> time, since they were just paying a depreciated amount, I debated on
> just banking this money since we will most likely be selling the house
> in the next year or 2 anyway, and if buyer wants new roof, negotiating
> it into the deal.  Problem is, check is issued to us as well as mortgage
> company.  I am not 100% sure how all that works but it appears as if I
> am going to have to basically sign the check over to them then somehow
> pay the roofer, or somehow get them to sign the check so I can deposit
> it then pay the roofer.  Long story short, since its also made out to
> them, it looks like that pretty much forces the repairs to have to be
> completed now, rather than waiting.  This could be somewhat of a problem
> as our mortgage company on that house is a total and complete pain in
> the ass to deal with, absolutely horrible.  I about guarantee I will
> send them the check, or have to send them some paperwork and it will get
> lost and it will take months and months to get anything done.
>
> Other part of the story, when talking to roofer about the possibility of
> them paying on ACV instead of replacement cost, he says he can help us
> haggle on the "insurance"  quote for replacement, then when it comes
> time to do the work since they are not paying the whole deal anyway, he
> will give us the cash price he would charge without insurance involved
> which should hopefully offset some of the depreciation portion of it.
> On a normal deal, there is an inflated amount they would bill insurance
> and all we pay is the deductible.
>
> Now on to insurance quotes.  Right now USAA is charging me $902/6 months
> for 4 cars, only 1 has full coverage.  Progressive is quoting $416/6
> months for full coverage on all 4 cars.  I quoted full coverage on all
> cars at USAA ant it was over $2k for 6 months. Primary house it is right
> at around $2k per year cheaper. This are not small differences which is
> one reason why I am not sure if this is too good to be true.  I have not
> even shopped the rental house yet.
>
> I am not really sure if I do decide to switch, I do it while these
> claims are still going on.  I was going to potentially try the
> progressive route now on the primary and cars while the rental claim is
> still going on, then move rental later.  Perhaps I should just wait till
> the whole deal is done.
>
>
> ___
> http://www.okiebenz.com
>
> To search list archives http://www.okiebenz.com/archive/
>
> To Unsubscribe or change delivery options go to:
> http://mail.okiebenz.com/mailman/listinfo/mercedes_okiebenz.com
>
>
___
http://www.okiebenz.com

To search list archives http://www.okiebenz.com/archive/

To Unsubscribe or change delivery options go to:
http://mail.okiebenz.com/mailman/listinfo/mercedes_okiebenz.com



[MBZ] USAA V Progressive, roof claim etc

2021-09-12 Thread Kaleb Striplin via Mercedes
First an update with the roof claims.  For the primary house the roofer 
says wind damage.  Have a couple of spots of missing shingles on the top 
of the roof peak.  Roofer showed me several areas where shingles are 
loose and could blow off.  Tried to get USAA to cover a roof replacement 
but their claim amount goes in at $600 for repair, well under 
deductible.  May or may not try to fight them on that but not sure it 
will go anywhere.  Will just wait till a good hail storm comes along.


On the rental, USAA is paying for a roof replacement, sort of. Their 
estimate is coming in at around $14.2k for complete replacement.  I sent 
this to roofer because to me is seems light. The deductible is $2k and 
apparently the roof is covered ACV rather than replacement value so they 
are depreciating it around $3k.  They then have a $300 recoverable 
depreciation amount that can be paid after repair is done.  They sent a 
check for around $9400, with basically me paying the rest out of pocket, 
so will have to come up with around $5k.  Will have the wife contact 
roofer to see what we need to do to get their number up.  In the mean 
time, since they were just paying a depreciated amount, I debated on 
just banking this money since we will most likely be selling the house 
in the next year or 2 anyway, and if buyer wants new roof, negotiating 
it into the deal.  Problem is, check is issued to us as well as mortgage 
company.  I am not 100% sure how all that works but it appears as if I 
am going to have to basically sign the check over to them then somehow 
pay the roofer, or somehow get them to sign the check so I can deposit 
it then pay the roofer.  Long story short, since its also made out to 
them, it looks like that pretty much forces the repairs to have to be 
completed now, rather than waiting.  This could be somewhat of a problem 
as our mortgage company on that house is a total and complete pain in 
the ass to deal with, absolutely horrible.  I about guarantee I will 
send them the check, or have to send them some paperwork and it will get 
lost and it will take months and months to get anything done.


Other part of the story, when talking to roofer about the possibility of 
them paying on ACV instead of replacement cost, he says he can help us 
haggle on the "insurance"  quote for replacement, then when it comes 
time to do the work since they are not paying the whole deal anyway, he 
will give us the cash price he would charge without insurance involved 
which should hopefully offset some of the depreciation portion of it.  
On a normal deal, there is an inflated amount they would bill insurance 
and all we pay is the deductible.


Now on to insurance quotes.  Right now USAA is charging me $902/6 months 
for 4 cars, only 1 has full coverage.  Progressive is quoting $416/6 
months for full coverage on all 4 cars.  I quoted full coverage on all 
cars at USAA ant it was over $2k for 6 months. Primary house it is right 
at around $2k per year cheaper. This are not small differences which is 
one reason why I am not sure if this is too good to be true.  I have not 
even shopped the rental house yet.


I am not really sure if I do decide to switch, I do it while these 
claims are still going on.  I was going to potentially try the 
progressive route now on the primary and cars while the rental claim is 
still going on, then move rental later.  Perhaps I should just wait till 
the whole deal is done.



___
http://www.okiebenz.com

To search list archives http://www.okiebenz.com/archive/

To Unsubscribe or change delivery options go to:
http://mail.okiebenz.com/mailman/listinfo/mercedes_okiebenz.com