Re: [meteorite-list] Franconia Meteorites/Variation, Classification & Confusion

2004-04-08 Thread David Freeman
Dear All,
So what will be the opinion when an iron or pallesite comes out of there?  
Two or three different chondrites you say and we will call them all H5 
regardless of the LL5 to H5...mmmseems like there needs to be a 
bunch more classification to do to me. With out classification, maybe 
they are not unlike some NWA's...orphans from a known location?
Not to feed the ducks,
Dave Freeman

John Birdsell wrote:

Hello everybody.  This is just to clear up some confusion that has 
arisen regarding meteorites recently found in the Franconia wash 
region east of Kingman, AZ.  As a number of you already are aware, 
there have been a number of new Chondrites found in the region loosely 
referred to as "Franconia wash".  These appear to range in composition 
from LL5 to H5.  We have at least two and perhaps three different 
Chondrites from this region (none of which have been classified as of 
yet).  Bob Verish has one of these meteorites which has been 
classified as an (H5) and given the name 'Franconia'.  In a recent 
posting Bob stated that only his stone can "be properly called 
Franconia".  We are assuming that he meant that only his stone can 
properly be called the Franconia 'type specimen'.  As with any 
meteorite fall, all individual members of that fall are both 
individually and collectively referrred to by the name given to the 
type specimen, in this case 'Franconia'.  We have posted on our 
website (http://www.arizonaskiesmeteorites.com) several slices from an 
individual found in the Franconia wash strewn field by Jack Schrader, 
which we stated was unclassified and which appears to be extremely 
similar to the Franconia slices posted by Bob Verish 
(http://www.geocities.com/bolidechaser/mrf/franh5-g.jpg).  Please 
compare these slices and draw you own conclusions. It is of course 
possible, though not very likely, that two very similar meteorites 
fell in the same strewn field. If indeed these are from the same fall, 
then they should of course all be referred to as 'Franconia'.  If they 
are from a different fall, then they represent a New, and as yet 
unclassified, Arizona chondrite.  In either case, this is an exciting 
find, and once the classification of these chondrites is verified we 
will update everyone.  This might be a good opportunity to get a nice 
slice from a new Arizona Chondrite while the prices are still 
reasonable.  If anyone has any questions please feel free to email us.

Thanks

John & Dawn
Arizona Skies Meteorites


__
Meteorite-list mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/meteorite-list



__
Meteorite-list mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/meteorite-list


[meteorite-list] Franconia Meteorites/Variation, Classification & Confusion

2004-04-08 Thread John Birdsell
Hello everybody.  This is just to clear up some confusion that has 
arisen regarding meteorites recently found in the Franconia wash region 
east of Kingman, AZ.  As a number of you already are aware, there have 
been a number of new Chondrites found in the region loosely referred to 
as "Franconia wash".  These appear to range in composition from LL5 to 
H5.  We have at least two and perhaps three different Chondrites from 
this region (none of which have been classified as of yet).  Bob Verish 
has one of these meteorites which has been classified as an (H5) and 
given the name 'Franconia'.  In a recent posting Bob stated that only 
his stone can "be properly called Franconia".  We are assuming that he 
meant that only his stone can properly be called the Franconia 'type 
specimen'.  As with any meteorite fall, all individual members of that 
fall are both individually and collectively referrred to by the name 
given to the type specimen, in this case 'Franconia'.  We have posted on 
our website (http://www.arizonaskiesmeteorites.com) several slices from 
an individual found in the Franconia wash strewn field by Jack Schrader, 
which we stated was unclassified and which appears to be extremely 
similar to the Franconia slices posted by Bob Verish 
(http://www.geocities.com/bolidechaser/mrf/franh5-g.jpg).  Please 
compare these slices and draw you own conclusions. It is of course 
possible, though not very likely, that two very similar meteorites fell 
in the same strewn field. If indeed these are from the same fall, then 
they should of course all be referred to as 'Franconia'.  If they are 
from a different fall, then they represent a New, and as yet 
unclassified, Arizona chondrite.  In either case, this is an exciting 
find, and once the classification of these chondrites is verified we 
will update everyone.  This might be a good opportunity to get a nice 
slice from a new Arizona Chondrite while the prices are still 
reasonable.  If anyone has any questions please feel free to email us.

Thanks

John & Dawn
Arizona Skies Meteorites


__
Meteorite-list mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/meteorite-list