Re: Failed sysupgrade from 6.6 to 6.7 amd64

2020-11-15 Thread Theo de Raadt
Maxim Khitrov  wrote:

> After all these years of trouble-free upgrades, I ran into my first
> problem. I used sysupgrade to go from 6.6/amd64 to 6.7. The upgrade
> process was successful, but after bsd.upgrade did its thing and
> rebooted the system, the new kernel would not boot.
> 
> It got to the "boot>" prompt, started loading the kernel, but then the
> system would reboot right after showing "booting hd0a:bsd:
> 12957+2753552..." line. I tried booting bsd.sp, bsd.rd, and
> bsd.booted with identical results. Was able to boot from cd67.iso.
> Tried downloading the original kernel, but that didn't work either.
> Re-running the upgrade didn't help.

This seems to be the efi issue.

> Finally, decided to upgrade to 6.8, so did that from cd68.iso, which
> fixed the problem. I also replaced bootx64.efi file on the EFI
> partition after this upgrade, but I'm not actually sure if it was
> different or not.

But the issue was also in 6.8.

It is fixed in current.

> Obviously curious as to what the issue may have been, but mostly
> wondering whether any upgrade steps may have been missed as a result
> of never fully booting the 6.7 OS and running post-upgrade steps
> there.

We don't know.  At this point, no developers have machines sensitive
to the issue.



Failed sysupgrade from 6.6 to 6.7 amd64

2020-11-15 Thread Maxim Khitrov
After all these years of trouble-free upgrades, I ran into my first
problem. I used sysupgrade to go from 6.6/amd64 to 6.7. The upgrade
process was successful, but after bsd.upgrade did its thing and
rebooted the system, the new kernel would not boot.

It got to the "boot>" prompt, started loading the kernel, but then the
system would reboot right after showing "booting hd0a:bsd:
12957+2753552..." line. I tried booting bsd.sp, bsd.rd, and
bsd.booted with identical results. Was able to boot from cd67.iso.
Tried downloading the original kernel, but that didn't work either.
Re-running the upgrade didn't help.

Finally, decided to upgrade to 6.8, so did that from cd68.iso, which
fixed the problem. I also replaced bootx64.efi file on the EFI
partition after this upgrade, but I'm not actually sure if it was
different or not.

Obviously curious as to what the issue may have been, but mostly
wondering whether any upgrade steps may have been missed as a result
of never fully booting the 6.7 OS and running post-upgrade steps
there.

Thanks!