Re: FYI SK(4) D-Link DGE-530T Rev B1 does not appear in dmesg. (SOLVED)

2006-06-22 Thread Nick Holland

[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

Quoting [EMAIL PROTECTED]:


Quoting Nick Holland [EMAIL PROTECTED]:


[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
...

The dmesg with the B1 card only lacks the three appropriate lines which
appear for the Rev A1 card when it is inserted in the same PCI slot:

IF that is true, your card wasn't inserted properly.


I tried it in all the other slots and neither OpenBSD nor Windows
detected it.


PCI cards show up.  SOMETHING will show up...even if it isn't
recognized.  The only exceptions are if the card is behind a broken or
unrecognized bridge.


I tried it in a different PC and the card was shown in the dmesg as a
DGE-560T_2.

So it seems that first PC is a quirky one. Sorry about the bogus FYI.


ah.
ok...there's a reason why a PCI card won't show up, which I have 
experienced, but forgot about...


Apparently, some newer cards require PCI2.2 spec, and many machines of 
your vintage (PII) are only PCI2.1.


I should have remembered this, once spent many hours trying to figure 
out why a PCI wireless card (wi(4) based) didn't show up on the vast 
majority of the machines I have...finally found one computer that it 
worked in...the second newest, fastest machine I had (ok, I got a lotta 
old junk).


Kinda a special case of incompatible PCI bridge, sorta, kinda.

Nick.



Re: FYI SK(4) D-Link DGE-530T Rev B1 does not appear in dmesg. (SOLVED)

2006-06-21 Thread shanejp
Quoting [EMAIL PROTECTED]:

 Quoting Nick Holland [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
 
  [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
  ...
   The dmesg with the B1 card only lacks the three appropriate lines which
   appear for the Rev A1 card when it is inserted in the same PCI slot:
 
  IF that is true, your card wasn't inserted properly.

I tried it in all the other slots and neither OpenBSD nor Windows
detected it.

  PCI cards show up.  SOMETHING will show up...even if it isn't
  recognized.  The only exceptions are if the card is behind a broken or
  unrecognized bridge.

I tried it in a different PC and the card was shown in the dmesg as a
DGE-560T_2.

So it seems that first PC is a quirky one. Sorry about the bogus FYI.


Shane




This email was sent from Netspace Webmail: http://www.netspace.net.au