Re: USB stick 4GB Kingston not working

2010-04-22 Thread Richard Toohey
On 20/04/2010, at 4:05 PM, STeve Andre' wrote:

 On Monday 19 April 2010 23:51:21 Sean Howard wrote:
 I have a Kingston, it has behaved very erratically (and currently lost its
 partition, leaving the drive unformatted). I've done no research into
this,
 but a similar problem is there. I found formatting it would work for a few
 days (but didn't want to try harder than that for just a USB drive).

 Somebody claiming to be Girish Venkatachalam wrote:
 Dear friends,

 Though I find that with each OpenBSD release an increasing array of
 exotic USB devices are supported, I got the shock
 of my life with my newly purchased USB stick.

 This is what I get from USB probing.
 [snip]

 Do not discount a bad usb stick.  I've seen a few brands which were (or,
 are) pretty bad.  One particular 1G/2G batch of pny sticks had about 50%
 not working on OpenBSD.  I got them to test because they were flaky on
 Windows, too.  I know there are incompatible sticks out there, but I've
 crashed into just plain badly made hardware, too.


I'll second that on PNY mem sticks - got an 8Gb one and it's hopeless!

Yer pays yer money and yer takes your choice!

 --STeve Andre'



Re: USB stick 4GB Kingston not working

2010-04-21 Thread STeve Andre'
On Monday 19 April 2010 23:51:21 Sean Howard wrote:
 I have a Kingston, it has behaved very erratically (and currently lost its
 partition, leaving the drive unformatted). I've done no research into this,
 but a similar problem is there. I found formatting it would work for a few
 days (but didn't want to try harder than that for just a USB drive).

 Somebody claiming to be Girish Venkatachalam wrote:
  Dear friends,
 
  Though I find that with each OpenBSD release an increasing array of
  exotic USB devices are supported, I got the shock
  of my life with my newly purchased USB stick.
 
  This is what I get from USB probing.
[snip]

Do not discount a bad usb stick.  I've seen a few brands which were (or,
are) pretty bad.  One particular 1G/2G batch of pny sticks had about 50%
not working on OpenBSD.  I got them to test because they were flaky on
Windows, too.  I know there are incompatible sticks out there, but I've
crashed into just plain badly made hardware, too.

--STeve Andre'



Re: USB stick 4GB Kingston not working

2010-04-19 Thread Sean Howard
I have a Kingston, it has behaved very erratically (and currently lost its 
partition, leaving the drive unformatted).
I've done no research into this, but a similar problem is there. I found 
formatting it would work for a few days (but didn't want to try harder than 
that for just a USB drive).

Somebody claiming to be Girish Venkatachalam wrote:
 Dear friends,
 
 Though I find that with each OpenBSD release an increasing array of
 exotic USB devices are supported, I got the shock
 of my life with my newly purchased USB stick.
 
 This is what I get from USB probing.
 
 
 umass1 at uhub0 port 6 configuration 1 interface 0 Kingston
 DataTraveler 130 rev 2.00/1.00 addr 3
 umass1: using SCSI over Bulk-Only
 scsibus2 at umass1: 2 targets, initiator 0
 sd1 at scsibus2 targ 1 lun 0: Kingston, DataTraveler 130, 1.00 SCSI2
 0/direct removable
 Unit test ready failed...
 sd1: Drive offline
 
 Obviously you won't get this message. I tried to hack the kernel to
 find out what is going on...
 
 Shall I wait for May 1 and hope that the problem goes away?
 
 Thanks.
 
 -Girish
 
 -- 
 Gayatri Hitech
 web: http://gayatri-hitech.com
 
 SpamCheetah Spam filter:
 http://spam-cheetah.com