Take back your modules! (was: Re: Give up your modules!)

2006-09-07 Thread Mark Stosberg
Ovid wrote:
 Hi all,
 
 No names, but if you happen to be sitting on a module which other people 
 depend on and you're not going to fix bugs, give up the module, offer someone 
 co-maintainership or figure out *something* which gives users a way out. I 
 realize that not everyone has a pile of free time to constantly upgrade and 
 maintain modules, but if it's something widely used and you don't have time 
 for it, isn't the responsible thing to find a way to get those bug fixes out 
 there? 

I just want to point out that giving maintainership involves two
consenting parties, and this a author-centric approach.

The user-centric approach works too.  Leave patches in RT. Follow-up on
the other bug reports until you reach resolution. Leave a note in RT
that says I recommend this issue be resolved because...

Go ahead and prepare a next proposed release with tests/docs/code and
ChangeLog updates and tell the author they can simply sign-off on it.

I now help maintain Data::FormValidator, CGI::Session, CGI::Application,
and WWW::Mechanize, none of which I wrote.

In all cases, the existing maintainers have been appreciative of my
pro-active approach.

From my perspective, there aren't enough users acting like the software
is theirs. Considering the licenses on CPAN, they have equal right to
work on it. I'm not sure what the hang-ups are for getting users to be
more active, though.

I say: If you are care about a module's maintenance, start acting like
you own it, being considering that others, especially the current
maintainer, may feel the same way.

   Mark



Re: Take back your modules! (was: Re: Give up your modules!)

2006-09-07 Thread Andy Lester


On Sep 7, 2006, at 9:08 AM, Mark Stosberg wrote:


I say: If you are care about a module's maintenance, start acting like
you own it, being considering that others, especially the current
maintainer, may feel the same way.


Nice.  Worthy of a use.perl.org post so others can see it.  Maybe  
perlmonks too.


--
Andy Lester = [EMAIL PROTECTED] = www.petdance.com = AIM:petdance






RE: Take back your modules! (was: Re: Give up your modules!)

2006-09-07 Thread Orton, Yves
Title: RE: Take back your modules! (was: Re: Give up your modules!) 





 On Sep 7, 2006, at 9:08 AM, Mark Stosberg wrote:
 
  I say: If you are care about a module's maintenance, start 
 acting like
  you own it, being considering that others, especially the current
  maintainer, may feel the same way.
 
 Nice. Worthy of a use.perl.org post so others can see it. Maybe 
 perlmonks too.


I heartily concur


Yves