When the major push of birds have gone through, and the straggling rares are being reported, it seems we come up with controversial subjects to fill in the gaps on the M.O.U.. Its been really interesting to read everyones approach to ethics and reporting, and I have gleaned much from all. I report rare birds sometimes and at other times I enter the data, but do not report on the list serve. My reasons. First, if I find a rare I want to substantiate it, so I don't have people running great distances to be let down. It waists their time and money and doesn't do much for my reputation. If it is substantiated, I also want to be sure it will hang around for a while so others may get a look. I will check back a few times a day so I know it will be there. Second, I do look at the impact the report may have upon the safety of the bird and how it would affect the people who live close. In past reports from Herb Dingman, I noticed how he would give information about viewing areas and on things to avoid. He taught me to give as much info relating to the least infringement on local residents and on the bird and environment. Next, Some birds I omit on the list serve intentionally. Because of the land owners request, or the impact upon the bird, I only enter the data on the M.O.U.. But, the bird does not go unnoticed. I have a circle of birder associates that I have learned to trust and respect. I usually call Milt Blomberg who contacts Herb Dingman, who is in contact with Ron Erpelding who may contact Barb and Denny Martin. These people are excellent birders who live the ethics of birding and have taught me. I respect them and they substantiate my sitings. Also, the best part of this is developing friendships and trust with other birders and is as important as finding the birds. Mike Hendrickson is an excellent, conscientious birder as is Bob Russel. I have gleaned a lot from both and respect each. Listen to what they say and learn. There are not two sides to this issue but your own experiences, what you have learned from others, and what is important to the bird and environment. Personally, I do dislike when people report and give no more info than a rare bird is in the state. If I can't go see it it would be better not to hear about it. What is the intent of the reporter? To lift up ones name and to dangle the candy in front of others. Also, I find good rare bird info by going into the query database and find all I need. Beyond this,people like Anthony Hertzel, Jim Lind, Kim Eckert,and Jeanne Joppru do a good job reporting rare area sitings. The M.O.U. Is a great site but it is not perfect. We are all learning and that's what the intent of the M.O.U. is. P.S. Found a Saw Whet Owl, Golden Eagle, Ravens and a Black Billed Magpie last weekend in the Boudora State Forest Area in Hubbard County, but, there were not many pull-offs and Hwy 64 is very well traveled. Have a good weekend and may your birding be rewarding. Frank Gosiak, Little Falls area.
---- Join or Leave mou-net: http://lists.umn.edu/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=mou-net Archives: http://lists.umn.edu/archives/mou-net.html
