Re: Cross Domain blocking - oversight in these days of Web Services

2004-02-03 Thread Martin Honnen


Dave Cline wrote:


Mozilla's cross domain page access blocking is a MAJOR OVERSIGHT in
these days of expanding use of Web Services.
Creating browser based applications which may wish to communicate
directly with SOAP based Web Services not of the domain the
application was served from will be a commonly demanded requirement.
The absence of any mechanism to allow such communication in Mozilla
constitutes a very narrow vision of future browser application use on
the Web.
Are you aware of
  http://www.mozilla.org/projects/webservices/
?? Indeed Mozilla has introduced a new security policy that doesn't 
enforce the same origin policy if the side providing a web service 
allows access in a file, see
  http://devedge.netscape.com/viewsource/2003/wsdl/01/#The-Security-Model

--

Martin Honnen
http://JavaScript.FAQTs.com/
___
Mozilla-security mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://mail.mozilla.org/listinfo/mozilla-security


Cross Domain blocking - oversight in these days of Web Services

2004-01-30 Thread Dave Cline
Tribe,
Mozilla's cross domain page access blocking is a MAJOR OVERSIGHT in
these days of expanding use of Web Services.

Creating browser based applications which may wish to communicate
directly with SOAP based Web Services not of the domain the
application was served from will be a commonly demanded requirement.
The absence of any mechanism to allow such communication in Mozilla
constitutes a very narrow vision of future browser application use on
the Web.
 
The only solution available to the Mozilla development team is to
include a checkbox and warning label within user preferences which
will enable such useful functionality.

Paranoid talk of security violations is expected. So be creative,
design some middle ground where the user is made aware of such
communication and can choose to allow or decline it on a per instance
basis. But don't just block it absolutely without providing some means
to override your heavy handed tyranical choices.

 Dave Cline
~bangeye.com~
___
Mozilla-security mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://mail.mozilla.org/listinfo/mozilla-security