Re: OT: [TalkBiz] Who's deleting your email (fwd)

2002-04-05 Thread Martin Karlsson

Hi David,

* David T-G [EMAIL PROTECTED] [2002-04-05 13.55 -0500]:
[...snip...]
 Surf on over to
 
   http://www.talkbiz.com/assassin.html
 
 and give it a read.

Hmmm. SA seems to be right at least 8 times out of 10 for me anyway.
And let's not forget that it *is* configurable.

Seriously:  ...alleged spam filter system...
Any person that recommends this software should be
required to re-take their IQ test, to see if they still
have one. (Still have an IQ test???)

This seems to be some sort of hate campaign; the author of this
web page doesn't even /try/ to stick to facts. Makes you wonder if
the author 'still has an IQ test' ;)

-- 
Martin   | PGP/GPG: | There is no cow
Karlsson | 9C924660 |on the ice.




msg26790/pgp0.pgp
Description: PGP signature


Re: OT: [TalkBiz] Who's deleting your email (fwd)

2002-04-05 Thread Peter De Wachter

On Fri, Apr 05, 2002 at 01:55:41PM -0500, David T-G wrote:
 Hi, all --
 
 I know that there are a lot of folks using various spam-fighting
 tools here, and particularly some who are using Spam Assassin, and so I
 thought this might be of interest.  I haven't checked into SA or how it's
 configured or looked [recently] at the SpamTricks article, but I'd like
 to know how much of this guy's claim is bupkus and how much is valid.
 Maybe I'll get to dig into it.
 
 Surf on over to
 
   http://www.talkbiz.com/assassin.html
 
 and give it a read.

SpamAssassin works fine for me. I'm using the default configuration and
almost all spam gets tagged. It never tagged real email incorrectly.

However, I agree with the author: ISP's should never delete mail without
the explicit permission of the customer. Marking suspected spam is ok,
but not deleting. His attack against SpamAssassin was just to show that
filters aren't 100% reliable, and it's true that spamassassin is geared to
technical types (it has negative scores for Bugzilla reports, blocks
of hexadecimal code, and patches...)

As a side note, I subscribed to his mailing list, to see what SpamAssassin
would do with it. I just received a You're subscribed message. No
confirmation message, no unsubscribe information. No unsubscribe
information on the website either. /me thinks I'll receive an offer to
make money fast soon...

Mvg,
Peter De Wachter



Re: OT: [TalkBiz] Who's deleting your email (fwd)

2002-04-05 Thread Shawn McMahon

begin  quoting what Michael Elkins said on Fri, Apr 05, 2002 at 12:29:56PM -0800:
 That's pretty much what yahoo and hotmail do.  They will place spam
 messages in a separate Spam folder so that the user can peruse through
 it in case something was blocked by accident.

Except, in Yahoo's case, if the spammer pays them.




msg26811/pgp0.pgp
Description: PGP signature


Re: OT: [TalkBiz] Who's deleting your email (fwd)

2002-04-05 Thread David Rock

On Fri, Apr 05, 2002 at 11:35:01AM -0800, Will Yardley wrote:
 
 it generally takes several tests to get a message blocked. in any
 event, sorry to continue this OT discussion.  if you haven't already,
 definitely check out spamassassin.  i was a long time spambouncer
 user, but i have to say i've been converted.

I have been using junkfilter myself and have been relatively happy with
it.  It is essentially a list of procmail recipes that can be tuned,
turned on/off or excluded altogether. I even went so far as to modify
its activity so that it tagged the subject line of offensive mails with
[SPAM] so that my wife's Netscape rules could find the emails in her
inbox for her (can't talk her into mutt).

I have not tried Spam Assassin personally, but I imagine it has many of
the same features if you bother to take the time to read the docs ;-).

http://junkfilter.zer0.org/

-- 
David Rock
[EMAIL PROTECTED]



msg26819/pgp0.pgp
Description: PGP signature