GSM Association and NeuStar Sign Agreement to Offer Root DNS Services

2005-09-30 Thread Stephane Bortzmeyer

It can be of operational interest or it can fuel a new flame about
alternative DNS roots.

http://www.neustar.com/pressroom/files/announcements/ns_pr_09282005.pdf

GSM Association and NeuStar Sign Agreement to Offer Root DNS Services
to More than 680 Global GSM Mobile Operators

...

NeuStar's Root DNS service will serve two functions: first, to
register domain names under the suffixes gprs and 3gppnetwork.org,
which are used to register private domain names that allow operators
to retrieve routing information when a subscriber accesses data and
multimedia services on a roaming or home network. For example, a U.S.
mobile subscriber traveling on business in Singapore will be able to
access a video or audio file using their mobile device while roaming
on a local GSM network.

Additionally, NeuStar will operate the master DNS root server and
provide updates to GRX (GPRS Roaming Exchange) and MMS (Multimedia
Messaging Service) providers, allowing mobile operators to access
updated DNS routing information.

...




Re: GSM Association and NeuStar Sign Agreement to Offer Root DNS Services

2005-09-30 Thread Randy Bush

different meaning of 'root server'.  pretty surely written by a 
droid.

randy



Re: GSM Association and NeuStar Sign Agreement to Offer Root DNS Services

2005-09-30 Thread Romeo Zwart

Stephane Bortzmeyer wrote:
 It can be of operational interest or it can fuel a new flame about
 alternative DNS roots.

Another flame fest? Possibly, but only if caused by lack of understanding where 
the Neustar DNS root will be living. This DNS structure for GPRS roaming lives 
in its own separate universe. As GSM in general does. :) 

GPRS providers do (usually) offer a connected mobile handset the possibility to 
connect to TheInternetAtLarge -- no flames about walled gardens, please :) . 
For Internet access the mobile will query what you might call 'DNS-proper' ; 
i.e. the mobile's domain namespace is in the real Internet. 

The services provided by Neustar will live in the non-public IP space that 
connects the GPRS (and IMS, and MMS) infrastructure, which is separate from the 
end-user (mobile device) IP space. 

Cheers, 

Romeo 

 
 http://www.neustar.com/pressroom/files/announcements/ns_pr_09282005.pdf
 
 GSM Association and NeuStar Sign Agreement to Offer Root DNS Services
 to More than 680 Global GSM Mobile Operators
 
 ...
 
 NeuStar's Root DNS service will serve two functions: first, to
 register domain names under the suffixes gprs and 3gppnetwork.org,
 which are used to register private domain names that allow operators
 to retrieve routing information when a subscriber accesses data and
 multimedia services on a roaming or home network. For example, a U.S.
 mobile subscriber traveling on business in Singapore will be able to
 access a video or audio file using their mobile device while roaming
 on a local GSM network.
 
 Additionally, NeuStar will operate the master DNS root server and
 provide updates to GRX (GPRS Roaming Exchange) and MMS (Multimedia
 Messaging Service) providers, allowing mobile operators to access
 updated DNS routing information.
 
 ...
 
 
 




Re: GSM Association and NeuStar Sign Agreement to Offer Root DNS Services

2005-09-30 Thread Suresh Ramasubramanian

On 30/09/05, Stephane Bortzmeyer [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

 It can be of operational interest or it can fuel a new flame about
 alternative DNS roots.

 http://www.neustar.com/pressroom/files/announcements/ns_pr_09282005.pdf


It is not a public root and it is not available over the internet either

A closed service  available solely over  the gprs network

I guess gprs phones will query real dns to access real internet resources

--srs

--
Suresh Ramasubramanian ([EMAIL PROTECTED])


Re: GSM Association and NeuStar Sign Agreement to Offer Root DNS Services

2005-09-30 Thread Brandon Butterworth

 It is not a public root and it is not available over the internet either
 
 A closed service  available solely over  the gprs network

Until the users want to access the same stuff from their
PC and they petition for it to be in the public root too

To the public if it looks like internet they expect it to
work like internet

brandon


Re: GSM Association and NeuStar Sign Agreement to Offer Root DNS Services

2005-09-30 Thread Niels Bakker



It is not a public root and it is not available over the internet either
A closed service  available solely over  the gprs network


* [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Brandon Butterworth) [Fri 30 Sep 2005, 12:55 CEST]:
Until the users want to access the same stuff from their 
PC and they petition for it to be in the public root too


To the public if it looks like internet they expect it to 
work like internet


You are misunderstanding.  The data in .gprs is used by infrastructure 
in the GSM networks to decide where a user's home station is.  End users 
have no way of interacting with this infrastructure (beyond turning on 
their phones outside their home country).


When a user surfs the internet from their handheld device they get the 
real Internet, not some walled garden that has .gprs.



-- Niels.


Re: GSM Association and NeuStar Sign Agreement to Offer Root DNS Services

2005-09-30 Thread Brandon Butterworth

 You are misunderstanding.

I'm extrapolating, things rarely stay restricted to the
original use they existed for. At some point I expect
they'll put something on it that users become aware of
and think it'd be much more convenient if we could
use the same on the internet

 The data in .gprs is used by infrastructure 
 in the GSM networks to decide where a user's home station is.

If they restrict it to internal use then it's non news,
anyone can make up stuff with risk of later collision,
and isn't on topic here.

brandon


[ON TOPIC] Was: Re: GSM Association and NeuStar Sign Agreement to Offer Root DNS Services

2005-09-30 Thread James R. Cutler


Management of Naming, Addressing, and the related directory service (DNS)
is properly part of Network Operations. Thus, on topic for
NANOG.
At 9/30/2005 01:43 PM +0100, Brandon Butterworth wrote:
snip/
If they restrict it to internal use then it's non news,
anyone can make up stuff with risk of later collision,
and isn't on topic here.
brandon

-
James R. Cutler
[EMAIL PROTECTED]




Re: GSM Association and NeuStar Sign Agreement to Offer Root DNS Services

2005-09-30 Thread Sabri Berisha

On Fri, Sep 30, 2005 at 02:33:13PM +0200, Niels Bakker wrote:
 
Hi,

 To the public if it looks like internet they expect it to 
 work like internet
 
 You are misunderstanding.  The data in .gprs is used by infrastructure 
 in the GSM networks to decide where a user's home station is.  End users 
 have no way of interacting with this infrastructure (beyond turning on 
 their phones outside their home country).

He has a point. Remember Het Net* as it was before they proxiet to the
real internet. Users expected the internet and after a while, they got
it.

-- 
Sabri

please do not throw salami pizza away


* Het Net, translated as The Net was an attempt by the dutch
national telco in the late 90's to come up with a big intranet where
users could dialup, using RFC1918 addresses and visit community and
commercial sites. After a few months, proxy-support to the real internet
was added and even later it was integrated into Planet.nl, a dutch
dsl-isp.