Re: Self-referential whois queries

2011-02-10 Thread Rubens Kuhl
>> I'm noticing an increase in getting "query rate exceeded" at whois
>> services that might be connected to a symptom described by ARIN at
>> NANOG 48/ARIN XXV and ARIN XXVI where machines ask for the whois
>> record of their own IP address.
>>
>> Are there any clues of what is causing this ?
>
> Some spam bots do these automated self-referential queries, but if you
> are seeing those rate exceeded messages when you perform queries from
> your client, you may simply be probably bumping up against a limit for
> the source host or network in question.

The ceil seems to be at the joint whois chain, where a RIR can ask
another RIR or NIR about an IP.

RIRs/NIRs answering such queries with "It's you!" or "Self-referential
queries not allowed" would be too harsh or a reasonable approach ?


Rubens



Re: Self-referential whois queries

2011-02-10 Thread John Kristoff
On Thu, 10 Feb 2011 17:27:26 -0200
Rubens Kuhl  wrote:

> I'm noticing an increase in getting "query rate exceeded" at whois
> services that might be connected to a symptom described by ARIN at
> NANOG 48/ARIN XXV and ARIN XXVI where machines ask for the whois
> record of their own IP address.
>
> Are there any clues of what is causing this ?

Some spam bots do these automated self-referential queries, but if you
are seeing those rate exceeded messages when you perform queries from
your client, you may simply be probably bumping up against a limit for
the source host or network in question.

John



Self-referential whois queries

2011-02-10 Thread Rubens Kuhl
I'm noticing an increase in getting "query rate exceeded" at whois
services that might be connected to a symptom described by ARIN at
NANOG 48/ARIN XXV and ARIN XXVI where machines ask for the whois
record of their own IP address.

Are there any clues of what is causing this ?


Rubens