[newbie] RAID configuration problems

2003-03-16 Thread Andrew Miller
Having big trouble trying to configure MDK 9.0 with a Promise IDE RAID. 
 If there are drives attached to the the RAID controller, in this case 
a couple of Western Digital 80 giggers, the BIOS allows me to set up 
the RAID.   However, the Mandrake 9.0 installer only sees two separate 
drives.  It also seem to insist that these are hda and hdc, making the 
other drives in the box hde and hdf.  I want to use the drives the 
installer sets to hde as the boot disk and location for the root 
directory, but since I can't seem to get the installer to see the array 
as a single volume, I tried to have the bootloader put on hde, with the 
plan to configure the RAID array later.  But then the machine won't 
boot.  Default location for the bootloader is on hda and it looks like 
the machine fails to find it on hde.

Is there a different strain of Mandrake Linux that will properly see 
the RAID array at installation?  Is there something I'm just missing 
here?  Been beating my head on this for a day and it seems like it 
shouldn't be so difficult.  The Promise controller is on the 
mtherboard, processor is an AMD XP2200+ with a gig of PC2700 RAM.  Any 
help with this is appreciated.  The machine has been running fine with 
just the two original drives (100 gig IBM 75GXP's) in it, but it just 
won't go with the array.

Andy Miller


Want to buy your Pack or Services from MandrakeSoft? 
Go to http://www.mandrakestore.com


Re: [newbie] RAID configuration problems

2003-03-16 Thread Greg Meyer
On Monday 17 March 2003 12:31 am, Andrew Miller wrote:
 Having big trouble trying to configure MDK 9.0 with a Promise IDE RAID.
   If there are drives attached to the the RAID controller, in this case
 a couple of Western Digital 80 giggers, the BIOS allows me to set up
 the RAID.   However, the Mandrake 9.0 installer only sees two separate
 drives.  It also seem to insist that these are hda and hdc, making the
 other drives in the box hde and hdf.  I want to use the drives the
 installer sets to hde as the boot disk and location for the root
 directory, but since I can't seem to get the installer to see the array
 as a single volume, I tried to have the bootloader put on hde, with the
 plan to configure the RAID array later.  But then the machine won't
 boot.  Default location for the bootloader is on hda and it looks like
 the machine fails to find it on hde.

You can fix the drive lettering problem by setting ide=reverse as a kernel 
boot parameter.


 Is there a different strain of Mandrake Linux that will properly see
 the RAID array at installation?  Is there something I'm just missing
 here?  Been beating my head on this for a day and it seems like it
 shouldn't be so difficult.  The Promise controller is on the
 mtherboard, processor is an AMD XP2200+ with a gig of PC2700 RAM.  Any
 help with this is appreciated.  The machine has been running fine with
 just the two original drives (100 gig IBM 75GXP's) in it, but it just
 won't go with the array.

Well, it is really not a Mandrake problem but a Linux problem.

ATA RAID is not supported well in Linux, mostly because the hardware vendors 
do not create linux drivers and do not make sufficient info available to the 
kernel guys to allow them to create drivers.  So, you are pretty much SOL.

ATA RAID is software RAID, meaning that a driver is required to make it work.  
Hardware RAID solutions like SCSI RAID do not need a driver, the hardware 
takes care of presenting the device to the OS as a standard SCSI device.

9.1 may be better, but I wouldn't count on it.  Try setting them up as single 
drives and using Linux software RAID.
-- 
Greg

Want to buy your Pack or Services from MandrakeSoft? 
Go to http://www.mandrakestore.com