Nginx fastcgi_next_upstream off doesn't work

2013-11-29 Thread Oleg V. Khrustov
nginx/1.5.4
location / {
...
fastcgi_pass   bg;
fastcgi_next_upstream off;
...
}

upstream bg {

server unix:/tmp/dsp.1.sock;
server unix:/tmp/dsp.2.sock;
server unix:/tmp/dsp.3.sock;
server unix:/tmp/dsp.4.sock;
server unix:/tmp/dsp.5.sock;
server unix:/tmp/dsp.6.sock;
server unix:/tmp/dsp.7.sock;
server unix:/tmp/dsp.8.sock;
server unix:/tmp/dsp.9.sock;
server unix:/tmp/dsp.10.sock;
server unix:/tmp/dsp.11.sock;
server unix:/tmp/dsp.12.sock;
server unix:/tmp/dsp.13.sock;

}

 log_format combined-r '$time_local: upstream $upstream_addr responded
$upstream_status in $upstream_response_time ms, request status $status is
in $request_time ms';


29/Nov/2013:13:57:51 +0400: upstream unix:/tmp/dsp.4.sock :
unix:/tmp/dsp.9.sock responded 504 : 504 in 0.148 : 0.050 ms, request
status 504 is in 0.198 ms


So nginx still pass request to next upstream dsp.4 - dsp.9


What can be wrong with this config?

Thanks,
OK
___
nginx mailing list
nginx@nginx.org
http://mailman.nginx.org/mailman/listinfo/nginx

Re: Nginx fastcgi_next_upstream off doesn't work

2013-11-29 Thread Maxim Dounin
Hello!

On Fri, Nov 29, 2013 at 03:50:52PM +0400, Oleg V. Khrustov wrote:

 nginx/1.5.4
 location / {
 ...
 fastcgi_pass   bg;
 fastcgi_next_upstream off;
 ...
 }
 
 upstream bg {
 
 server unix:/tmp/dsp.1.sock;
 server unix:/tmp/dsp.2.sock;
 server unix:/tmp/dsp.3.sock;
 server unix:/tmp/dsp.4.sock;
 server unix:/tmp/dsp.5.sock;
 server unix:/tmp/dsp.6.sock;
 server unix:/tmp/dsp.7.sock;
 server unix:/tmp/dsp.8.sock;
 server unix:/tmp/dsp.9.sock;
 server unix:/tmp/dsp.10.sock;
 server unix:/tmp/dsp.11.sock;
 server unix:/tmp/dsp.12.sock;
 server unix:/tmp/dsp.13.sock;
 
 }
 
  log_format combined-r '$time_local: upstream $upstream_addr responded
 $upstream_status in $upstream_response_time ms, request status $status is
 in $request_time ms';
 
 
 29/Nov/2013:13:57:51 +0400: upstream unix:/tmp/dsp.4.sock :
 unix:/tmp/dsp.9.sock responded 504 : 504 in 0.148 : 0.050 ms, request
 status 504 is in 0.198 ms
 
 
 So nginx still pass request to next upstream dsp.4 - dsp.9
 
 
 What can be wrong with this config?

The 504 : 504 in $upstream_status indicate that there were two 
requests to the upstream, with an internal redirect between them 
(note :).  See here for the variable format description:

http://nginx.org/en/docs/http/ngx_http_upstream_module.html#variables

That is, everything works as expected, you just have an error_page 
redirection which does an additional request and confuses you.

-- 
Maxim Dounin
http://nginx.org/en/donation.html

___
nginx mailing list
nginx@nginx.org
http://mailman.nginx.org/mailman/listinfo/nginx


Re: Nginx fastcgi_next_upstream off doesn't work

2013-11-29 Thread Oleg V. Khrustov
Yes, you are absolutely right.  Thanks again!
___
nginx mailing list
nginx@nginx.org
http://mailman.nginx.org/mailman/listinfo/nginx