Re: [onap-tsc] [onap-discuss] 答复：Re: 答复：Re: Modelling discussion on Friday May 5th
Huabing I'm curious on what basis are you making the following assumptions: "Condition 2: Neither declarative nor internal imperative workflow is capable of the process model of general Telecom cloud NFV process model. which I have already elaborated in my previous mails. and you also agreed. Condition 3: BPMN/BPEL can do this job. " Is there a specific POC or test that you've ran to validate those assumptions? What are the specific use cases that can't be implemented with option 2? The reason i'm asking is that i want to verify those statements is that its important to separate the conceptual/architecture limitation from specific implementation limitation and without knowing those details its too early to make this kind of arguments. I would like to point out that many use web-scale use cases (mostly) outside of the telco industry use a declarative model (Amazon cloud formation is a good example, Terraform could be another good example) to deal with large scale and complex deployment that span across zones, sites etc. This is even more true with the containers and cloud native services. I could also point out just as equally to how you can deliver VCPE, SD-WAN and many other Telco use cases that spans across multi-site in either option hence my point above. So while were making this sort of discussions i think that it would important that we will more specific on the use-case and user-story first, than explore which options first that use case best and drive the decision from there. It sounds like you've gone through this process youself hence my original question for sharing the details from that experience before we jump into conclusion and build an entire strategy around them. Nati S. On Fri, Apr 28, 2017 at 9:45 AM wrote: > The reasoning is obvious and simple: > > Condition 1: TOSCA intend to have both the topology model and process > model to facilitate the cloud and NFV orchestration. > > Condition 2: Neither declarative nor internal imperative workflow is > capable of the process model of general Telecom cloud NFV process model. > which I have already elaborated in my previous mails. and you also agreed. > > Condition 3: BPMN/BPEL can do this job. > > reasoning result: BPMN/BPEL should be included in TOSCA for process > modelling, along with declarative workflow. > > What if we not: TOSCA workflow solution is uncompleted due to the lack of > NFV process modelling capability. > > I just don't understand the logic why you keep pushing back what is > obviously good for the expansion of TOSCA adaption and healthy of TOSCA > ecosystem.___ > onap-discuss mailing list > onap-disc...@lists.onap.org > https://lists.onap.org/mailman/listinfo/onap-discuss > ___ ONAP-TSC mailing list ONAP-TSC@lists.onap.org https://lists.onap.org/mailman/listinfo/onap-tsc
[onap-tsc] [ONAP TSC VICE-CHAIRPERSON ELECTION] Kickoff of the ONAP TSC Vice-Chairperson Election
Hello ONAP TSC Members: Please consider this email as the kickoff of the ONAP TSC Vice-Chair Election process. There are two phases to the election process. The first is the Nomination Phase where TSC Members may nominate themselves for the position of TSC Vice-Chairperson. Once the Nomination Phase has concluded, we will enter the Election Phase, where all ONAP TSC Members are invited and encouraged to vote on the candidates whom have been nominated. Timing: - Nominations open April 28th, 2017. - Nominations close May 2nd at 9:00pm Pacific Time - Voting begins May 3rd, 2017 - Voting Ends May 5th, 2017 at 9:00pm Pacific Time If you are an ONAP TSC member and wish to nominate yourself for the position of TSC Vice-Chairperson, please respond-all to this email with your picture (headshot), biography, and statement of interest on why you would wish to be the TSC Vice-Chairperson. I wlll post this information to the wiki prior to the start of the election so that everyone in the technical community is able to become familiar with the candidates. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. Best, Phil. -- Phil Robb Executive Director, OpenDaylight Project VP Operations - Networking & Orchestration, The Linux Foundation (O) 970-229-5949 (M) 970-420-4292 Skype: Phil.Robb ___ ONAP-TSC mailing list ONAP-TSC@lists.onap.org https://lists.onap.org/mailman/listinfo/onap-tsc
Re: [onap-tsc] [ONAP TSC VICE-CHAIRPERSON ELECTION] Kickoff of the ONAP TSC Vice-Chairperson Election
Dear ONAP TSC, I am interested in serving as ONAP’s TSC Vice-Chairperson. In this role, I will focus on two priorities: community and cadence. I am committed to openness and transparency, making room for other people’s contributions, and recruiting new developers and new companies. Also, I believe that it is essential that we demonstrate the ability to release on time, before the end of the year. Over the past year, I have served as OPEN-O’s TSC Chair. I know what it takes to build and lead an open source community and to release on time, having delivered two on-time releases in 11 months. Also, I can devote about 90% of my time to ONAP, and I am committed to its success. I have over 20 years’ networking experience, including 6+ years’ experience leading open source SDN/NFV development teams using Agile and Lean methodologies. I have also been active in open source leadership for several years: ·OPEN-O TSC Chair and Member of the Governing Board ·OPNFV Certification & Compliance Chair; former Member of the Board of Directors and Strategic Planning Committee Chair ·Open Daylight Advisory Committee ·MEF Certification Committee Co-Chair ·CableLabs Virtualization and Network Evolution head, developing residential and business Virtual CPEs, including the first open source version of MEF LSO. Thank you. I appreciate your support. Chris Chris Donley serves as Senior Director, Open Source Ecosystems at Huawei. He is providing open source leadership in several Software Defined Networking (SDN) and Network function Virtualization (NfV) initiatives, including Open-O, ONAP, and OPNFV. He previously served as Director, Virtualization and Network Evolution at CableLabs. Chris has been involved in many standards and open source organizations. He currently serves as TSC Chair for Open-O, Certification and Compliance Chair for OPNFV, and Huawei’s TSC member for ONAP. He previously served on the OPNFV Board of Directors and Open Daylight Advisory Council. He also chaired the OPNFV Strategic Planning Committee and served as MEF Certification Committee Co-Chair. Chris received a Bachelor's degree in Engineering from Dartmouth College and a Master's degree in Business Administration from the University of Colorado. He holds Cisco CCIE and (ISC)2 CISSP certifications, and has been granted 15 US patents. [Chris Donley] From: onap-tsc-boun...@lists.onap.org [mailto:onap-tsc-boun...@lists.onap.org] On Behalf Of Phil Robb Sent: Friday, April 28, 2017 3:49 PM To: onap-tsc@lists.onap.org Subject: [onap-tsc] [ONAP TSC VICE-CHAIRPERSON ELECTION] Kickoff of the ONAP TSC Vice-Chairperson Election Hello ONAP TSC Members: Please consider this email as the kickoff of the ONAP TSC Vice-Chair Election process. There are two phases to the election process. The first is the Nomination Phase where TSC Members may nominate themselves for the position of TSC Vice-Chairperson. Once the Nomination Phase has concluded, we will enter the Election Phase, where all ONAP TSC Members are invited and encouraged to vote on the candidates whom have been nominated. Timing: § Nominations open April 28th, 2017. § Nominations close May 2nd at 9:00pm Pacific Time § Voting begins May 3rd, 2017 § Voting Ends May 5th, 2017 at 9:00pm Pacific Time If you are an ONAP TSC member and wish to nominate yourself for the position of TSC Vice-Chairperson, please respond-all to this email with your picture (headshot), biography, and statement of interest on why you would wish to be the TSC Vice-Chairperson. I wlll post this information to the wiki prior to the start of the election so that everyone in the technical community is able to become familiar with the candidates. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. Best, Phil. -- Phil Robb Executive Director, OpenDaylight Project VP Operations - Networking & Orchestration, The Linux Foundation (O) 970-229-5949 (M) 970-420-4292 Skype: Phil.Robb ___ ONAP-TSC mailing list ONAP-TSC@lists.onap.org https://lists.onap.org/mailman/listinfo/onap-tsc
Re: [onap-tsc] [ONAP TSC VICE-CHAIRPERSON ELECTION] Kickoff of the ONAP TSC Vice-Chairperson Election
Hi Phil and all, I am writing to let you know I am running for the ONAP TSC Vice Chairperson and would appreciate your support. I have been working as different roles in different committees of several related open source projects, including end user, technical community and governance committees. I would share my experience and commit my time and efforts in supporting TSC Chair and other fellow TSC members in fulfilling the ONAP goals: reference implementation and commercial adoption. In particular, I have been and will be continue working on technical harmonization, collaboration with other open source projects in building an open and agile developing community for ONAP. I am devoted to working both internally and with other end users in the community on alignment on technical requirements and realistic use cases on the ONAP platform and release planning. I will be working to build open labs and cooperate with vendors in their ONAP products or 3rd party commercial components to accelerate commercial adoption. Last but not the least, based on previous experience from other open source projects, language issue has been demonstrated as one of the blocking issues for efficient communication between TSC leadership and the Chinse developers, which accounts a considerable portion of ONAP technical community as well. I am offering my commitment and experience to cultural harmonization as the bridge between the TSC leadership and Chinese developer groups, organize and host Chinese open source events, in order to recruit more and help with existing Chinese developers to more actively interact with and contribute to the broader community. Below is my short bio: Lingli Deng obtained her Doctor’s degree in computer science from the Institute of Software, Chinese Academy of Sciences and joined China Mobile in 2009. She is currently leading OPNFV/ONAP project and Novonet experimental network at China Mobile Research Institute. She is also currently serving as the ONAP TSC member representing china Mobile. She was in the formation team for OPEN-O, served as OPEN-O TSC representative and NFV-O PTL. And contributed mostly to the harmonization between openECOMP and OPEN-O. She is also serving on the OPNFV Board of Directors and act as the treasurer of Board officer. She joined OPNFV community since its early phase, and led OPNFV DPACC project, won 1st OPNFV community award for collaboration, and has been actively pushing OPEN-O integration with OPNFV. Thanks and Regards, Lingli From: onap-tsc-boun...@lists.onap.org [mailto:onap-tsc-boun...@lists.onap.org] On Behalf Of Phil Robb Sent: 2017年4月29日 6:49 To: onap-tsc@lists.onap.org Subject: [onap-tsc] [ONAP TSC VICE-CHAIRPERSON ELECTION] Kickoff of the ONAP TSC Vice-Chairperson Election Hello ONAP TSC Members: Please consider this email as the kickoff of the ONAP TSC Vice-Chair Election process. There are two phases to the election process. The first is the Nomination Phase where TSC Members may nominate themselves for the position of TSC Vice-Chairperson. Once the Nomination Phase has concluded, we will enter the Election Phase, where all ONAP TSC Members are invited and encouraged to vote on the candidates whom have been nominated. Timing: * Nominations open April 28th, 2017. * Nominations close May 2nd at 9:00pm Pacific Time * Voting begins May 3rd, 2017 * Voting Ends May 5th, 2017 at 9:00pm Pacific Time If you are an ONAP TSC member and wish to nominate yourself for the position of TSC Vice-Chairperson, please respond-all to this email with your picture (headshot), biography, and statement of interest on why you would wish to be the TSC Vice-Chairperson. I wlll post this information to the wiki prior to the start of the election so that everyone in the technical community is able to become familiar with the candidates. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. Best, Phil. -- Phil Robb Executive Director, OpenDaylight Project VP Operations - Networking & Orchestration, The Linux Foundation (O) 970-229-5949 (M) 970-420-4292 Skype: Phil.Robb ___ ONAP-TSC mailing list ONAP-TSC@lists.onap.org https://lists.onap.org/mailman/listinfo/onap-tsc
[onap-tsc] TSC Charter
Dear TSC, For your reference, here is the TSC Charter we approved yesterday. The team and I made the updates we discussed in the meeting and cleaned up the formatting. We have asked LF to post a copy of this to the website. Chris -- next part -- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: <http://lists.onap.org/pipermail/onap-tsc/attachments/20170428/f3a71d47/attachment-0001.html> -- next part -- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: ONAP TSC Charter APPROVED 7 1 CLEAN.pdf Type: application/pdf Size: 672442 bytes Desc: ONAP TSC Charter APPROVED 7 1 CLEAN.pdf URL: <http://lists.onap.org/pipermail/onap-tsc/attachments/20170428/f3a71d47/attachment-0001.pdf>
